Courts Cannot Rush Pre-Trial Before the Pleadings Are Complete

Pre-trial cannot be held before pleadings are complete. A pending bill of particulars on a counterclaim can make sanctions for non-appearance improper. Litigants should not be penalized for missing a pre-trial that was set too early. When a counterclaim remains unanswered because a pending motion for bill of particulars has not yet been resolved, the […]

When Shareholder Settlements Do Not Kill Corporate Fraud Claims

A shareholder settlement did not waive claims against non-settling directors, and courts may review stock issuances alleged to oppress minority shareholders. Corporate insiders cannot defeat a shareholder challenge simply by pointing to a partial settlement with other defendants or by calling a contested stock issuance a matter of internal management. Where the transaction allegedly injures […]

When a Missed Pre-Trial Cannot End Your Case: Why Courts Must Notify the Party, Not Just the Lawyer

A missed pre-trial cannot justify default and execution when the party was not personally notified, protecting litigants from defective judgments. A litigant cannot be punished with default, judgment, and execution after a missed pre-trial when the court failed to give the required notice to the party himself, especially where counsel was no longer effectively protecting […]

Rent Control Can Stop Ejectment Even When the Lease Has Expired

Rent-control legislation may suspend ejectment based on lease expiration, and police power can override ordinary contract remedies in housing disputes. Landlords cannot use an expired lease term alone to eject residential occupants when rent-control legislation has suspended that very ground for ejectment. In Gutierrez v. Cantada, the controlling lesson is a police-power doctrine with direct […]

Loss of Confidence Is Not a Shortcut to Fire Employees Without Proof

Employers cannot dismiss ordinary employees on vague loss-of-confidence grounds; Central Textile required proof, due process, and reinstatement when theft was unproven. An employer cannot convert an unproven accusation of theft into a lawful dismissal by calling it loss of confidence. For ordinary employees, security of tenure means that livelihood cannot be taken away on suspicion, […]

When Broken Railroad Crossing Signals Make the Operator Liable for Lifetime Injury Damages

Railroad operators may be liable for crashes at ungarded crossings when warning devices fail, allowing recovery of medical costs, lost income, moral damages, and fees. Railroad operators may be held liable when they allow trains to pass through a public crossing without working warning devices, without an assigned guard, and without adequate audible warnings, especially […]

Late Land Title Filings Can Still Survive When Congress Extends the Deadline

Late land registration filings may survive when Congress extends the deadline, but applicants must still prove possession, tax payment, and land qualification. Property owners who filed for judicial confirmation after an old statutory deadline were not automatically out of court when Congress later extended the period for land registration. In Director of Lands v. Abairo, […]