When a Government Corporation Acts Like a Business, It Can Be Sued Like One

Government corporations may be sued when acting commercially. The Supreme Court allowed a damages case against PNR for alleged common carrier negligence. Government ownership does not automatically shield a corporation from lawsuits. When the State chooses to operate through a corporation engaged in commercial or proprietary activity, that entity may be treated like a private […]

Tax Deficiency Assessments Based on False Returns Can Survive Prescription Challenges

False or underdeclared tax returns may extend BIR assessment periods, and taxpayers must contest assessments in the proper forum before deadlines lapse. Taxpayers who underdeclare income in a way that makes their return false cannot rely on the ordinary prescriptive period to defeat a deficiency tax assessment. Basa v. Republic reinforces a practical rule in […]

A Land Awardee Can Fight Registration Even Before a Title Is Issued

A government land awardee may oppose another person’s title registration over the same property, even before final issuance of a Torrens title. A person who has already been awarded public land under a government sales application has enough legal interest to oppose another person’s attempt to register the same land. The practical lesson is direct: […]

When Eyewitness Identification Defeats an Alibi in a Murder Case

Positive eyewitness identification defeated alibi in a murder appeal, with the Court upholding conviction despite minor inconsistencies and procedural objections. A person accused of murder cannot rely on alibi when eyewitnesses place him at the scene, know him personally, and describe his participation in the attack with enough clarity to leave no reasonable doubt. For […]

When a Lost Land Title Does Not Automatically Make the Seller Pay

A buyer who loses land after title cancellation cannot enforce seller warranty unless the seller was formally summoned into the eviction case. A buyer who loses land because someone else had a better registered title cannot automatically recover from the seller under a warranty against eviction unless the seller was formally brought into the earlier […]

Corporate Control Disputes Belong Before the Corporate Regulator, Not the Trial Court

Corporate control disputes cannot be disguised as ordinary rescission suits; jurisdiction follows the substance of the shareholder and management controversy. A lawsuit framed as rescission, damages, or injunction may still be an intra-corporate controversy when its real object is to recover control, management, board seats, or shareholder power in a corporation. For shareholders, banks, investors, […]