Final Judgments Stay Final: When Judges Can Be Disciplined for Ignoring Res Judicata

A judge was disciplined for disregarding res judicata and deciding a later property case contrary to a final judgment involving the same parties and land. A judge who reopens issues already settled by a final judgment may face administrative discipline, even if the losing party believes the later ruling was merely an error in judgment. […]

When Barangay Conciliation Is Not Required Before Filing a Property Case

Barangay conciliation is not required when the Lupon lacks authority. A judge was fined for dismissing a property case despite clear territorial limits. Courts may not dismiss a lawsuit for failure to undergo barangay conciliation when the barangay justice system had no legal authority over the dispute in the first place. For property owners and […]

Tax Returns Are Not Always Required to Prove Lost Income Damages

Tax returns do not automatically control lost income claims. The Court allowed plantation damages proven by inspection and valuation despite absent tax returns. A defendant cannot defeat a lost income or business interruption claim simply by demanding income tax returns when the injury concerns only a specific portion of property or operations. The practical rule […]

Tax Declarations Alone Do Not Prove Land Ownership in the Philippines

Tax declarations and real property tax receipts support land claims, but they do not conclusively prove ownership without actual legal possession. Paying real property taxes and holding tax declarations can help support a land claim, but they do not, by themselves, make a person the owner. The controlling doctrine from Cequena v. Bolante is practical […]

Judges Cannot Jail Lawyers for Missing a Hearing Without Due Process

A missed hearing is not direct contempt. The Supreme Court disciplined a judge for jailing a lawyer without the due process required for indirect contempt. A lawyer, party, or witness who misses a court hearing cannot be summarily jailed for direct contempt unless the conduct occurs in or near the court and immediately obstructs the […]