Courts Must Put Orders in Writing: Why Margin Notes Are Not Enough in Criminal Cases

Court rulings on motions must be formally recorded. The judge was reprimanded for using a margin note but cleared on arraignment, counsel, and contempt issues. People facing criminal charges are entitled to more than informal courtroom instructions, handwritten margin notes, or verbal explanations from court staff. When a court grants or denies a motion, especially […]

When Your Lawyer Takes Your Case, Silence and Delay Can Become Misconduct

A lawyer who accepts a case must act with fidelity and diligence. Refunding the fee may mitigate, but does not erase neglect or professional responsibility. A lawyer who accepts a client’s case cannot later avoid responsibility by saying the engagement was unclear, informal, or dependent on documents the client supposedly failed to provide. Once counsel […]

When Court Delay Becomes Judicial Misconduct: The Three-Month Decision Rule for Pending Cases

Trial judges must decide submitted cases within three months; missing transcripts, transferred staff, and workload do not excuse unreasonable delay. Parties who submit a case for decision are not expected to wait indefinitely: trial judges must decide lower court cases within the constitutional three-month period, and delay may result in administrative liability even when the […]

Lost Court Records Can Trigger Discipline, Even Without Proof of Bad Faith

Lost criminal case records can make a clerk of court administratively liable for neglect of duty, even without proof of bad faith, though penalties depend on context. Court users are entitled to expect that their case records will not simply disappear. When a clerk of court fails to safely keep criminal case records under her […]

Sheriff’s Fees Must Be Court-Approved: What Judgment Winners Should Know Before Paying for Execution

Sheriffs must follow court-approved procedures for execution expenses and timely returns; bypassing those safeguards may constitute dereliction of duty. A winning judgment does not give a sheriff a free hand to collect money directly from the prevailing party. Execution expenses must follow the procedure fixed by the Rules of Court: they must be estimated, approved […]

A Judge Cannot Freeze Property Rights by Rushed Ex Parte TRO Without Real Urgency

A judge may be disciplined for issuing a 20-day ex parte TRO without true urgency, notice, or summary hearing, especially when property rights are affected. A temporary restraining order obtained without notice is not a shortcut for taking control of property. It is an extraordinary remedy available only in cases of genuine, immediate, and irreparable […]

Tax Declarations Can Support Possession, But They Cannot Win a Land Ownership Case Alone

Tax declarations and real property tax payments may support possession, but they do not alone prove ownership in a land recovery case. Paying real property tax and holding tax declarations may help show possession, but they do not, by themselves, prove ownership of land. A claimant who wants a court to recover ownership must still […]