When a Judge Sits on Your Case Too Long, Delay Itself Can Be Misconduct

Judges may be disciplined for unjustified delay in deciding submitted cases, even without proof of bias, if the delay violates speedy disposition rules. Litigants who wait months or years for a decision are not powerless: a judge’s unjustified failure to decide a submitted case within the required period can itself be an administrative offense, even […]

Tax Declarations Can Help Prove Ownership When Possession and History Support Them

Tax declarations do not prove ownership alone, but with possession, sale, and improvements, they can help defeat a free patent over private land. Property owners who consistently declare land for taxation, possess it openly, and can trace how they acquired it may use those tax records as meaningful evidence of ownership, even though tax declarations […]

Court Employees Can Be Fined for Office Misconduct Even When No One Is Injured

Court personnel may be fined for misconduct inside court premises when their actions disrupt order, endanger others, or degrade judicial dignity. Judicial personnel can face administrative liability for conduct that disrupts court discipline, degrades the dignity of the judiciary, or endangers people inside court premises, even when the incident is treated as a first offense […]

When Weak Proof of Age Saves an Accused From the Death Penalty but Not From Conviction

Rape conviction affirmed but death penalty reduced because the prosecution failed to prove the victim’s age with competent evidence. A rape conviction can be affirmed even when the prosecution fails to prove every fact needed for the highest penalty. In People v. Corial, the Court held that the victim’s direct and credible testimony was enough […]

When Testimony Uses Conclusions Instead of Facts, Conviction Cannot Stand

Rape convictions require factual proof of carnal knowledge, not bare conclusions. The Court acquitted where testimony and medical findings left reasonable doubt. Criminal conviction cannot rest on a complainant’s conclusion that she was “raped” unless the testimony, taken with the rest of the evidence, proves the concrete facts that constitute the crime beyond reasonable doubt. […]

When a Victim Has Intellectual Disability, Credible Testimony Can Still Prove Rape

The Supreme Court affirmed a rape conviction based on credible testimony from a victim with intellectual disability, rejecting alibi and modifying damages. A rape conviction may rest on the coherent testimony of a victim with intellectual disability when the trial court finds her competent to perceive, remember, and narrate what happened, and when her account […]

Corporate Stock Deals: When a President’s Letter Can Bind the Company

A corporation may be bound by its president’s stock sale letter when apparent authority exists, but attorney’s fees still require clear legal basis. A corporation may be bound by a president’s post-closing letter in a stock purchase dispute when the company’s own conduct gave that officer apparent authority to complete acts connected with the transaction. […]

Electric Cooperatives Can Lose Local Tax Exemptions Without Violating the Constitution

Electric cooperatives under P.D. 269 may lose local tax exemptions when Congress validly withdraws them; no equal protection or contract impairment violation was found. Tax exemptions granted to electric cooperatives are not permanent shields against later legislation: when Congress validly narrows or withdraws an exemption, a cooperative cannot defeat local taxation simply by invoking equal […]

Income Tax Returns Can Help Prove Lost Earning Capacity in Criminal Cases

Income tax returns may prove lost earning capacity in death cases, helping heirs recover damages when income is properly documented. Families seeking damages after a wrongful death may recover more than burial expenses and moral damages when they can prove the victim’s earning capacity through competent evidence, including income tax returns. People v. Caratao is […]