When the Charge Is Defective, the Penalty Cannot Be Upgraded After Trial

The Supreme Court affirmed murder and rape convictions but reduced penalties where homicide was not alleged in the rape information. A criminal conviction may stand even when the accused’s defense fails, but the penalty cannot be increased for a graver crime unless the charging document itself alleges the facts that make that graver crime punishable. […]

Schools Seeking Real Property Tax Exemption Must First Appeal to Tax Boards, Not Rush to Court

Schools claiming real property tax exemption must first appeal assessor actions to tax boards before seeking court relief through mandamus. A private school that wants a real property tax exemption cannot usually force the city assessor through mandamus or go straight to court simply by invoking educational use. When the dispute involves whether land is […]

A Child’s Clear Testimony Can Convict Even When the Accused Is Her Own Father

The Court affirmed a father’s rape conviction, holding that a child victim’s clear and credible testimony can overcome denial and prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A rape conviction may rest on the testimony of a child victim when her account is straightforward, candid, and credible, even if the accused argues that poor lighting, family pressure, […]

When Age Is Not Properly Proved, Rape Conviction May Stand but the Penalty Can Change

A rape conviction may stand on credible testimony, but statutory rape and harsher penalties require proper proof of the victim’s age. A rape conviction can survive even when the prosecution fails to prove the victim’s exact age, but the highest penalty cannot be imposed unless the qualifying facts are properly alleged and proven. For accused […]

A Guilty Plea Is Not Enough in Death Penalty Cases: Why Courts Must Still Hear Evidence

A guilty plea in a capital case cannot support conviction alone; courts must conduct a searching inquiry and require prosecution evidence before judgment. An accused person who pleads guilty to a capital offense cannot be convicted on that plea alone. In the most serious criminal cases, the court must still conduct a searching inquiry, require […]

A Rape Conviction Can Stand on the Victim’s Testimony Alone — But Death Penalty Allegations Must Be Strictly Proved

Credible victim testimony may sustain rape conviction, but death-penalty facts like age and relationship must be strictly alleged and proven. A person accused of rape may be convicted on the credible testimony of the victim alone, even without medical findings of physical resistance, but aggravating facts that increase the penalty must be alleged and proven […]

Delayed Reporting Does Not Defeat a Rape Case When Fear Explains the Silence

Delayed reporting does not defeat a rape case when fear, threats, and circumstances explain the silence; conviction and damages were affirmed. A rape victim’s delay in reporting the assault does not automatically destroy her credibility when the silence is reasonably explained by fear, threats, shame, isolation, or the victim’s vulnerable circumstances. For accused persons, complainants, […]

When a Victim’s Clear Testimony Is Enough to Convict Despite Delay, Family Ties, and Denial

The Court upheld a rape conviction based on credible victim testimony, ruling that delay, minor inconsistencies, denial, and unproven impotence did not defeat the case. A rape conviction may stand even without perfect recollection, immediate reporting, or physical evidence of force, when the trial court finds the victim’s testimony clear, credible, and consistent on the […]