Bad Checks Can Get a Lawyer Suspended: The Private-Debt Misconduct Rule

Private loans and bouncing checks can become lawyer misconduct. The Court suspended a lawyer for gross misconduct but refused to award repayment in discipline. A lawyer who borrows money, issues unfunded checks, and refuses to answer disciplinary proceedings may be suspended from practice even when the transaction was purely private. The doctrine is simple but […]

Senior Citizen Discounts Are a Police Power Burden, Not a Tax Refund Right

Businesses must honor senior citizen discounts; the Supreme Court upheld tax deduction treatment as police power, not a compensable taking. Businesses required to give the 20% senior citizen discount cannot demand peso-for-peso reimbursement from the government merely because the discount reduces revenue. The Supreme Court treated the mandatory discount and its tax deduction treatment as […]

A Disbarment Complaint Cannot Substitute for Trial When the Real Fight Is Over Facts

Disbarment cannot replace trial when alleged lawyer dishonesty depends on unresolved civil or criminal facts, but lawyers may still be reprimanded for ignoring court orders. Clients who believe an opposing lawyer used false statements, questionable documents, or baseless pleadings cannot always win disbarment by proving that the underlying litigation is bitter or fact-heavy. When the […]

When a Lawyer’s Neglect Kills a Labor Case, Discipline Is Possible—but Damages Need a Separate Remedy

A lawyer may be suspended for neglecting a labor case and lying about representation, but clients seeking lost settlement money need a separate civil remedy. Lawyers who allow a client’s labor case to be dismissed through missed mandatory conferences or neglected filings may be disciplined even years later, but the disciplinary case will not automatically […]