RMC No. 3-2022: Separate Assessment Notices and Payment Forms Required for BIR Compromise Penalties

RMC No. 3-2022 requires BIR compromise penalties to be separated from deficiency tax, surcharge, and interest in assessment notices and BIR Form 0605. Taxpayers facing BIR audits must now check whether any compromise penalty is being presented separately from deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest. RMC No. 3-2022 clarifies that compromise penalties should not be […]

When an Irregular Government Loan Is Not Automatically Graft

Irregular LGU loan transactions are not automatically graft; prosecutors must prove gross and manifest disadvantage beyond reasonable doubt. Public officers are not guilty of graft merely because a government loan transaction was irregular, poorly documented, or later criticized as financially risky. To convict under the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act for entering into a contract […]

When a Private Person Can Be Dropped from a Graft Case for Lack of Conspiracy

Private persons cannot be tried for graft without probable cause of conspiracy with public officers; tax and corporate records helped defeat the charge. A private individual cannot be forced to stand trial for graft merely because prosecutors suspect ownership, influence, or benefit from a questioned government transaction. When the charge is violation of Section 3(e) […]

Banks Can Deduct Common Expenses Without BIR-Imposed Allocation Rules

The Supreme Court voided RR 4-2011, holding that the BIR cannot impose expense allocation rules or curtail deductions without clear Tax Code authority. Banks and financial institutions cannot be forced by revenue regulation to reduce their deductible business expenses through an allocation formula that Congress did not authorize. The Supreme Court’s ruling protects taxpayers from […]

Constructive Delivery of Land: When Sale Documents Prove Ownership

Constructive delivery can transfer land ownership when deeds, survey, possession, and conduct prove a completed real property sale. Constructive delivery of land can transfer ownership even when the buyer never personally occupies the property, so long as the parties’ documents, conduct, possession arrangement, and payment show that the land was already placed under the buyer’s […]

Tax Regulation Ultra Vires Rule: When BIR Rules Go Too Far

BIR tax rules are void when they expand the Tax Code, restrict deductions, or impose accounting methods without legal basis. Taxpayers may challenge a revenue regulation when the BIR or Department of Finance uses rulemaking to impose burdens that Congress itself did not authorize. The Tax Regulation Ultra Vires Rule confirms that administrative agencies may […]