Security Guards Must Keep Their Address Updated Before Claiming Constructive Dismissal

Security guards must prove employer-caused dismissal; failed notices due to an outdated address may defeat constructive dismissal claims. A security guard who stops receiving assignments cannot automatically claim constructive dismissal when the employer sent return-to-work orders to the address he himself provided and the notices failed only because he had moved without leaving a forwarding […]

When a Bad Deal Is Also Illegal: Why Courts May Refuse to Return Money Paid for Public Office

Supreme Court acquits one estafa accused, affirms anotherโ€™s conviction, but bars recovery of money paid for an illegal party-list seat deal. Money paid for an unlawful promise to secure public office may not be recoverable in court, even when the transaction also involved deceit. In Morales, the Supreme Court acquitted one accused for lack of […]

A Seafarerโ€™s Disability Case Can Be Sent Back to the NLRC When the CBA Arbitration Clause Is Not Proven

A seafarer disability claim returns to the NLRC because the CBA arbitration procedure was not proven, clarifying forum rules in maritime labor disputes. A seafarer cannot force a disability benefits case into voluntary arbitration merely by showing that a collective bargaining agreement exists; the worker must also prove that the agreement clearly sends that type […]

Foreign Investment Questions Must Go Through the SEC Before Reaching Court

The Supreme Court ruled that companies cannot seek court pre-clearance for vague foreign investment plans without a ripe controversy and prior SEC process. Companies cannot ask courts to pre-clear a possible foreign investment based only on a vague future transaction. When a business wants to know whether foreign ownership limits apply, it must first present […]

COMELEC Cannot Let Election Overspending Cases Sleep for Six Years

COMELEC cannot delay election overspending investigations for six years; failure to file a counter-affidavit does not suspend speedy disposition rights. Election-offense investigations cannot be left unresolved for years simply because the respondent failed to file a counter-affidavit. When the COMELEC sits on a campaign overspending complaint far beyond its own procedural deadlines, and offers no […]

Seafarers Must Receive a Clear Final Medical Assessment Before Disability Benefits Can Be Cut Off

A vague or undisclosed company medical assessment cannot defeat a seafarerโ€™s claim; disability may become total and permanent by operation of law. A seafarerโ€™s disability claim cannot be defeated by a vague, unexplained, or undisclosed company medical report. When the company-designated physician fails to give a final, definite, and properly explained assessment within the legally […]

RMC No. 80-2025: Lost BIR Form No. 0535 Taxpayer Information Sheets and Verification Steps for RDO 27 Transactions

RMC No. 80-2025 identifies sixty lost triplicate copies of BIR Form No. 0535 and urges verification of affected taxpayer information sheet transactions. Businesses and taxpayers dealing with Revenue District Office No. 27 under Revenue Region No. 5 in Caloocan City should immediately verify any transaction involving the identified BIR Form No. 0535 Taxpayer Information Sheet […]

Drug Charges Can Fail When Police Skip Mandatory Inventory Witnesses

Supreme Court acquits drug-sale accused after police failed to justify missing inventory witnesses and chain-of-custody deviations under RA 9165. A person accused in a drug sale case cannot be convicted on the strength of a buy-bust story alone when the prosecution fails to prove that the seized drug was preserved through a lawful, documented, and […]

Property Owners Cannot Evict Occupants by Simply Saying Their Stay Was Tolerated

Title alone did not justify ejectment; owners must prove occupants entered by tolerance before using unlawful detainer to recover possession. A registered landowner who wants to remove long-time occupants through an unlawful detainer case must prove that the occupants entered the property by permission or tolerance from the very beginning. A land title may support […]

Online Lenders Cannot Save Data Privacy Cases by Objecting Too Late

Borrowers may rely on screenshots in NPC cases when lenders fail to timely object; late authentication challenges can be waived on appeal. Parties in National Privacy Commission proceedings must raise evidentiary objections at the earliest opportunity, or they risk losing them completely. For borrowers, this ruling matters because an online lender accused of shaming a […]