Resignation Does Not Erase Administrative Liability: Court Employees Can Still Lose Benefits After Leaving Service

The Supreme Court held that resignation does not erase administrative liability once proceedings begin, allowing benefit forfeiture, disqualification, and fines. Public employees cannot avoid administrative accountability by resigning, going AWOL, or being dropped from the rolls after a disciplinary case has already begun. In this ruling, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that once jurisdiction attaches, the […]

When Government Extensions Defeat Criminal Liability: Why Courts Must Notice Official Agency Acts

The Supreme Court acquitted a firearm owner after recognizing a PNP license extension as an official act courts must judicially notice. Courts cannot ignore official government acts when a person’s liberty turns on them. In Ponce De Leon, the Supreme Court acquitted an accused firearm owner because the government itself had extended the validity of […]

BIR Tax Assessments Must Explain the Facts, Not Just Show the Numbers

The Supreme Court voided BIR assessments that listed computations without sufficient factual and legal bases, allowing challenge despite missed protest deadlines. A taxpayer may still attack a BIR assessment as void even after missing the usual protest deadline if the assessment itself failed to state the specific factual and legal bases required by law. The […]

A Pending Criminal Case Does Not Automatically Block a Bar Passer From Becoming a Lawyer

A pending criminal case does not automatically block a Bar passer from oath-taking; the Supreme Court required case-specific review and upheld innocence. A person who has passed the Bar may not be treated as morally unfit merely because a criminal charge is still pending. In this ruling, the Supreme Court held that the presumption of […]

A Creditor Cannot Use Execution to Take Property Worth Far More Than the Debt

The Supreme Court voided an excessive execution sale, restored Winluck’s title, and barred a creditor from taking property far beyond the debt. Creditors who win a money claim cannot turn execution into a windfall. When a sheriff levies and sells property grossly disproportionate to the judgment debt, especially where the property belongs to a non-party […]

Corporate Records, Hidden Revenues, and Shareholder Damages: When Poor Accounting Becomes Legal Exposure

Minority shareholders denied corporate records may recover damages when hidden books reveal fraud, related-party abuse, and misuse of corporate entities. Minority shareholders who are shut out from corporate records are not limited to asking for access to the books. When the refusal to disclose records reveals deeper fraud, diverted revenues, conflicted management, and the misuse […]

Schools Can Lose Tax Exemption Without Proof of Educational Use

Schools may exempt lease and canteen income only with proof of actual, direct, and exclusive educational use; status alone is insufficient. Non-stock, non-profit schools may be exempt from income tax, VAT, and local business taxes even on income from canteens, leases, and other non-classroom activities, but only if they can prove that the specific revenue […]

False Travel Liquidations Can Become Criminal Cases, Even When the Amount Is Small

False travel liquidation documents can support falsification and graft convictions even for small per diem overpayments, though clemency may be recommended. Government personnel who liquidate official travel expenses must tell the truth about actual travel dates, not merely repeat the dates written in a travel order. A false itinerary or certificate of travel completed may […]

When Police May Search a Courier Package Without a Warrant in Drug Cases

A courier package drug conviction was upheld after the Court found valid hot pursuit arrest, consented search, urgency, and preserved chain of custody. A person who receives a suspicious courier package may be arrested and searched without a warrant when law enforcers have immediate, personally verified facts showing that the package likely contains dangerous drugs, […]

Child Sex Trafficking Convictions Can Stand on Victim Testimony When Identity, Exploitation, and Minority Are Proven

Supreme Court affirms qualified trafficking convictions, holding that minors cannot consent to sexual exploitation and credible victim testimony may prove guilt. Trafficking victims who are minors do not need to prove that they physically resisted, escaped, or withheld consent before a conviction may stand. When the prosecution proves that children were recruited, received, transferred, or […]