Refund Claims Can Survive Reconsideration When the Tax Authority Merely Repeats Rejected Arguments

Refund of EWT penalties stood after the tax authority’s motion merely repeated rejected arguments, reinforcing record-based refund litigation. Taxpayers seeking refunds of penalties, surcharges, and interest gain an important litigation lesson from this resolution: once the Court of Tax Appeals has already resolved the evidentiary and legal issues, a motion for reconsideration that merely repeats […]

Tax Refund Claims Can Survive Fast Court Filings When the Two-Year Deadline Is Met

A taxpayer’s ₱152.5M refund survived despite a quick court filing after the administrative claim because both claims were filed within the two-year period. Taxpayers seeking a refund or tax credit for erroneously paid withholding VAT and final withholding tax should not assume that a quick judicial filing automatically defeats their claim. Where both the administrative […]

Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When the BIR Issues the Final Demand Too Early

A tax assessment for 2009 deficiency income tax and VAT was voided because the BIR issued the final demand before the 15-day PAN reply period expired. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax or VAT assessments should carefully check the assessment timeline, because a final demand issued before the taxpayer’s 15-day period to answer the preliminary assessment […]

Taxpayers Can Preserve Assessment Victories When Reconsideration Merely Rehashes Old Arguments

A taxpayer preserved its win after the tax court denied reconsideration of cancelled deficiency income tax, VAT, withholding tax, DST, and penalties. Taxpayers who secure the cancellation of a deficiency tax assessment should treat the government’s motion for reconsideration as another litigation stage, not as an automatic reopening of the case. Where the motion merely […]

Missed Electronic Filing Can End Customs Criminal Cases Before They Begin

A customs criminal case was terminated after prosecutors missed the 24-hour PDF filing rule; heavy workload did not justify reconsideration. Prosecutors, importers, brokers, and companies facing customs enforcement should treat the Court of Tax Appeals’ electronic filing rules as jurisdiction-critical litigation requirements: a paper-filed criminal information may be deemed not filed if the required PDF […]

Past-Dated Payment Deadlines Can Void BIR Deficiency Tax Assessments

Past-dated payment deadlines voided a BIR deficiency tax assessment, with the CTA cancelling P849.14M in alleged 2014 tax liabilities. Taxpayers receiving a Formal Letter of Demand, Final Assessment Notice, or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment should immediately check whether the payment deadline is real, definite, and prospective. A demand for payment that uses a due […]

VAT Refund Claims for Imported Exempt Medicines Need Proof the Input VAT Was Not Used

Medicine importers must prove VAT paid on exempt importations was not claimed as input tax credit, or their refund claim may be denied. Importers claiming a refund or tax credit for VAT paid on VAT-exempt medicines must be ready to prove, through traceable VAT returns, ledgers, and reconciliations, that the same VAT was not already […]