Employers cannot automatically dismiss workers on a union’s request; due process remains required, with reinstatement and backwages for bad-faith termination.

Employers cannot hide behind a union request or a maintenance-of-membership clause to dismiss workers without first giving them a fair chance to be heard. When management acts hastily, ignores the circumstances behind a union expulsion, and terminates employees without inquiry, the dismissal may be treated as bad faith, exposing both the company and the union to liability for reinstatement and backwages.

Why This Ruling Matters to Employers and Unionized Workers

Union security clauses are common in collective bargaining agreements. They are designed to preserve union membership, prevent free riders, and strengthen collective bargaining. But Liberty Cotton Mills Workers Union teaches a critical limit: a union security clause is not a license for automatic termination. Even where the agreement says that employees expelled by the union may be dismissed upon written request, the employer must still act with fairness, prudence, and respect for the worker’s right to labor.

For HR managers and business owners, the case is a warning against treating union letters as self-executing termination orders. For employees, it confirms that losing union membership does not automatically mean losing employment without due process. The employer’s power to dismiss remains subject to constitutional and statutory protection of labor.

Background: Disaffiliation, Expulsion, and Immediate Dismissal

The dispute arose after members of the Liberty Cotton Mills Workers Union disaffiliated from PAFLU, the mother federation. The local union members were reportedly dissatisfied with PAFLU’s handling of their concerns, including its negotiation of the collective bargaining agreement and its alleged lack of concern for the local union’s problems. PAFLU later treated the disaffiliation as disloyalty and requested the company to dismiss the affected workers under the maintenance-of-membership provision of the collective bargaining agreement.

The company acted quickly. After receiving PAFLU’s request, it terminated the workers without first hearing them, without asking them or PAFLU about the real reasons for the expulsion, and without independently examining whether the union’s accusation of disloyalty was justified. The workers sought reconsideration of the earlier decision in Liberty Cotton Mills Workers Union v. Liberty Cotton Mills, Inc. (G.R. No. L-33987), asking for reinstatement and fuller backwages.

The Doctrine: A Union Security Clause Does Not Cancel Due Process

The Supreme Court recognized that dismissal is generally a management prerogative, but emphasized that the power is not unlimited. Employers must exercise it in a manner consistent with workers’ rights, especially because termination affects not only the employee’s position but also the employee’s livelihood.

The Court found that the company acted in bad faith when it dismissed the workers hastily and summarily. The company did not merely comply with a neutral contractual obligation. It disregarded the workers’ right to be heard, accepted PAFLU’s request at face value, and failed to investigate whether the expulsions were justified. The Court treated this conduct as more than procedural error; it supported the conclusion that there was conspiracy or connivance between the company and PAFLU in the dismissal of the workers.

The ruling is especially important because the employees were not expelled for conduct that was clearly harmful to the employer. The Court noted that their disaffiliation appeared to arise from dissatisfaction with PAFLU, not from true disloyalty. In other words, the employees’ exercise of freedom of association could not be converted into a ground for dismissal without careful scrutiny.

Why the Company and the Union Were Both Held Liable

The Court held the company and PAFLU jointly and severally liable for the workers’ backwages. This is the most practical consequence of the ruling: when a union wrongfully seeks a worker’s dismissal and the employer blindly implements it, both may be made answerable.

The Court reasoned that the company had its own duty to protect the workers’ right to due process. It could not escape liability by saying that it merely followed PAFLU’s written request. At the same time, PAFLU was not excused because it pushed for dismissal based on an erroneous view that the workers’ disaffiliation was disloyalty. The Court also ordered PAFLU to reimburse Liberty Cotton Mills for amounts the company would pay to the workers as backwages.

The Remedy: Reinstatement, Seniority, Benefits, and Three Years Backwages

The Supreme Court amended the earlier decision and ordered the company to immediately reinstate the complainant workers. The reinstatement had to be without loss of seniority and other privileges, and the workers were to be restored to the same or similar positions as if they had not been wrongfully dismissed.

The Court also imposed a practical enforcement consequence. If the company failed to reinstate the workers within thirty days from notice of the decision, it would be liable for wages at current rates after the expiration of that period. The Court further sentenced both the company and PAFLU to pay the workers the equivalent of three years of backwages at the rates actually received by them before dismissal, without deduction or qualification.

The Court rejected the request for more than three years of backwages or at least fifty percent for two years. It applied the established formula fixing backwages at three years without deduction or qualification. This approach was meant to avoid prolonged disputes over what employees earned or could have earned during the layoff period, while also preventing employers from delaying satisfaction of awards.

Practical Impact for HR, Management, and Labor Unions

For employers, the lesson is direct: before terminating an employee at the request of a union, management should conduct its own review, notify the employee, allow the employee to explain, and document the basis for any action. A union security clause may create a contractual obligation, but it does not remove the employer’s independent duty to observe fairness.

For unions and federations, the case is equally serious. A union’s disciplinary power must not be used to punish dissent, disaffiliation, or dissatisfaction without valid grounds. If a union wrongfully pressures an employer to terminate workers, it may share monetary liability for the illegal dismissal.

For workers, the ruling confirms that employment protection and freedom of association remain meaningful even in a unionized workplace. Workers may challenge dismissals that appear to be the product of internal union politics, retaliation, or automatic implementation of a union request without a hearing.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, unions, and employees in labor disputes involving union security clauses, collective bargaining agreements, illegal dismissal, reinstatement, backwages, and NLRC litigation. If your company received a union request to terminate an employee, or if you were dismissed because of union expulsion or disaffiliation, our labor litigation team can help assess the legal risks, prepare the proper notices and defenses, and represent you before labor tribunals and courts. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our labor and litigation lawyers in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *