Fuel suppliers may recover excise tax on Jet A-1 fuel sold to international carriers, but refund claims still depend on strict proof of qualifying sales.

Petroleum suppliers that paid excise tax on Jet A-1 fuel sold to international air carriers may recover the tax through refund or tax credit when they can prove that the fuel was sold to qualified international carriers and used or consumed outside the Philippines. For fuel suppliers, aviation companies, and tax teams handling excise tax refund claims, the ruling reinforces both sides of the refund equation: the right to recover erroneously paid excise tax exists, but the evidentiary burden remains strict.

Background of the Refund Dispute

The taxpayer sought a refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate for excise taxes paid on Jet A-1 fuel sold to international air carriers. The fuel was allegedly sold for use or consumption outside the Philippines during the relevant period. In its earlier decision, the Court of Tax Appeals partially granted the refund claim and ordered the Commissioner to refund or issue a tax credit certificate in the amount of P207,765,676.00.

Both sides sought reconsideration. The Commissioner argued that tax refunds are in the nature of tax exemptions and must be strictly construed against the claimant. The Commissioner also maintained that the exemption under Section 135 of the National Internal Revenue Code belonged to the buyer-air carriers, not to the petroleum supplier. The taxpayer, in turn, sought partial reconsideration of the disallowed portion of its claim, particularly items affected by the absence of signed Mandaue Official Register Books and Foreign Air Carrier Permits for certain airlines (CTA Case No. 10611).

The Court Sustained the Supplier’s Right to Claim the Excise Tax Refund

The Court rejected the Commissioner’s position and reaffirmed that the supplier was entitled to claim a refund under Section 135 of the NIRC, as amended. The Court emphasized that the exemption for petroleum products sold to international carriers is an impersonal tax exemption. In practical terms, the exemption attaches to the petroleum products, not merely to the identity of the buyer as a person.

This distinction matters because excise tax is imposed on the goods or articles themselves. The statutory taxpayer is generally the manufacturer or importer that paid the excise tax. While the international carrier may ultimately bear the economic burden if the tax is passed on in the selling price, the carrier is not necessarily the statutory taxpayer that paid the tax to the government. Thus, once the petroleum products are confirmed to have been sold to qualified international carriers for covered use, the excise tax previously paid on those products may be treated as erroneously or illegally collected and may be recovered by the supplier, subject to compliance with refund requirements.

CREATE MORE Confirmed the Refund Mechanism, But Did Not Control the Case

The Court also discussed the introduction of Section 135-A under Republic Act No. 12066, or CREATE MORE. That provision expressly recognizes that suppliers who paid excise taxes on otherwise exempt sales of petroleum products under Section 135 may seek a refund or credit, provided they comply with the administrative requirements and statutory periods.

The Court clarified that the procedural periods under Section 135-A did not govern the case because CREATE MORE took effect only on November 28, 2024. However, the Court treated the enactment as confirmation that excise taxes paid on Section 135 exempt sales are refundable when the legal and documentary requirements are met. This is significant for current and future refund claims because the statute now expressly provides a refund framework for suppliers.

Why the Court Denied the Commissioner’s Reconsideration

The Commissioner’s motion was denied because the Court found no cogent reason to depart from its earlier ruling. The Court relied on Supreme Court jurisprudence recognizing that sellers of petroleum products to international carriers may seek refunds of excise taxes paid on exempt sales. It also reiterated that the exemption under Section 135 should not be reduced to a mere prohibition against passing on the tax burden to the buyer.

For business readers, the ruling confirms that the government cannot defeat a supplier’s refund claim simply by saying that the exemption belongs only to the international carrier. The more relevant question is whether the petroleum products fall within the exempt class and whether the claimant can prove the statutory and evidentiary elements of the refund claim.

The Taxpayer Still Lost Part of the Claim Because of Documentary Gaps

The taxpayer did not win everything. The Court sustained the disallowance relating to Mandaue Official Register Books that lacked sufficient proof of concurrence by the Revenue Officer On Premise. The taxpayer explained that the original books had been lost because of flooding caused by Typhoon Odette and presented Excel-printed copies. However, the Court held that the testimony presented did not sufficiently establish that the ROOP reviewed, approved, or concurred in the entries reflected in the reproduced records.

The Court stressed that the taxpayer should have presented proof of the ROOP’s concurrence or, at the very least, secured certified true copies of the ORBs from the BIR where the records were officially filed. Without that corroboration, the taxpayer failed to discharge its evidentiary burden for the affected transactions. This is a critical reminder that refund claims before the tax court are document-driven. Even a legally valid theory of refund can fail in whole or in part if the supporting records are incomplete, unsigned, or insufficiently authenticated.

CAAP Certification Was Enough to Prove Foreign Registry of the Airlines

The taxpayer succeeded on another evidentiary issue. The Court reconsidered its earlier disallowance of P2,023,628.00 in excise taxes on sales to airlines without valid Foreign Air Carrier Permits. The Court clarified that an FACP is a regulatory prerequisite for a foreign carrier’s operating rights in the Philippines, but proving operating rights in the Philippines is not one of the statutory requisites for a Section 135 refund.

Instead, the taxpayer needed to prove the foreign registry of the international air carriers or, for Philippine-registered carriers, their authority to operate international flights. The Court found that the CAAP Certification dated February 22, 2022, which confirmed the countries of registration of the relevant international air carriers based on aircraft registration codes reflected in the Aviation Service Returns, was sufficient for that purpose.

Final Refund Amount Increased After Reconsideration

Because the Court reversed the disallowance tied solely to the absence of valid FACPs, it adjusted the refundable amount. The taxpayer’s original claim covered 57,834,665 liters, equivalent to P231,338,660.00 in excise taxes at P4.00 per liter. After deducting disallowed transactions involving sales from TOGRI for September 2019 and January to August 2020, the Court fixed the refundable excise taxes at P209,789,304.00.

The Commissioner was therefore ordered to refund or issue a tax credit certificate in that amount, representing excise taxes paid from August 2019 to January 2020 on Jet A-1 fuel sold to international air carriers for use or consumption outside the Philippines during the period from September 2019 to August 2020.

Practical Takeaways for Petroleum Suppliers and Tax Teams

First, suppliers of petroleum products should not assume that excise tax paid on sales to international carriers is unrecoverable merely because the buyer enjoyed the economic benefit of the exemption. The Court’s reasoning supports the supplier’s standing to claim the refund because the supplier is the party legally liable for the excise tax.

Second, the refund claim must be built around the specific elements required for Section 135 petroleum product sales: proof that the fuel was properly stored and disposed of under applicable rules, proof of the foreign registry of the international air carriers or authority to operate international flights, and proof that the fuel was used or consumed outside the Philippines.

Third, tax teams should preserve and authenticate Official Register Books, Aviation Service Returns, certifications from aviation authorities, and other transaction-level records. Where originals are lost or destroyed, the claimant should be prepared to prove not only the contents of the substitute documents, but also official concurrence or certification where required. Disaster-related loss of records may explain non-production, but it does not automatically satisfy the evidentiary burden.

Finally, taxpayers with pending or future petroleum excise tax refund claims should review the impact of Section 135-A under CREATE MORE. While the provision did not govern this case, it now provides a specific procedural framework for supplier refund claims, including administrative filing, decision periods, reconsideration, and appeal to the Court of Tax Appeals.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, manufacturers, fuel suppliers, and corporate tax departments in evaluating, preparing, and litigating tax refund and tax credit claims before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help assess refund eligibility, organize evidentiary records, prepare administrative claims, respond to denials, and prosecute appeals where the claim is denied or left unresolved.

For companies handling excise tax refund claims, VAT refund claims, customs disputes, or assessments before the Court of Tax Appeals, early legal review can determine whether the claim is properly documented before deadlines expire. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on Philippine tax litigation and refund recovery strategy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *