A borrower obtained a P21.6M DST refund after proving duplicate payment on one bank loan and timely filing both BIR and CTA refund claims.
Businesses that discover a duplicate documentary stamp tax payment on a bank loan must act within the two-year refund period and preserve clear bank, tax return, and remittance records because the Court of Tax Appeals may order a refund where the taxpayer proves that DST was paid twice on the same debt instrument.
Background: The Dispute Over DST Paid on a Bank Loan
The taxpayer, a domestic corporation registered with the BIR, obtained a P2.88 billion loan from a bank under a promissory note executed on December 22, 2020. Because the transaction involved a loan obligation evidenced by a debt instrument, documentary stamp tax became due under the National Internal Revenue Code. Based on the statutory rate for debt instruments, the DST due on the loan was computed at P21.6 million.
The controversy arose because the taxpayer claimed that the same P21.6 million DST was paid twice. First, the bank allegedly deducted the DST from the loan proceeds and remitted it to the BIR through the electronic DST system. Second, the taxpayer separately paid P21.6 million through a BTR-BIR deposit slip and BIR Form No. 2000 stamped received by the collecting bank on January 5, 2021. The taxpayer filed an administrative refund claim on January 4, 2023, followed by a judicial claim the next day (CTA Case No. 11064).
The Taxpayer Won Because the Refund Claim Was Timely Filed
The Commissioner argued that the taxpayer failed to exhaust administrative remedies because the administrative claim was filed only one day before the judicial petition. The Commissioner also questioned the absence of a duly received BIR Form No. 1914 and argued that there was only one payment, not two.
The tax court rejected the prematurity argument. It held that Sections 204(C) and 229 of the NIRC require both the administrative claim and the judicial claim to be filed within two years from payment of the tax. Since the DST was paid or remitted on January 5, 2021, the two-year period expired on January 5, 2023. The taxpayer filed its administrative claim on January 4, 2023 and its judicial claim on January 5, 2023. Both filings therefore fell within the statutory period.
For taxpayers, this is an important litigation point. The court applied the rule that, for refund claims involving erroneously or illegally collected internal revenue taxes, the law requires the administrative claim to precede the judicial claim, but it does not impose a minimum waiting period between them. Where prescription is about to lapse, the taxpayer may proceed to court to protect its right to judicial recourse, provided both claims are timely filed.
A Written Refund Claim Need Not Be Defeated Merely Because of Form Issues
The Commissioner also argued that the taxpayer did not file a valid administrative claim because it allegedly failed to file BIR Form No. 1914. The court clarified that the administrative claim contemplated under Sections 204(C) and 229 refers to a written claim for refund filed with the Commissioner or the Commissioner’s authorized representative. It need not necessarily be in the form of BIR Form No. 1914.
The court found that the taxpayer’s written refund claim, stamped received by the BIR on January 4, 2023, satisfied the requirement that a taxpayer must first file a written administrative claim. The court also noted that the administrative claim itself referred to BIR Form No. 1914 as one of the supporting documents. This portion of the decision is useful for taxpayers because it emphasizes substance over rigid formality, although taxpayers should still submit complete BIR refund forms and supporting documents whenever possible.
Why the Court Found an Erroneous DST Payment
The decisive factual issue was whether the taxpayer proved that DST was paid twice on the same loan. The taxpayer presented the promissory note, disclosure statement, bank passbook, BTR-BIR deposit slip, BIR Form No. 2000, the bank’s electronic DST transaction report, loan or trade instruction sheet, the bank’s documentary stamp tax report, and a bank certification.
The disclosure statement showed that the loan amount was P2.88 billion, that P21.6 million was deducted as DST, and that the net proceeds credited to the taxpayer amounted to P2.8584 billion. The bank’s reports further showed that its total electronic DST remittance included the P21.6 million DST attributable to the taxpayer’s loan. A bank officer also testified that only the net proceeds were credited to the taxpayer because the DST had already been deducted and remitted to the BIR on January 5, 2021.
Separately, the taxpayer submitted the BTR-BIR deposit slip and monthly DST declaration or return for December 2020, both stamped received on January 5, 2021, to show that it also paid P21.6 million on the same loan. Since the Commissioner did not refute the taxpayer’s documentary evidence, the court concluded that the DST had indeed been erroneously or wrongfully collected.
Key Legal Principle: Only One DST Should Be Imposed on the Same Loan Transaction
Section 179 of the NIRC imposes DST on debt instruments at P1.50 for every P200, or fractional part thereof, of the issue price. The same provision recognizes that only one DST shall be imposed on either the loan agreement or the promissory note issued to secure the loan. The tax is imposed on the transaction evidenced by the instrument, not as a penalty for every internal payment step made in relation to that transaction.
In practical terms, once the correct DST has been paid on the loan transaction, a second payment for the same taxable event is not legally due. If the government retains both payments, the excess constitutes an erroneous or wrongfully collected tax. The court also invoked the principle of solutio indebiti and the rule against unjust enrichment, explaining that the government must restore taxes erroneously paid.
Practical Takeaways for Borrowers, CFOs, and Tax Teams
Corporate borrowers should closely review loan release documents, disclosure statements, bank debit entries, DST returns, deposit slips, and bank remittance reports. A duplicate DST payment can occur when the bank deducts DST from loan proceeds and the borrower’s accounting or tax team separately remits the same DST through a manual or over-the-counter payment.
Tax managers should also calendar the two-year prescriptive period from the actual date of payment. Waiting for the BIR to act on an administrative refund claim can be risky when the deadline is near. The safer approach is to file a complete administrative claim early, monitor the deadline, and file the judicial claim within the same two-year period when necessary.
The ruling also underscores the importance of evidence. A refund claim for erroneously paid DST will not prosper on allegation alone. Taxpayers should be ready to prove the loan amount, the DST computation, the deduction from loan proceeds, the bank’s remittance to the BIR, the taxpayer’s separate payment, and the connection of both payments to the same debt instrument.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, lenders, borrowers, and finance teams in evaluating potential DST refund claims, preparing administrative refund applications, preserving evidence, and litigating tax refund cases before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help determine whether a duplicate DST payment, erroneous tax remittance, or wrongfully collected internal revenue tax may be recovered.
If your company has paid DST on a loan, promissory note, restructuring, or financing transaction and suspects that the same tax was deducted or remitted twice, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.