A tax assessment was cancelled after defective substituted service and a demand letter that merely “requested” payment failed due process standards.

Taxpayers facing BIR assessments should closely examine both the manner of service and the exact wording of the demand letter, because an assessment may be cancelled when the taxpayer was not validly served or when the notice merely asks the taxpayer to pay instead of making a clear and categorical demand for payment.

Background of the Assessment Dispute

The dispute arose from a deficiency tax assessment for taxable year 2016 involving income tax, expanded withholding tax, and withholding tax on compensation. The taxpayer challenged the assessment after the BIR issued a Formal Letter of Demand with Details of Discrepancies, Final Assessment Notices, and later a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment. The total assessment stated in the Court’s earlier decision was P37,756,661.02.

In the main decision, the Court of Tax Appeals granted the taxpayer’s Petition for Review, cancelled the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, nullified the related Warrants of Garnishment dated January 3, 2022, cancelled the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices dated January 14, 2020, and prohibited the Commissioner and persons acting on his behalf from collecting the assessed deficiency taxes for taxable year 2016 (CTA Case No. 10763).

The Commissioner moved for reconsideration. The Commissioner argued that substituted service of the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment was valid because no person was found at the taxpayer’s registered business address; that the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices contained a categorical demand for payment despite using the phrase “requested to pay”; and that even if the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment was void for lack of due process, the underlying tax assessment remained valid.

Why the Motion for Reconsideration Failed

The Court denied the Commissioner’s motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. It sustained its prior ruling that the taxpayer was not liable for the assessed internal revenue taxes because the assessment process violated the taxpayer’s right to due process and because the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices failed to contain a categorical demand for payment.

On service of the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, the Court recognized that substituted service may be resorted to in appropriate cases. However, the Court emphasized that substituted service must comply with the conditions for validity under subsection 3.1.6 of Revenue Regulations No. 18-2013. The problem was not merely that the BIR attempted substituted service. The problem was that the BIR failed to prove compliance with the required safeguards.

The Court found several defects. First, there was no showing that the revenue officer was accompanied by a barangay official from the barangay where the taxpayer’s registered address was located and by two disinterested witnesses who could personally attest to and observe the absence of any person at the address. Second, the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment was left with a barangay official of a different barangay, not the barangay where the taxpayer’s registered address was located. Third, only one witness signed the acknowledgment of receipt, and the witness’s status as disinterested was not established. Fourth, the acknowledgment of receipt did not state the factual basis justifying resort to substituted service.

Because of these defects, the Court held that the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment was void for violating the taxpayer’s right to due process. For taxpayers, this is significant because it confirms that BIR collection action cannot rest on defective service of a critical assessment document. The government must follow the procedural rules that give the taxpayer a real opportunity to know, respond, and protect its rights.

The Demand Letter Must Clearly Impose an Obligation to Pay

The Court also sustained its ruling that the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices were void because they did not contain a categorical demand for payment. The Court relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Telstar Manufacturing Corporation, where the Supreme Court required that a Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice must contain a categorical demand for payment of the assessed tax, together with the factual and legal bases for the assessment.

The Court explained that the obligation to pay tax must be stated in clear and plain language so that the taxpayer is properly apprised of what the BIR is imposing. In this case, the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices used the phrase that the taxpayer was “requested to pay” its deficiency tax liabilities. For the Court, that language was permissive, not mandatory. It was not an unequivocal command to pay.

This distinction matters in tax litigation. A valid assessment is not simply a computation of alleged tax liabilities. It must also contain the legal and factual basis for the assessment and a definite demand that the taxpayer pay the assessed amount. Where the language fails to impose a definite obligation, the assessment may be attacked as void.

Practical Lessons for Taxpayers and Corporate Finance Teams

Taxpayers should not treat every BIR assessment notice as automatically valid. When a Formal Letter of Demand, Final Assessment Notice, or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment is received, management should immediately review not only the amounts assessed but also the form, wording, service, dates, and attachments. Technical defects may have substantive consequences, especially when they affect due process.

Companies should preserve envelopes, registry receipts, email transmittals, acknowledgment receipts, service reports, and all documents showing how BIR notices were delivered. In disputes involving substituted service, the details matter: who attempted service, where it was made, who witnessed it, which barangay official was involved, and what factual basis was written in the acknowledgment. A defective substituted service record may be decisive.

Tax managers should also review whether the Formal Letter of Demand actually contains a categorical demand to pay. Words such as “requested to pay” may appear harmless, but the Court may treat permissive wording as insufficient when the notice fails to impose a definite obligation upon the taxpayer. This is especially relevant for corporations reviewing old assessments, pending protests, or collection actions based on demand letters issued before the Supreme Court’s Telstar ruling became widely relied upon in tax litigation.

For importers, manufacturers, exporters, and service companies with large assessments, the ruling reinforces a broader point: procedural defenses are not mere technicalities. The BIR must comply with the rules on notice, service, and demand because tax assessments carry serious consequences, including garnishment and enforced collection. When those safeguards are disregarded, the taxpayer may have grounds to seek cancellation of the assessment and related collection measures.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in evaluating BIR assessments, preparing administrative protests, challenging defective Formal Letters of Demand and Final Assessment Notices, seeking relief from collection actions, and litigating tax cases before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps businesses identify both substantive and procedural defenses, preserve evidence, and build a litigation strategy before deadlines expire.

If your company has received a BIR assessment, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, warrant of garnishment, or other collection notice, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on your options for tax protest, settlement, or Court of Tax Appeals litigation.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *