Taxpayers may challenge BIR garnishment when PAN and FAN/FLD notices were not validly served; void assessments cannot support distraint or levy.
Taxpayers facing bank garnishment or distraint may still challenge collection when the underlying assessment was not validly served. The ruling is a reminder that the government cannot enforce deficiency income tax, VAT, withholding tax, DST, IAET, penalties, surcharges, and interest through summary remedies unless the taxpayer was first given the written notices required by law and a real opportunity to protest.
Background of the Tax Assessment Dispute
The taxpayer was a VAT-registered domestic corporation assessed for alleged deficiency income tax, value-added tax, expanded withholding tax, documentary stamp tax, improperly accumulated earnings tax, and compromise penalty for taxable year 2018. The aggregate amount originally placed in issue was P8,766,191.92, plus interest and surcharges.
The BIR investigation began with a Letter of Authority dated December 13, 2019. The taxpayer received a request for presentation of records and submitted several batches of documents. The account was later reassigned to another revenue officer and group supervisor, and the BIR eventually issued a Notice of Discrepancy, a Preliminary Assessment Notice, a Formal Letter of Demand with details of discrepancies, assessment notices, a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy, and Warrants of Garnishment addressed to banks.
The taxpayer, however, denied that it had validly received the PAN and the FAN/FLD. It argued that the assessment notices were not properly served on the corporation or on any person authorized to receive them. The taxpayer brought the case after it was informed by its banks of the warrants of garnishment, arguing that the assessment and the collection remedies were void for violation of administrative due process (CTA Case No. 10984).
Why the Court Took Jurisdiction Despite the BIR’s Finality Argument
The Commissioner argued that the assessment had already become final, executory, and demandable because the taxpayer supposedly failed to file a valid protest within 30 days from receipt of the FAN/FLD. The Commissioner also argued that the petition should be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction or for being premature.
The Court rejected that position. It emphasized that the Court of Tax Appeals has jurisdiction not only over disputed assessments and refund claims, but also over other matters arising under the National Internal Revenue Code and laws administered by the BIR. Warrants of garnishment and warrants of distraint and/or levy are acts of the Commissioner that may be reviewed when they arise from internal revenue tax collection.
Because the taxpayer denied receiving the assessment notices, the burden shifted to the BIR to prove by competent evidence that the notices were actually and validly served. The Court held that the 30-day period to appeal was reckoned from the taxpayer’s receipt of notice of the warrants of garnishment through its banks. On that basis, the petition was timely.
The Due Process Rule for PAN, FAN, and FLD Service
Section 228 of the Tax Code requires that a taxpayer be informed in writing of the law and the facts on which an assessment is made. Otherwise, the assessment is void. This is not a technical formality. It is the core due process requirement that allows the taxpayer to understand the alleged deficiency and prepare an effective protest.
The Court also applied Revenue Regulations No. 12-99, as amended, and Revenue Memorandum Order No. 40-2019 on the proper modes of serving assessment notices. Personal service is the primary mode. If personal service is not practicable, the BIR may resort to substituted service or service by mail, but only by strictly complying with the requirements of its own rules.
For substituted service, the BIR must show why the taxpayer could not be personally served, and depending on the circumstance, the notice must be left with a proper person at the registered or known address, or a barangay official and two disinterested witnesses must personally observe and attest to the taxpayer’s absence or refusal to receive. The required facts, names, positions, and signatures must appear in the proper portion of the notice or supporting report.
For service by registered mail, the BIR must present proof such as the registry receipt, return card or proof of delivery, and, where applicable, the returned envelope or certification showing why delivery failed. The Court stressed that when the taxpayer denies receipt, valid service cannot rest on assumption.
Why the Assessment and Warrants Were Cancelled
The Court found that the Commissioner failed to prove valid substituted service of the PAN and FAN/FLD. The taxpayer maintained that the person who supposedly received the notices was not authorized to receive papers on its behalf. The Court was not persuaded that the BIR had exhausted the required steps to locate and properly serve the taxpayer or its authorized representative.
The Court also found the proof of service by mail insufficient. The Commissioner claimed that the FAN/FLD had also been served by registered mail, but the required proof of mailing and delivery was not adequately established in the proceedings. Without competent proof that the taxpayer received the assessment notices, the assessment could not become final, executory, and demandable.
The Court therefore held that due process was not accorded to the taxpayer in the issuance of the PAN and FAN/FLD. The deficiency tax assessments were void. Since the collection remedies were founded on a void assessment, the Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy and the Warrants of Garnishment were likewise cancelled and set aside.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Facing BIR Collection
First, a taxpayer should not assume that bank garnishment means the case is already lost. If the underlying PAN, FAN, FLD, or final assessment was not validly served, the taxpayer may still have a remedy before the Court of Tax Appeals.
Second, proof of service matters. Businesses should keep updated registered addresses with the BIR, maintain receiving logs, identify authorized representatives for tax documents, and preserve bank notices, warrants, envelopes, registry records, and correspondence. These details can determine whether an assessment became final or whether the taxpayer was denied due process.
Third, the BIR must strictly observe its own service rules before using summary collection remedies. Substituted service is not a shortcut. It requires factual justification, proper witnesses, proper documentation, and proof that the required steps were actually followed.
Fourth, taxpayers must act quickly once they learn of a warrant of garnishment, distraint, or levy. The ruling recognized that the appeal period may be reckoned from receipt of the adverse collection action where the taxpayer did not validly receive the assessment notices, but delay can still create serious procedural risk.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, business owners, importers, and individuals in tax assessment disputes, BIR protest proceedings, warrants of garnishment, warrants of distraint and levy, and petitions before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation team can review whether a PAN, FAN, FLD, FDDA, or collection warrant was validly issued and served, assess available remedies, and prepare the necessary protest, petition, or urgent relief strategy.
If your company has received a BIR assessment, bank garnishment notice, or collection warrant, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation practice.