Fuel excise tax refunds require strict proof linking importation, tax payment, bonded storage, delivery, and foreign use by international carriers.

Importers claiming an excise tax refund or tax credit for Jet A-1 fuel sold to international carriers must be ready to trace the fuel from importation, tax payment, bonded storage, withdrawal, delivery, and actual use outside the Philippines. In this ruling, the taxpayer preserved a substantial refund, but the Court refused to enlarge the amount where the supporting documents failed to prove that certain fuel deliveries came from the taxed importation or where the delivery records were unreadable.

Background of the Excise Tax Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from a petroleum importer’s claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate for excise taxes paid on imported Jet A-1 fuel. The fuel was allegedly later sold to tax-exempt international air carriers during April to May 2018. The taxpayer had operated its Tabangao product storage tanks as a Customs Bonded Warehouse from July 2015 until its closure in September 2018.

In April 2018, the taxpayer paid excise taxes of P29,252,140.00 on its importations of Jet A-1 fuel under Sections 129 and 131(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code. On March 10, 2020, it filed an administrative claim for refund or tax credit with the BIR, and on June 9, 2020, it elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals. The Court in Division partially granted the claim in the amount of P15,501,712.00. Both the Commissioner and the taxpayer challenged the result before the Court En Banc (CTA EB No. 2934).

Why the Commissioner’s Challenge Failed

The Commissioner argued that tax refunds are in the nature of tax exemptions and should not be allowed without a clear statutory basis. He maintained that the NIRC contains no applicable refund remedy except Section 130(D), and that Section 135 benefits only the international carriers purchasing the fuel, not the importer that paid the excise tax upon importation.

The Court rejected that position. It applied Section 229 of the NIRC, which allows recovery of national internal revenue taxes that were erroneously or illegally assessed or collected. The Court also relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in the earlier Pilipinas Shell petroleum excise tax case, which clarified that for indirect taxes such as excise tax, the statutory taxpayer remains the importer or manufacturer that actually pays the tax and files the corresponding returns. The economic burden may be passed on to a purchaser, but the legal incidence remains with the statutory taxpayer.

Because the importer paid the excise tax on petroleum products that were later sold to international carriers falling within Section 135 of the NIRC, the exemption must inure to the benefit of the party legally liable for the tax. The Court therefore sustained the taxpayer’s entitlement to a refund or tax credit to the extent that the claim was properly proven.

Why the Taxpayer Could Not Increase the Refund

The taxpayer also sought to increase the refundable amount. It argued that certain Aviation Service Returns, initially unreadable, were later resubmitted in clearer form during the motion for reconsideration stage and should have been considered. It also argued that fuel withdrawn from the Tabangao Refinery before April 26, 2018 still came from the same imported Jet A-1 fuel on which excise taxes had been paid.

The Court refused. For Section 135(a) of the NIRC to apply to petroleum products sold to international air carriers, the taxpayer had to prove, among others, that the fuel was stored in a bonded storage tank and disposed of under the applicable rules, and that the fuel was used or consumed outside the Philippines. The taxpayer also had to establish a reliable documentary chain connecting the imported fuel, the excise tax payment, the withdrawal, the delivery, and the eventual sale to qualified international carriers.

The Court found that the excise tax payments for the importation subject of the claim were supported by the Authority to Release Imported Goods and the Statement of Settlement of Duties and Taxes, both dated April 26, 2018. The taxpayer’s own witness testified that Jet A-1 fuel could not be withdrawn without the ATRIG, which served as BIR permission to withdraw the fuel from the Customs Bonded Warehouse after settlement of taxes and duties. For that reason, fuel withdrawals made before April 26, 2018 could not be treated as sourced from the importation covered by those tax payment documents.

Accordingly, the Court upheld the disallowance of P11,132,948.00 covering 2,783,237 liters of Jet A-1 fuel supported by Certificates of Quantity Delivered and Bulk Delivery Notes dated before April 26, 2018. The taxpayer failed to prove that those liters formed part of the taxed importation covered by the refund claim.

Unreadable Evidence Can Defeat Part of a Tax Refund Claim

The Court also upheld the disallowance of P1,759,256.00 for 439,814 liters of Jet A-1 fuel because the relevant Aviation Service Returns were unreadable. These records were important because they were supposed to show details such as destination, customer name, and volume, and to establish that the fuel was sold or consumed outside the Philippines.

The taxpayer argued that clearer copies were not new evidence because the exhibits had already been admitted. The Court disagreed in substance. Admission of evidence is different from probative value. A document may be admitted, but if the Court cannot read the material details needed to verify the claim, it may still be given no weight. The Court also noted that the defect had been observed as early as the resolution on the formal offer of evidence in May 2022, yet the taxpayer failed to correct the problem before the case was submitted for decision.

Practical Takeaways for Importers, Airlines, and Tax Managers

This decision is important for petroleum importers, aviation fuel suppliers, international carriers, customs brokers, and tax managers handling excise tax refund claims. The ruling confirms that a statutory taxpayer who pays excise tax on imported petroleum products may claim the benefit of the Section 135 exemption when the products are sold to qualified international carriers. However, entitlement in principle is not enough. The refund will be allowed only to the extent supported by clear, readable, and chronologically consistent evidence.

For businesses, the most practical lesson is that tax refund litigation is document-intensive. ATRIGs, Statements of Settlement of Duties and Taxes, Official Register Books, Daily Product Deliveries Reports, Bulk Delivery Notes, Certificates of Quantity Delivered, Aviation Service Returns, and related records must match in timing, volume, source, destination, and customer. Any gap in the chain may reduce the refund, even if the taxpayer is legally entitled to exemption for other transactions.

Taxpayers should also treat exhibit quality as a litigation issue, not a clerical matter. Blurred scans, unreadable delivery records, or incomplete supporting documents can result in permanent disallowance if not corrected at the proper stage. A motion for reconsideration is not a safe opportunity to repair evidentiary defects that could have been addressed earlier.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, exporters, customs brokers, and corporate finance teams in tax assessments, refund claims, excise tax disputes, VAT controversies, customs issues, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate refund eligibility, organize documentary proof, prepare administrative claims, and litigate disputes where the BIR or Bureau of Customs denies or reduces a claim.

For companies dealing with excise tax refund claims, petroleum product exemptions, tax credit applications, or CTA cases involving documentary proof, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *