Taxpayers may still recover overpaid Makati business tax when the city reopens the same taxable year and its own revised assessment shows an overpayment.
Local business taxpayers that paid a city assessment are not automatically barred from seeking a refund if the local treasurer later reopens the same taxable year, conducts another assessment, and effectively treats the earlier payment as part of a continuing audit. For companies facing Makati business tax assessments, the decision is a useful reminder that finality cannot be invoked selectively by the city when its own later actions show that the same tax period remained open.
Background of the Local Business Tax Dispute
The taxpayer was a domestic corporation based in Makati City and engaged in services connected with construction, installation works, electrical works, piping works, repairs and maintenance, and staff services. For taxable year 2016, the local treasurer first issued a business tax billing assessment in the amount of P543,775.99, which the taxpayer paid in full. The following year, another billing assessment was issued for alleged deficiency local business tax for the same taxable year, consisting of P107,550.24 in basic tax plus surcharge and interest of P54,850.62, for a total of P162,400.86. The taxpayer also paid this additional amount.
The controversy arose when the local treasurer later issued a broader notice of assessment covering taxable years 2013 to 2017. That later assessment again included taxable year 2016 and assessed additional local business taxes for that same year. The taxpayer protested the later assessment and, separately, filed an administrative claim for refund or tax credit for the P162,400.86 previously paid for taxable year 2016. It then filed a judicial refund case within two years from payment. The dispute eventually reached the tax court en banc (CTA EB No. 2892), after the local treasurer argued that the refund case should be dismissed because the taxpayer had not protested the 2017 billing assessment within sixty days.
The Core Issue: Section 195 Protest or Section 196 Refund?
The local treasurer argued that because there was an assessment, the taxpayer was required to follow Section 195 of the Local Government Code. Under that provision, a taxpayer who receives a notice of assessment must file a written protest within sixty days; otherwise, the assessment becomes final and executory. The city maintained that the taxpayer’s failure to protest the 2017 billing assessment within the sixty-day period made the assessment final and unappealable.
The taxpayer’s position, however, was anchored on the remedy for refund or tax credit under Section 196 of the Local Government Code. That provision requires a written claim for refund or credit with the local treasurer before a court action may be maintained, and it sets a two-year period from payment, or from the date the taxpayer becomes entitled to the refund or credit, for filing the court case.
Why the Tax Court Allowed the Refund Claim
The tax court rejected the city’s attempt to treat the 2017 assessment as final while also relying on its later audit of the same taxable year. The court noted that after the taxpayer paid the P162,400.86 in January 2017, the local treasurer later issued another notice of assessment in June 2018 covering taxable year 2016. In that later assessment, the city deducted the basic tax paid in January 2017 from the new computation, showing that the 2016 assessment process continued and that the earlier payment was considered in arriving at the later assessed amount.
For the court, this mattered. The local treasurer could not fairly argue that the 2017 assessment had become final against the taxpayer while the city itself continued to audit and assess the same taxable year. The court found that the city’s own conduct belied its claim of finality. It was also significant that the Local Government Code and its implementing rules limit the examination of a taxpayer’s books and records to only once for every tax period. A view that would allow the 2017 assessment to be final for the taxpayer but still open for the city was rejected as unfair and unreasonable.
The court also emphasized that a refund under Section 196 is not automatically barred merely because a taxpayer previously paid pursuant to an assessment. A taxpayer that receives an assessment, pays the amount, and later seeks recovery may still pursue a refund, provided the taxpayer satisfies the procedural conditions recognized under the Local Government Code and controlling jurisprudence. In this case, the taxpayer protested the later assessment covering taxable year 2016, filed a court action after the city’s inaction, filed an administrative refund claim for the P162,400.86, and filed the judicial refund case within the two-year period.
The Revised Assessment Strengthened the Taxpayer’s Refund Position
The later revised assessment was particularly damaging to the city’s position. During the related assessment proceedings, the city issued a revised notice of assessment showing an overpayment for taxable year 2016 amounting to P243,491.99. The worksheet also contained a notation referring to a claim for refund or tax credit. The tax court treated this as at least an acknowledgment that the taxpayer had paid more than what was due and that the excess amount could properly be the subject of a refund claim.
The parties later entered into a judicial compromise agreement settling deficiency business taxes, surcharge, and interest for taxable years 2013 to 2017. However, the compromise did not dispose of the overpaid tax for taxable year 2016. The court refused to presume that the overpayment had been absorbed into the compromise, because doing so would effectively allow the city to retain money that was not due, resulting in unjust enrichment.
Final Ruling: Refund of the Overpaid Local Business Tax
The tax court denied the local treasurer’s petition and affirmed the earlier rulings in favor of the taxpayer. It held that the taxpayer had established the requirements for a successful refund claim under Section 196 of the Local Government Code and was entitled to recover the overpaid local business tax in the amount of P162,400.86.
The ruling does not mean that taxpayers may ignore the sixty-day protest period whenever an assessment exists. The decision is more nuanced. As a general rule, a taxpayer who receives a local tax assessment should still file a written protest within sixty days and, if necessary, go to court within thirty days from denial or inaction. What makes this case important is that the city’s own later actions reopened and continued the assessment of the same taxable year, making it inequitable for the city to rely on finality only against the taxpayer.
Practical Takeaways for Businesses Facing Makati Business Tax Assessments
First, taxpayers should not assume that payment ends the dispute. If the amount paid is later shown to be erroneous, excessive, or illegally collected, a refund or tax credit may still be available, but the administrative and judicial deadlines must be carefully tracked.
Second, local treasurers cannot have it both ways. If a city continues to audit the same taxable year and issues a later assessment that incorporates or recomputes prior payments, that conduct may undermine an argument that an earlier assessment had already become final and closed.
Third, revised assessments and computation worksheets matter. In this case, the city’s own revised computation showing an overpayment became a key factual basis supporting the taxpayer’s refund claim. CFOs, tax managers, and accounting teams should preserve assessment worksheets, official receipts, compromise agreements, protest letters, and refund claims because these documents may determine whether a local tax refund case succeeds.
Fourth, settlement language must be drafted carefully. A compromise agreement resolving deficiency local business taxes should expressly address whether any overpayment, refund, or tax credit is waived, preserved, or excluded. Silence may create future litigation, especially where the city’s own records show an overpayment.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists companies, business owners, and finance teams in handling local business tax assessments, refund claims, protests before city treasurers, and appeals before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can review assessment notices, evaluate whether Section 195 or Section 196 applies, prepare protest and refund strategies, and represent taxpayers in court when local tax collections are excessive, procedurally defective, or unsupported by law.
For assistance with Makati business tax assessments, local tax refund claims, or Court of Tax Appeals litigation, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.