Holding companies may seek LBT refunds when cities tax passive dividend income through permit renewal billings instead of valid assessments.
Holding companies that merely receive passive dividend income should closely review local business tax billings, because dividend income may not be treated as taxable gross receipts unless the taxpayer is a bank or other financial institution. In this ruling, the tax court sustained a refund of local business tax paid during business permit renewals after finding that the taxpayer was not liable for local business tax on dividends and that ordinary billing statements were not valid assessment notices under the Local Government Code.
Background of the Local Business Tax Refund Dispute
The dispute arose from local business taxes imposed by the City Treasurer of Taguig City during the renewal of the taxpayerâs business permits for 2018 and 2019. The taxpayer was registered with the Bureau of Internal Revenue under financial holding company activities. During the 2018 business permit renewal, it received a billing statement assessing local business tax on dividend income in the amount of Php139,064.34, which it paid on January 20, 2018. During the 2019 renewal, it received another billing statement assessing local business tax on dividend income in the amount of Php514,035.47, which it paid on January 19, 2019.
On September 25, 2019, the taxpayer filed an administrative claim for refund for the aggregate amount of Php653,099.81. It then filed its judicial claim before the Regional Trial Court of Taguig City on January 20, 2020. The trial court granted the refund, and the City Treasurer elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA AC No. 344), arguing that the billing statements should be treated as notices of assessment, that the claim was filed out of time, and that the taxpayer was liable as a holding company under the Taguig Revenue Code as amended by Ordinance No. 34, Series of 2017.
Billing Statements for Business Permit Renewal Are Not Automatically Assessment Notices
The tax court rejected the argument that the billing statements issued during business permit renewal were notices of assessment under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. This distinction mattered because a taxpayer who receives a true local tax assessment must protest within 60 days from receipt, and any appeal must be brought within the periods provided under Section 195.
The court emphasized that a valid notice of assessment must state the nature of the tax, fee, or charge, the amount of deficiency, and the applicable surcharges, interests, and penalties. More importantly, it must sufficiently inform the taxpayer of the factual and legal bases of the assessment so that the taxpayer can make an intelligent protest. A mere billing statement used as part of the business permit renewal process does not become an assessment simply because it states amounts to be paid.
Here, the billing statements were found to be prerequisites for the issuance or renewal of the taxpayerâs business permits for 2018 and 2019. They did not show that the City Treasurer had made a finding that the taxpayer failed to pay correct taxes, fees, or charges. They also did not provide the facts and law used as bases for the alleged assessment. For that reason, Section 196 of the Local Government Code, not Section 195, governed the refund claim.
The Refund Claim Was Filed on Time Under Section 196
Because there was no valid notice of assessment, the taxpayerâs remedy was a claim for refund of taxes erroneously or illegally collected under Section 196 of the Local Government Code. That provision requires a written claim for refund or credit to be filed with the local treasurer before going to court, and the court action must be brought within two years from payment of the tax, fee, or charge, or from the date the taxpayer becomes entitled to the refund or credit.
The taxpayer paid the 2018 local business tax on January 20, 2018 and the 2019 local business tax on January 19, 2019. It filed the administrative claim on September 25, 2019, and the judicial claim on January 20, 2020. The court held that both the administrative and judicial claims were filed within the two-year prescriptive period. The taxpayer was not required to wait indefinitely for the City Treasurerâs action on the administrative claim, especially because waiting could have caused the judicial claim to prescribe.
Dividend Income of a Holding Company Was Not Subject to Local Business Tax
The central substantive issue was whether the taxpayer, as a holding company, could be made liable for local business tax on dividend income. The City Treasurer relied on Taguigâs ordinance imposing local business tax on dividend income received by holding companies from investments in shares of stock or interests in other companies.
The court sustained the taxpayerâs position. It held that Section 133(a) of the Local Government Code limits the taxing powers of local government units by prohibiting the levy of income tax, except when imposed on banks and other financial institutions. Section 143(f) permits local business tax on banks and other financial institutions based on gross receipts derived from items such as interest, commissions, discounts from lending, financial leasing income, dividends, rentals, and gains from sale or exchange of property.
The taxpayer, however, was not a bank or other financial institution. The court adopted the distinction between a holding company and a financial intermediary: a holding company may hold shares and receive dividends from investments, but that does not automatically make it a financial intermediary actively dealing with public funds or performing quasi-banking functions. The taxpayerâs dividend income was treated as passive investment income from holding shares, not gross receipts from the regular business of a bank or financial institution.
Refund Granted, But No Interest or Attorneyâs Fees
The court denied the City Treasurerâs petition and affirmed the trial courtâs ruling ordering the refund or payment of Php139,064.34 for 2018 and Php514,035.47 for 2019, or a total of Php653,099.81. The court also clarified that the trial court did not exempt the taxpayer from all local business tax. Rather, it held only that the taxpayer could not be held liable for local business tax on dividend income because it was not categorized as a bank or other financial institution.
However, the taxpayer was not awarded interest and attorneyâs fees. The court noted that interest on tax refunds is allowed only when authorized by law or when the collection was attended by arbitrariness. It also found no basis to award attorneyâs fees because there was no showing of bad faith; the City Treasurer had relied on the local ordinance, although erroneously.
Practical Takeaways for Holding Companies and Local Taxpayers
First, taxpayers should not assume that every amount appearing in a business permit renewal billing statement is legally due. If the local government collects local business tax on passive income such as dividends, interest, or gains from shares, the taxpayer should examine whether the income is truly part of taxable gross receipts under the Local Government Code.
Second, the form and content of the local governmentâs document matter. A billing statement, official receipt, or permit renewal computation may not be the same as a valid notice of assessment. If it does not state the legal and factual bases, the nature of the deficiency, and applicable surcharges, interests, and penalties, the taxpayer may have a refund remedy under Section 196 rather than being confined to the protest procedure under Section 195.
Third, timing remains critical. Even where Section 196 applies, taxpayers must file an administrative claim with the local treasurer and must also file the court action within two years from payment or from entitlement to refund or credit. Businesses should track payment dates carefully, especially when local taxes are paid annually during permit renewal season.
Fourth, holding companies should distinguish passive investment income from operating gross receipts. The fact that a company receives dividends or holds shares does not necessarily convert it into a bank, financial institution, or financial intermediary for local business tax purposes.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, holding companies, property groups, family-owned enterprises, and operating businesses on local business tax assessments, refund claims, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can assist in reviewing local tax billings, preparing administrative refund claims, evaluating prescription periods, and litigating disputes before the proper court when local taxes are illegally or erroneously collected.
For companies facing local business tax assessments on dividend income, passive income, or business permit renewal billings, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.