A taxpayer’s assessment appeal was dismissed without prejudice after it failed to cure a defective verification and certification against forum shopping.

Taxpayers challenging a BIR assessment before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat verification and certification requirements as jurisdiction-sensitive litigation safeguards, not clerical formalities. A petition for review, including a request to suspend tax collection, may be dismissed when the taxpayer fails to submit a verification that strictly complies with the Rules of Civil Procedure after being ordered to do so.

Background of the Tax Assessment Dispute

The taxpayer filed a petition for review with a manifestation and motion to suspend collection of taxes on 5 January 2026. The case involved an assessment dispute before the Court of Tax Appeals, with the taxpayer seeking judicial relief against the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and, at the same time, asking the court to suspend collection while the petition was pending.

Before the Court could proceed to the substantive issues of the assessment, however, it required the taxpayer to cure a defect in its Verification and Certification Against Forum Shopping. In a 16 January 2026 minute resolution, received by the taxpayer on 22 January 2026, the taxpayer was directed to submit a verification and certification that complied with Rule 7, Section 4 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, as amended (CTA Case No. 12302).

Instead of immediately submitting the required compliant document, the taxpayer filed several pleadings: motions for extension, a motion to admit supplemental pleadings with partial compliance, and a motion to admit an affidavit in full compliance. Despite these filings, the Court found that the taxpayer still failed to submit the specific revised Verification and Certification Against Forum Shopping that the Court had required.

Why the Verification Was Defective

The Court focused on the wording of the verification executed by the taxpayer’s representative. The representative stated that the allegations in the petition were true and correct based on what was relayed to her by the taxpayer and/or based on authentic records at hand and made available to her. This language was insufficient because Rule 7, Section 4 requires the affiant to attest that the allegations are true and correct based on personal knowledge or based on authentic documents.

Under the amended rule, a pleading verified by an authorized representative must be supported by proper authority, such as a secretary’s certificate or special power of attorney, and must allege the required attestations. These include that the allegations are true and correct based on personal knowledge or authentic documents, that the pleading is not filed to harass or delay, and that the factual allegations have evidentiary support or will have such support after a reasonable opportunity for discovery.

The distinction matters. A verification based on information merely relayed by another person does not satisfy the requirement of personal knowledge or authentic documents. The rule expressly provides that a pleading required to be verified but verified only on information and belief, or on knowledge, information and belief, or one that lacks a proper verification, is treated as an unsigned pleading.

The Court’s Ruling: Dismissal Without Prejudice

The Court dismissed the taxpayer’s petition for review with manifestation and motion to suspend collection of taxes without prejudice. The dismissal was not based on the validity of the BIR assessment, the correctness of the tax computation, or the substantive grounds raised by the taxpayer. It was based on the taxpayer’s failure to comply with the Court’s order to submit a revised and compliant Verification and Certification Against Forum Shopping.

The Court relied on Section 3, Rule 17 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, as amended. That rule allows dismissal when a plaintiff, without justifiable cause, fails to comply with the Rules or with any order of the court. In this case, the Court had already identified the defect and gave the taxpayer the opportunity to cure it. The taxpayer filed multiple submissions, but none complied with the specific requirement imposed by the Court.

Because the dismissal was declared to be without prejudice, the ruling did not operate as a final adjudication on the merits of the tax assessment dispute. However, from a practical standpoint, a dismissal without prejudice can still be dangerous in tax litigation. Tax remedies are governed by strict statutory and procedural deadlines. A taxpayer whose petition is dismissed may face serious timing issues if the period to appeal, refile, or seek other remedies has already lapsed or is close to lapsing.

Practical Lessons for Taxpayers Challenging BIR Assessments

This ruling is a reminder that tax litigation is not won or lost only on tax law arguments. Procedural compliance can determine whether a taxpayer is even allowed to have the assessment reviewed. When a corporation files a petition through an authorized representative, counsel must ensure that the verification uses the precise language required by Rule 7, Section 4 and that the representative’s authority is properly attached and clearly established.

For corporate taxpayers, the safest approach is to avoid wording that suggests hearsay, secondhand information, or reliance on matters merely relayed by officers or employees. The verification should be grounded in the affiant’s personal knowledge or in authentic corporate and tax records. Where the affiant is not the person with direct knowledge of every transaction, the pleading should be carefully drafted to show that the verification is based on authentic documents rather than on loose internal reports or oral statements.

The ruling is also important for taxpayers seeking suspension of collection. A motion to suspend collection is usually urgent because the BIR may proceed with enforcement while the case is pending. If the main petition is dismissed for a defective verification, the taxpayer’s request to suspend collection may fall with it. This can expose the taxpayer to collection measures even before the substantive validity of the assessment is resolved.

Taxpayers should also pay attention to court directives after filing. Once the Court points out a defect and orders a specific compliance, the response must directly cure the identified defect. Filing motions for extension, supplemental pleadings, or explanatory affidavits may not be enough if the Court required a revised verification and certification in a particular form. Procedural compliance should be exact, timely, and responsive to the Court’s order.

What This Means for Philippine Tax Litigation

For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, the key takeaway is simple: a meritorious defense to a BIR assessment can be derailed by a defective verification. Before filing a petition for review with the Court of Tax Appeals, the taxpayer should conduct a procedural audit of the pleading package. This includes checking the verification, certification against forum shopping, secretary’s certificate, board authority, special power of attorney if applicable, proof of service, filing mode, and all relevant appeal deadlines.

For individuals and corporate representatives, the ruling underscores the importance of choosing the correct affiant. The person signing the verification should be able to truthfully attest to the pleading based on personal knowledge or authentic records. Where the taxpayer is a corporation, internal coordination among finance, tax, accounting, and legal teams is necessary so that the petition is not supported by a weak or technically defective certification.

For taxpayers already before the Court, the ruling also shows that corrective orders must be handled with urgency. A court directive to cure a verification defect should not be treated as a routine administrative matter. It is an opportunity to prevent dismissal. Once missed or improperly complied with, the taxpayer may lose valuable time and may have to confront procedural defenses from the government.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, business owners, and corporate officers in tax assessment disputes, Court of Tax Appeals litigation, motions to suspend collection, and procedural compliance for tax appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients evaluate BIR assessments, preserve appeal periods, prepare petitions for review, and ensure that pleadings comply with the technical requirements that can affect the survival of a case.

If your company has received a Final Assessment Notice, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, collection notice, warrant, or other BIR enforcement action, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax litigation strategy, Court of Tax Appeals remedies, and urgent steps to protect your business from avoidable procedural dismissal.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *