Tax assessment voided after the BIR failed to address the taxpayer’s PAN reply and supporting contracts before issuing final assessment notices.

Taxpayers who answer a Preliminary Assessment Notice must be told why their explanations and documents were rejected before the BIR proceeds to a final assessment. In this assessment case, the Court cancelled a P35.846 million deficiency tax assessment because the tax authority merely repeated its earlier findings in the final demand and failed to explain why the taxpayer’s crowd-funding and loan-contract defense was not accepted.

Background of the Dispute

The taxpayer was an agricultural corporation registered under RDO No. 16 in Cabarroguis, Quirino. Its stated business purpose included operating and developing agricultural lands and raising livestock. For taxable year 2018, the BIR issued a Letter of Authority to examine its books and records, followed by notices requesting documents and later notices of discrepancy based largely on third-party information.

The BIR initially treated alleged purchases as undeclared income and eventually assessed deficiency income tax, percentage tax, registration fee, compromise penalties, surcharge, and interest. The taxpayer disputed the assessment and argued that the amounts treated as undeclared income were not income at all, but funds raised through crowd-funding or borrowings from different lenders. The case reached the tax court after the taxpayer sought cancellation of the assessment (CTA Case No. 10916).

What the Taxpayer Argued

The taxpayer’s core defense was that the BIR made a sweeping assumption: because the taxpayer had alleged purchases, it must have had undeclared taxable income. The taxpayer insisted that the amounts were sourced from borrowings or crowd-funding, not from realized income. In support, it submitted contracts, deposit slips, and summaries covering arrangements with numerous lenders.

The taxpayer also questioned the legal and factual basis of the assessment. It argued that the assessment notices merely cited general authorities, such as Revenue Audit Memorandum Order No. 1-2000 and Section 32 of the National Internal Revenue Code, without sufficiently explaining how those authorities specifically applied to the taxpayer’s alleged transactions. It further objected to the imposition of the 50% surcharge, arguing that fraud had not been properly established in the assessment documents.

The BIR’s Position

The Commissioner maintained that the assessment was valid. The BIR argued that the deficiency income tax was based on undeclared purchases derived from third-party information, that the taxpayer’s alleged loan contracts had no probative value, that the percentage tax assessment was based on undeclared sales of agricultural products, and that the taxpayer failed to pay the annual registration fee for taxable year 2018.

The BIR also disputed the taxpayer’s reliance on the loan or crowd-funding documents. It contended that the contracts were defective or unreliable, including because of issues relating to signatures, authority, recognition in the financial statements, the taxpayer’s registered business activities, and alleged notarization irregularities.

The Court’s Ruling

The Court granted the taxpayer’s Petition for Review. It declared the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices dated 04 January 2022 void and cancelled them. It also cancelled and set aside the final decision on the disputed assessment covering the taxpayer’s alleged deficiency liabilities for taxable year 2018 in the aggregate amount of P35,846,321.69. The Commissioner, and any person acting on the Commissioner’s behalf, was enjoined from collecting that amount from the taxpayer.

The ruling turned on due process. The Court emphasized that Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code and Revenue Regulations No. 12-99, as amended, require that taxpayers be informed in writing of the law and facts on which an assessment is made. The assessment process does not merely require the BIR to issue forms and notices; it also requires meaningful consideration of the taxpayer’s explanations.

The Court relied on the due process principles applied in Supreme Court cases such as Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Avon Products Manufacturing, Inc. and Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Yumex Philippines Corporation. These cases require the BIR not only to state the factual and legal bases of the assessment, but also to consider the taxpayer’s defenses and communicate the reasons for rejecting them. A taxpayer’s right to be heard becomes meaningless if the BIR may simply ignore the taxpayer’s evidence without explanation.

Why the Assessment Failed

After receiving the Preliminary Assessment Notice, the taxpayer submitted a reply explaining that the alleged undeclared income represented property acquisition, equipment purchases, and other farm-related items funded through borrowings or crowd-funding. The taxpayer also attached 126 contracts to support that position.

The Court found that the BIR issued the final demand and final assessment notices only eight days after receiving the taxpayer’s reply. More importantly, the final demand did not mention or discuss the taxpayer’s reply or the attached contracts. Instead, the details of discrepancies attached to the final demand merely repeated the same findings in the preliminary assessment notice, with an upward interest adjustment that increased the aggregate assessment.

Although the BIR revenue officer had internally prepared a memorandum discussing reasons for rejecting the taxpayer’s defense, the Court found that those reasons were not communicated to the taxpayer in the assessment documents. That omission was fatal. Due process requires more than internal evaluation; the taxpayer must be informed why its explanations and evidence were rejected.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Facing BIR Assessments

This decision is important for companies facing BIR assessments based on third-party information, purchase matching, RELIEF data, or alleged undeclared income. A taxpayer should not assume that an assessment is valid simply because the BIR has generated a numerical discrepancy. The BIR must still connect the facts to the law, explain the basis of the tax liability, and address material defenses raised during the administrative protest process.

For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, the lesson is clear: respond to the Preliminary Assessment Notice with a detailed factual and legal explanation, attach supporting documents, and preserve proof of submission. If the BIR later issues a final assessment that simply repeats the preliminary findings without addressing the taxpayer’s defense, there may be a strong due process argument before the Court of Tax Appeals.

At the same time, taxpayers should not read this ruling as a blanket approval of crowd-funding, loan contracts, or similar arrangements for tax purposes. The Court did not need to resolve every substantive issue because the assessment was already void for denial of due process. Businesses that rely on non-traditional financing structures should still maintain clear contracts, board authority, accounting recognition, bank records, and regulatory compliance documentation.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in defending deficiency tax assessments, preparing PAN replies and administrative protests, evaluating BIR third-party information findings, and litigating disputed assessments before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients identify procedural defects, build evidentiary records, and present practical defenses that align with Philippine tax law and CTA procedure.

If your business has received a Notice of Discrepancy, Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, Final Assessment Notice, or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, timely action is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team on your options before deadlines expire or collection action begins.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *