Petroleum importers may recover excise taxes on Jet A-1 fuel sold to exempt carriers, but only with strict tracing, timely filing, and complete proof.
Fuel importers and manufacturers claiming excise tax refunds must prove more than tax-exempt customers and timely filings: they must trace the taxed petroleum products from payment or removal, through storage and transfers, up to actual delivery to qualified international carriers or exempt entities. In this April 2026 decision, the Court of Tax Appeals allowed a substantial refund for excise taxes paid on Jet A-1 fuel, but reduced the claim where volumes, Aviation Delivery Receipts, certificates, withdrawals, and transfer documents did not fully match.
Background of the Refund Dispute
The taxpayer, a domestic petroleum company, sought the refund or issuance of a tax credit for excise taxes paid on locally produced and imported Jet A-1 fuel that was later sold and delivered during taxable year 2020 to international air carriers and tax-exempt entities. The total claim was P586,958,664.00, covering two periods: January 1 to June 30, 2020 and July 1 to December 31, 2020.
The controversy reached the Court after the taxpayer filed administrative refund applications with the Bureau of Internal Revenue and later judicial claims for the two periods (CTA Case Nos. 10750 and 10905). The Commissioner opposed the refund, arguing that the taxpayer was not entitled to claim the exemption, that the governing refund rule should be limited to the NIRC provision on removal of petroleum products, and that at least one administrative claim was not properly filed before the judicial action.
The Court Found the Refund Claims Timely Filed
The Court first addressed jurisdiction. For imported Jet A-1 fuel, it reckoned the two-year period from the date of actual payment of excise tax under Section 131(A) of the NIRC. For locally produced Jet A-1 fuel, it counted the two-year period from the date of removal from the place of production under Section 130(A)(2). Applying those reckoning points, the Court found that both the administrative and judicial claims were filed within the required two-year period.
The Commissioner argued that the administrative claim for the second half of 2020 was defective because documents had allegedly been returned by the BIR. The Court rejected this position. It found that the refund application itself bore the BIR stamped receipt dated April 11, 2022, and that what had been returned were loose documents for proper accounting, paging, and preparation of schedules, not the refund application itself. This distinction mattered because a refund case can fail if the administrative claim is missing or filed too late.
Why the Petroleum Seller Was the Proper Refund Claimant
The ruling is important for petroleum companies, airlines, and tax managers because it confirms that the statutory taxpayer may claim the excise tax refund when petroleum products are sold to qualified exempt buyers. The Commissioner argued that Section 135 of the NIRC benefits only the buyers, such as international carriers or exempt entities. The Court disagreed.
Relying on Supreme Court doctrine, the Court treated the importer or manufacturer of petroleum products as the statutory taxpayer for excise tax purposes. Even if the economic burden of the tax may be passed on to the buyer through pricing, that does not make the buyer the statutory taxpayer. The exemption under Section 135 therefore benefits the importer or manufacturer that actually bears the legal liability to pay the excise tax, not merely the purchaser that may shoulder the tax as part of the contract price.
Section 135 Exemption Requires Specific Proof
The Court applied the three categories under Section 135 of the NIRC. Sales to international carriers of Philippine or foreign registry must be for use or consumption outside the Philippines, with the petroleum products stored in a bonded storage tank and disposed of under applicable rules. Sales to exempt entities or agencies covered by tax treaties, conventions, or international agreements require proof of the applicable treaty or agreement and proof of use or consumption by the exempt entity. Sales to entities exempt by law from direct and indirect taxes require proof of that legal exemption.
The taxpayer submitted Civil Aeronautics Board certifications, Department of Foreign Affairs certifications, air service agreements or transport agreements, Aviation Delivery Receipts, commingling permits, sales invoices, withdrawal certificates, product movement records, and testimony from personnel handling storage, withdrawals, deliveries, and terminal operations. These documents helped prove that many of the fuel sales were made to qualified international carriers or exempt entities and that the fuel was connected to the taxpayer’s claimed excise tax payments.
Why the Court Reduced the Refund
The taxpayer did not receive the full P586,958,664.00 claim. The Court disallowed portions of the claim because tax refunds are construed strictly against the claimant, and the claimant must prove entitlement by competent evidence. Several volumes were rejected due to insufficient substantiation, including Aviation Delivery Receipts with local destinations not covered by exemption, no destination, unsupported entries, out-of-period dates, unreadable documents, and missing dates or signatures.
The Court also disallowed differences between the total sales volume examined and the volumes traced to certifications from aviation and foreign affairs authorities. Additional disallowances were made where the foreign registry or authority to operate international flights was not sufficiently proven. The Court further scrutinized the movement of Jet A-1 fuel from refinery or production sources to depots, into-plane facilities, refuellers, and direct deliveries. Where withdrawal certificates were missing, or where the taxpayer could not satisfactorily reconcile volumes issued by depots, into-plane facilities, and refuellers with volumes actually traced to the claim, the corresponding excise tax amounts were removed from the refundable amount.
Final Outcome: Partial Refund Granted
After reviewing the evidence, the Court found total disallowances of P197,465,168.00. It therefore partially granted the petitions and ordered the Commissioner to refund P389,493,496.00, representing erroneously paid excise taxes on imported and locally produced Jet A-1 fuel for the two 2020 periods that were subsequently sold and delivered to various international carriers and tax-exempt entities.
For taxpayers, the lesson is practical and evidence-driven. A valid legal exemption is only the starting point. Refund claimants must maintain a clean audit trail showing the tax paid, the source and movement of the petroleum products, the exempt status or international carrier status of the customer, the qualifying use or destination of the fuel, and the precise reconciliation between claimed liters and supporting documents. Any gap can reduce the refund even if the underlying transaction is generally exempt.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers
Businesses claiming refund or tax credit for excise taxes should prepare the case as if every liter must be independently traced. Petroleum companies should preserve import documents, ATRIGs, excise tax payment records, removal records, bonded storage permits, withdrawal certificates, depot records, Aviation Delivery Receipts, sales invoices, certifications, and reconciliation schedules. Aviation and fuel supply contracts should also be reviewed to ensure that tax-exempt sales can be supported by operational documents, not merely by commercial invoices.
The decision also reinforces a broader tax litigation point: timely filing does not guarantee recovery. The Court may accept jurisdiction and still cut down the refundable amount if the substantiation is incomplete. CFOs, tax managers, and customs brokers should therefore treat refund preparation as both a legal and accounting exercise, requiring coordination among tax, logistics, terminal operations, sales, and finance teams.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, exporters, customs brokers, and corporate groups in tax refund claims, excise tax disputes, BIR audits, customs controversies, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate refund entitlement, organize evidentiary records, prepare administrative claims, reconcile accounting and logistics documents, and represent taxpayers in contested proceedings.
For businesses facing a denied refund claim, a disputed assessment, or a high-value excise tax issue, early legal review can prevent avoidable disallowances and preserve the strongest possible record for litigation. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on Philippine tax litigation and Court of Tax Appeals representation.