A criminal tax appeal was dismissed as late because the 15-day period ran from DOJ receipt, not BIR receipt, leaving the CTA En Banc without jurisdiction.
Government prosecutors, BIR officers, and accused taxpayers in criminal tax cases must treat appeal deadlines as jurisdictional: once the 15-day period is missed, the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc may dismiss the appeal without reaching the merits of the alleged Tax Code violation.
Why the Timing of a Criminal Tax Appeal Mattered
The dispute arose from a criminal tax case involving an alleged violation of the National Internal Revenue Code. After the Court in Division issued resolutions dated June 24, 2024 and January 20, 2025, the government sought review before the Court En Banc. The En Banc had earlier dismissed the petition for review for lack of jurisdiction because it was filed beyond the applicable period. The government then asked for reconsideration, insisting that its appeal was timely because the Bureau of Internal Revenue received the adverse resolution later than the Department of Justice.
The procedural question was narrow but decisive: for purposes of appealing to the Court En Banc in a criminal tax case, should the 15-day period be counted from receipt by the DOJ, which acted as principal counsel, or from the later receipt by the BIR, which was the complainant or offended party? The resolution addressed that issue in the context of the government’s motion for reconsideration (CTA EB Crim. No. 185).
The Government’s Argument for Timeliness
The petitioner relied on Section 9(b), Rule 9 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, which gives an aggrieved party 15 days from receipt of the assailed resolution to file a petition for review before the Court En Banc. The government pointed out that the DOJ received the January 20, 2025 resolution on January 21, 2025, while the BIR received its copy on January 23, 2025.
Because the BIR was the complainant or offended party in the criminal tax case, the petitioner argued that the BIR’s receipt should control. Counting 15 days from January 23, 2025, the deadline would fall on February 7, 2025. Since the petition for review was filed on that date, the government maintained that the appeal was seasonably filed.
The petitioner also argued, in the alternative, that even assuming the DOJ’s January 21, 2025 receipt should control, the En Banc should still give due course to the petition in the higher interest of substantial justice. On that theory, the delay would have been only two days.
The Court Applied the Principal Counsel Rule
The Court rejected the motion for reconsideration. It emphasized that an appeal is not a natural or constitutional right, but a statutory privilege. A party who invokes that privilege must comply with the law and procedural rules that allow the appeal. The perfection of an appeal within the period prescribed by law is mandatory and jurisdictional.
The En Banc relied on the rule that, where a party is represented by a principal counsel and deputized or collaborating lawyers, service upon the principal counsel is decisive. The Court discussed prior Supreme Court authority holding that when the Office of the Solicitor General deputizes lawyers from a government agency, the OSG remains the principal counsel, and service of legal processes upon the principal counsel controls for purposes of computing the appeal period. The En Banc applied the same principle to the DOJ as principal counsel in the criminal tax case.
On that basis, the Court held that the DOJ’s receipt on January 21, 2025 triggered the 15-day period to file the petition for review. The later receipt by the BIR on January 23, 2025 did not extend or restart the appeal period. Consequently, the petition filed on February 7, 2025 was out of time.
Substantial Justice Did Not Cure the Late Appeal
The Court also rejected the request to relax procedural rules in the interest of substantial justice. While courts may relax procedural rules in exceptional cases, the En Banc stressed that they cannot acquire jurisdiction where none exists. Because the appeal was not perfected within the reglementary period, the Court had no jurisdiction to hear and determine the petition.
The result was that the government’s motion for reconsideration was denied for lack of merit. The prior dismissal of the petition for review for lack of jurisdiction stood. Importantly, the ruling turned on the procedural timeliness of the appeal, not on a final determination of the substantive criminal tax allegations.
What This Means for Taxpayers Facing Criminal Tax Cases
For accused taxpayers and responsible corporate officers, the ruling is a reminder that criminal tax litigation is often won or lost on procedure before the court reaches the merits. A late appeal by the prosecution can end the appellate proceeding even where the underlying case involves alleged violations of the Tax Code. Taxpayers defending criminal tax charges should therefore monitor not only the substantive allegations, but also whether the government complied with jurisdictional appeal periods.
The decision also matters for companies and individuals dealing with BIR criminal referrals because it underscores the importance of identifying the correct counsel of record. When government agencies and prosecutors both receive copies of court issuances, the controlling date may be the date of receipt by principal counsel, not the later date of receipt by the agency that initiated or supported the complaint.
What This Means for the BIR and Prosecutors
For the BIR and government prosecutors, the practical lesson is direct: internal coordination cannot be allowed to blur appeal deadlines. When the DOJ or another principal counsel receives an adverse CTA resolution, the countdown may already have started, even if the BIR receives its copy later. Filing teams should compute deadlines conservatively from the earliest binding receipt date and should not rely on a later agency receipt unless the rules and representation structure clearly support that computation.
This is especially important in criminal tax cases, where delay can prevent review of an adverse ruling. The government’s invocation of the public interest in enforcing tax laws will not necessarily overcome jurisdictional defects. Substantial justice is not a substitute for a timely perfected appeal.
Practical Takeaways for Businesses and Individuals
First, jurisdictional deadlines in CTA litigation should be treated as non-negotiable. Whether the case involves a tax assessment, refund, customs dispute, or criminal tax prosecution, missed appeal periods can be fatal.
Second, parties should determine who the principal counsel is and use that counsel’s receipt date as the safest starting point for deadline computation. In cases involving multiple lawyers, agency counsel, collaborating counsel, or deputized counsel, assuming that the latest receipt date controls can be risky.
Third, taxpayers should keep a detailed procedural timeline. Dates of receipt, filing, service, and resolution are not mere administrative details; they can determine whether the CTA has jurisdiction at all.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, corporate officers, and businesses in tax assessments, BIR investigations, customs disputes, criminal tax exposure, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice helps clients evaluate deadlines, preserve defenses, prepare pleadings, challenge defective proceedings, and develop practical strategies before disputes escalate.
If you are facing a BIR assessment, a tax fraud investigation, a customs seizure, or a pending case before the Court of Tax Appeals, early procedural review can make the difference between preserving your remedies and losing them. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.