Petroleum importers may recover excise tax on Jet A-1 fuel sold to international carriers when foreign use is proven by competent records.

Importers and petroleum companies that pay excise tax on fuel later sold to tax-exempt international carriers may recover the tax when they can prove that the product was used or consumed outside the Philippines, even if one airline customer lacks a foreign air carrier permit in the documentary record. For taxpayers handling excise tax refund or tax credit claims, the ruling underscores that the Court will look at the substance and probative value of the evidence, not merely the absence of a single regulatory document.

Background of the Excise Tax Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from a petroleum importer’s claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate covering excise taxes paid on imported Jet A-1 fuel. The fuel was imported in April 2019 and sold to various international air carriers from April to May 2019. The taxpayer filed an administrative claim with the Bureau of Internal Revenue for ₱71,182,352.00, representing excise taxes paid at ₱4.00 per liter on 17,795,588 liters of Jet A-1 fuel sold to international carriers.

The taxpayer later elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals after seeking recovery of the alleged erroneously paid excise taxes. The Division partially granted the claim, ordering the Commissioner to refund or issue a tax credit certificate for ₱70,767,488.00, but disallowed ₱414,864.00 corresponding to 103,716 liters sold to Deutsche Lufthansa AG because that airline was not included in the list of foreign air carriers with a valid Foreign Air Carrier’s Permit. Both sides appealed to the En Banc (CTA EB No. 3085, consolidated with the taxpayer’s separate appeal).

What the Taxpayer Had to Prove

The central issue was whether the excise taxes paid on imported Jet A-1 fuel became refundable when the fuel was subsequently sold and delivered to tax-exempt international air carriers. Under Section 135(a) of the National Internal Revenue Code, petroleum products sold to international carriers of Philippine or foreign registry are exempt from excise tax when used or consumed outside the Philippines, subject to the statutory requirements on bonded storage and disposition under applicable rules.

The Court identified three practical requirements for exemption in this type of claim. First, the taxpayer must prove the foreign registry of the international air carriers, or for Philippine-registered carriers, their authority to operate international flights. Second, the taxpayer must prove that the imported Jet A-1 fuel was used or consumed outside the Philippines. Third, the taxpayer must prove that the imported Jet A-1 fuel sold to international air carriers was stored in a bonded storage tank and disposed of in accordance with applicable rules and regulations.

The Commissioner’s Argument Was Rejected

The Commissioner argued that the taxpayer could claim a refund only for erroneous payment of excise taxes, and that the taxes were legally and validly collected because the taxpayer, as importer, was liable for excise tax. The Commissioner also argued that Section 135 of the Tax Code merely identifies exempt entities and should not be treated as the source of a refund remedy. In the Commissioner’s view, the taxpayer should have proceeded under the rules governing refunds for exported domestic products.

The En Banc rejected this position. It held that the Division committed no reversible error in recognizing the taxpayer’s entitlement to recover excise taxes under Section 135, in relation to Sections 204 and 229 of the Tax Code. The Court relied on established Supreme Court doctrine holding that when a statutory taxpayer pays excise tax on petroleum products that are later sold to international carriers covered by Section 135, the tax is considered illegally or erroneously paid and may be refunded or credited to the payor.

Why the Taxpayer Won the Full Refund

The more important part of the decision concerns the disallowed portion of the claim. The Division had ruled that the absence of a valid Foreign Air Carrier’s Permit for Deutsche Lufthansa AG prevented the Court from determining whether the Jet A-1 fuel sold to that airline was used or consumed outside the Philippines. On appeal, the taxpayer argued that the Aviation Service Returns, Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines certification, Department of Foreign Affairs certification, and the air transport agreement with Germany were enough to prove foreign use.

The En Banc agreed with the taxpayer. It emphasized that the Aviation Service Returns showed the details of the Jet A-1 fuel deliveries, including the origin and destination of the international carriers. The Court noted that the Division itself had recognized the probative value of these documents because they showed that the aircraft routes were between the Philippines and another country. For the En Banc, the absence of a Foreign Air Carrier’s Permit did not defeat the claim because the taxpayer had other competent documentary evidence showing that the fuel sold to Deutsche Lufthansa AG was used or consumed outside the Philippines.

As a result, the En Banc set aside the reduced refund amount and ordered the Commissioner to refund, or in the alternative issue a tax credit certificate, in the full amount of ₱71,182,352.00. This represented the taxpayer’s erroneously paid excise taxes on imported Jet A-1 fuel sold and delivered to tax-exempt international air carriers for the period from April to May 2019.

Key Legal Principle for Excise Tax Refund Claims

The ruling reinforces a taxpayer-favorable principle in petroleum excise tax refund cases: the exemption under Section 135 is not merely personal to the international carrier but is construed in relation to the petroleum products sold for qualifying international use. Where the statutory taxpayer, such as an importer or manufacturer, directly pays the excise tax and later sells the petroleum products to a qualified exempt international carrier, the taxpayer may seek refund or tax credit under the Tax Code if the payment becomes erroneous in light of the exemption.

Equally important, the ruling confirms that proof of use or consumption outside the Philippines may be established through the totality of evidence. A foreign air carrier permit may be useful, but it is not necessarily the exclusive evidence of foreign use. Documents showing actual flight route, destination, delivery, airline registry, and international operation may be decisive when they reliably connect the fuel sale to an international flight.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

Businesses claiming excise tax refunds or tax credits should preserve a complete documentation trail from importation, bonded storage, withdrawal, delivery, sale, and aircraft fueling. The documents discussed in the ruling show the kind of evidence that may matter: official register books, withdrawal certificates, delivery notes, invoices, Aviation Service Returns, supplier sales reports, and certifications from aviation or foreign affairs authorities. The stronger the documentary chain, the better the taxpayer’s chance of proving that the tax was erroneously paid.

For CFOs, tax managers, and customs or logistics teams, the lesson is that refund claims should be built before litigation begins. Each liter claimed should be traceable to an importation, a bonded storage record, an excise tax payment, a specific sale, an airline customer, and an international route. Gaps in documentation can reduce the refundable amount even when the legal theory is sound.

The ruling is also useful for taxpayers facing BIR resistance based on narrow documentary objections. If the BIR denies a claim because one document is missing, the taxpayer may still be able to prove entitlement through other competent records. However, this requires careful evidentiary preparation, witness testimony, and a clear presentation of how each document supports the statutory requirements.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, importers, fuel suppliers, logistics companies, and other taxpayers in prosecuting and defending tax refund, tax credit, excise tax, VAT, customs, and assessment disputes before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation team can review the documentary trail, identify evidentiary gaps, prepare administrative refund claims, and handle petitions before the Court of Tax Appeals when the BIR denies or fails to act on a claim.

For assistance with excise tax refund claims, tax credit certificates, BIR assessment disputes, or Court of Tax Appeals litigation, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *