A taxpayer’s VAT refund appeal may run from actual receipt of a timely BIR denial, not the 90-day lapse, when there was action rather than inaction.

Taxpayers pursuing VAT refunds or tax credit certificates should not be forced to guess whether a BIR denial exists but has not yet been received. When the Commissioner issues a written denial within the statutory 90-day period, the 30-day period to appeal should be counted from the taxpayer’s actual receipt of that denial, not automatically from the expiration of the 90-day period.

Background of the VAT Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from a claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate involving creditable input value-added tax. The taxpayer sought judicial relief after the Commissioner denied the administrative claim. The procedural issue became whether the taxpayer’s appeal period should be reckoned from actual receipt of the Commissioner’s written denial or from the lapse of the 90-day period for BIR action under Section 112(C) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended by the TRAIN Law.

In the earlier ruling, the Court En Banc granted the taxpayer’s petition for review and reversed the Second Division’s dismissal of the case (CTA EB No. 2903). The case was remanded to the Second Division for the proper determination of the refundable or creditable amount, if any. The Commissioner then moved for reconsideration, asking the Court En Banc to reinstate the dismissal on jurisdictional grounds.

The Commissioner’s Argument on Deemed Denial

The Commissioner argued that the TRAIN Law merely shortened the BIR’s period to act on VAT refund claims from 120 days to 90 days and did not abolish the deemed denial rule. Under this theory, a denial must not only be issued but also received by the taxpayer within the same 90-day period. Otherwise, the claim would allegedly be deemed denied upon the lapse of the 90 days, and the taxpayer would have only 30 days from that lapse to file an appeal.

The Commissioner relied on the view that failure to communicate the denial within the 90-day period should be treated as inaction. If accepted, this would mean that even where the BIR had already prepared and issued a written denial within the statutory period, the taxpayer might still be required to appeal from the expiration of the 90-day period if the taxpayer received the denial later.

The Taxpayer’s Position: There Was Action, Not Inaction

The taxpayer countered that the case was not governed by inaction at all. The Commissioner had issued a denial dated 05 June 2023, while the 90-day period ended on 29 June 2023. The taxpayer received the denial on 04 July 2023. Because the BIR had in fact acted within the statutory period by issuing a written denial, the taxpayer argued that the deemed denial doctrine never attached.

The taxpayer emphasized the unfairness of allowing the BIR to characterize a case as inaction after the BIR had already issued a written decision but communicated it belatedly. Such a rule would place taxpayers seeking VAT refunds in an impossible position: they would have to appeal without knowing whether the BIR had granted or denied the claim, and without knowing the legal and factual reasons for any denial.

The Ruling on the 90-Day Period and the 30-Day Appeal Period

The Court En Banc denied the Commissioner’s motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. It held that Section 112(C) of the NIRC, as amended by the TRAIN Law, requires the Commissioner to grant the refund within 90 days or, if the refund is not proper, to state in writing the legal and factual basis for the denial. The text of the law does not say that the taxpayer must receive the written denial within the same 90-day period.

Applying the plain meaning of the law, the Court concluded that the act required within the 90-day period is the Commissioner’s action: either to grant the refund or to state in writing the legal and factual basis for denial. Only if the Commissioner fails to perform that act within the prescribed period does a situation of inaction arise. Since the Commissioner issued a categorical written denial within the 90-day period, there was no inaction to be deemed a denial.

Why Actual Receipt Matters in VAT Refund Litigation

The Court relied on the framework recognized in VAT refund jurisprudence, where the law contemplates two scenarios: first, when the Commissioner issues a decision within the statutory period; and second, when no decision is made after the statutory period. In both instances, the taxpayer has a 30-day period to appeal, but the reckoning point depends on which scenario applies.

Where a decision is issued within the statutory period, the appeal period is counted from receipt of that decision. Where no decision is issued after the statutory period, the taxpayer may appeal based on inaction from the expiration of the period fixed by law. The case fell under the first scenario because the Commissioner had issued a denial within the 90-day period. The taxpayer’s 30-day period to seek judicial relief was therefore properly reckoned from actual receipt of the denial.

The Practical Problem the Court Avoided

The Court rejected a reading that would make judicial recourse a moving target. If taxpayers were required to appeal from the 90-day lapse even where an undisclosed BIR decision had already been issued, they could be forced to file a case without knowing whether the claim had been granted or denied. If the undisclosed decision later turned out to be a grant, the case could be unnecessary or moot. If it turned out to be a denial, the taxpayer may have filed without knowing the actual reasons to challenge.

The Court also noted that allowing the Commissioner to switch between action and inaction depending on what benefits the government would create confusion and unfairness. Taxpayers need a clear and predictable avenue for judicial relief, especially because the 30-day period to appeal to the Court of Tax Appeals remains mandatory and jurisdictional.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Seeking VAT Refunds or Tax Credit Certificates

Taxpayers should carefully track three separate dates in every VAT refund or tax credit certificate claim: the date of submission of complete supporting documents, the end of the BIR’s 90-day action period, and the actual date of receipt of any written denial. These dates determine whether the case is one of action or inaction, and therefore determine the proper deadline for appeal.

This ruling is helpful to taxpayers because it prevents the BIR from defeating judicial recourse through delayed communication of a written denial that was issued within the 90-day period. However, it does not relax the 30-day appeal period. Once the taxpayer receives a written denial, the appeal clock begins to run, and missing that deadline can still be fatal to the claim.

Businesses with recurring input VAT, exporters, zero-rated taxpayers, and companies seeking tax credit certificates should not treat VAT refund litigation as a purely accounting exercise. Procedural timing can decide the case before the Court even reaches the amount of the refund. Internal tax teams should preserve proof of filing, proof of submission of supporting documents, envelopes or receiving records showing when BIR decisions are received, and all correspondence with the BIR.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in VAT refund claims, tax credit certificate applications, BIR administrative proceedings, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice helps clients evaluate jurisdictional deadlines, prepare administrative records, respond to BIR denials, and file timely petitions before the Court of Tax Appeals.

If your company has a pending VAT refund, has received a BIR denial, or is uncertain whether the 30-day appeal period has already started, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax refund disputes and Court of Tax Appeals remedies.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *