The tax court reduced a 2018 BIR assessment for ignored PAN objections but sustained income tax, VAT, and EWT items lacking proof.

Taxpayers who answer a Preliminary Assessment Notice must be meaningfully heard, but they still need competent documents to defeat assessment items that remain factually supported. In this March 2026 assessment ruling, the Court of Tax Appeals reduced a multi-tax BIR assessment after finding that the revenue officers failed to address specific objections raised in the taxpayer’s Reply to PAN, yet still sustained deficiency income tax, VAT, and expanded withholding tax where the taxpayer failed to substantiate purchases and withholding compliance.

Background of the Dispute

The dispute involved deficiency income tax, value-added tax, expanded withholding tax, and compromise penalties for calendar year 2018. The BIR issued a Letter of Authority authorizing an examination of the taxpayer’s books and accounting records for all internal revenue taxes for the period January 1 to December 31, 2018. After a Notice of Discrepancy, the BIR issued a Preliminary Assessment Notice with details of computation and discrepancies. The taxpayer filed a Reply to PAN contesting the proposed assessment.

Despite the taxpayer’s reply, the BIR later issued a Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice reflecting deficiency income tax, VAT, and EWT totaling ₱3,121,495.00, plus compromise penalties of ₱208,417.62, for an aggregate assessment of ₱3,329,912.62. The taxpayer protested, but the BIR denied the request for reconsideration and treated the assessment as final, executory, and demandable. The taxpayer then elevated the dispute to the Court of Tax Appeals (Case No. 10850).

Why the Assessment Was Partly Voided for Due Process Defects

The central due process issue was not simply whether the BIR sent the required notices. The Court examined whether the BIR actually considered the taxpayer’s Reply to PAN before issuing the FLD/FAN. The taxpayer had specifically disputed, among others, the alleged undeclared purchases based on third-party AITEID or RELIEF data, the alleged undeclared sales derived from those data, the VAT consequences of the alleged undeclared sales, and the disallowance of input VAT allegedly tied to unsubstantiated purchases.

The Court compared the Details of Discrepancy attached to the PAN and the FLD/FAN and found them substantially identical. The basic tax deficiencies remained unchanged, with only interest and penalties recomputed up to the date of the FLD/FAN. More importantly, the FLD/FAN did not explain why the taxpayer’s objections were rejected, nor did it show how the taxpayer’s explanations and supporting submissions were evaluated.

Applying Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code, Revenue Regulations No. 12-99 as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 18-2013, and Supreme Court rulings on administrative due process, the Court emphasized that the right to be heard includes the BIR’s corresponding duty to consider the taxpayer’s explanations and give reasons when they are rejected. A taxpayer’s reply is not a ceremonial step. If the BIR merely repeats the PAN findings in the FLD/FAN without addressing specific objections, the affected assessment items may be void and unenforceable.

Why the Taxpayer Still Had to Pay Part of the Assessment

The taxpayer did not obtain a complete cancellation. The Court drew an important distinction: the due process defect affected only the assessment items specifically disputed in the Reply to PAN but left unaddressed in the FLD/FAN. It did not automatically void assessment items that were not specifically refuted or that remained supported by the evidence on record.

For income tax, the BIR asserted that purchases amounting to ₱1,772,780.74 were not substantiated by official receipts and supporting documents. The taxpayer argued that the computation did not sufficiently explain how the BIR arrived at the unsupported purchases, but the Court found that the taxpayer failed to present sufficient documents to refute the finding or substantiate the claimed purchases. The Court therefore sustained the disallowance of unsupported expenses and computed a basic deficiency income tax of ₱538,220.38.

For VAT, the same unsubstantiated purchases affected the taxpayer’s input VAT claims. Since the taxpayer failed to substantiate purchases of ₱1,772,780.74, the corresponding input VAT disallowance was also sustained. The Court computed the basic deficiency VAT at ₱233,883.48 after considering declared sales, allowable input tax, and VAT payments per return.

For expanded withholding tax, the taxpayer argued that he could not be treated as a top withholding agent without receiving individual written notice. The Court rejected that position. It held that Revenue Regulations No. 11-2018 governed and that publication of the approved list of top withholding agents in a newspaper of general circulation, with posting on the BIR website, constituted sufficient notice. Because the taxpayer’s name appeared in the published list, the obligation to withhold began on the first day of the month following publication. The Court sustained the basic EWT deficiency of ₱42,156.15.

Compromise Penalties Were Cancelled

The BIR imposed compromise penalties totaling ₱208,417.62 for alleged violations such as failure to file or pay taxes on time, failure to supply complete information, eFPS penalty, and failure to withhold or remit taxes. The Court cancelled the compromise penalties because compromise penalties require the taxpayer’s consent. Without proof that the taxpayer agreed to compromise, the Court cannot compel payment of those penalties. Their unilateral imposition was treated as illegal and unauthorized.

Final Outcome: Assessment Reduced, But Collection Still Allowed

The Petition for Review was partly granted. The Court upheld the assessments only in part and ordered the taxpayer to pay ₱1,300,093.89, inclusive of 25% surcharge and 12% deficiency interest computed until February 4, 2022. This amount consisted of sustained deficiency income tax, VAT, and EWT, with statutory additions. The Court also ordered delinquency interest at 12% per annum on the unpaid amount from February 5, 2022 until full payment.

Because the decision was partly favorable to the government, the Court authorized the BIR, through the Commissioner, to enforce collection to the extent of the findings in the decision, including by distraint or levy over sufficient property to satisfy the tax and increments due.

Practical Lessons for Taxpayers Facing BIR Assessments

This ruling is important for taxpayers dealing with PANs, FLDs, FANs, and disputed assessments. First, a Reply to PAN should be detailed, issue-specific, and supported by documents. The taxpayer’s objections matter because the BIR must address them when it proceeds to final assessment. A generic reply may not preserve enough issues; a well-developed reply can help narrow or defeat unsupported assessment items.

Second, taxpayers should not rely on due process arguments alone. Even if part of an assessment is voided because the BIR ignored taxpayer explanations, the Court may still sustain items that are independently supported by the record. Unsupported expense deductions and input VAT claims remain vulnerable if official receipts, invoices, schedules, reconciliations, and accounting records are incomplete.

Third, top withholding agent issues require careful checking of BIR publications and effective dates. The ruling confirms that individual written notice is not always required where the applicable regulations treat publication as sufficient notice. Businesses included in published lists must review their withholding obligations immediately because non-withholding can result in EWT assessments, surcharge, and interest.

Finally, compromise penalties should be questioned when there is no agreement. The BIR may propose compromise penalties, but they are not the same as basic tax, surcharge, or statutory interest. Without taxpayer conformity, they should not be imposed as collectible liabilities in the same manner as assessed taxes.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers at every stage of a tax dispute, from responding to Notices of Discrepancy and Preliminary Assessment Notices to preparing protests, Requests for Reconsideration or Reinvestigation, and petitions before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients identify due process defects, challenge unsupported third-party information, reconcile accounting records, defend deductions and input VAT claims, and manage collection risks after assessment.

If your company or business has received a PAN, FLD/FAN, FDDA, collection notice, warrant of distraint and levy, or other BIR assessment document, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco’s tax litigation team and assess your options before deadlines expire.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *