A criminal tax evasion case was dismissed after the government filed the Information too late and failed to comply with appeal and OSG authority rules.
Businesses and responsible corporate officers facing criminal tax cases should pay close attention to prescription, appeal requirements, and the authority of government counsel, because even a serious tax evasion charge may be dismissed when the government files too late or fails to perfect its appeal.
Background of the Criminal Tax Dispute
The case involved a hauling corporation and its responsible officers who were charged with alleged willful attempt to evade or defeat tax under Section 254, in relation to Sections 253(d) and 256 of the National Internal Revenue Code. The prosecution alleged that the taxpayer failed to file the necessary income tax return for taxable year 2012, resulting in a basic income tax liability of โฑ1,010,856.58, excluding interest and penalties.
The alleged violation was tied to the taxpayer’s supposed failure to file its 2012 income tax return on or before April 15, 2013. A joint complaint-affidavit was filed before the Department of Justice on June 29, 2016, but the Information was filed in court only on May 27, 2024. The Court in Division dismissed the criminal case on the ground of prescription, and the government elevated the matter to the Court En Banc (CTA EB Crim. No. 165).
The Government’s Appeal Was Timely, But Still Defective
The Court En Banc first recognized that the government’s petition for review was filed within the 15-day appeal period. The government received the denial of its motion for reconsideration on August 22, 2024 and filed its petition on September 6, 2024, which was within the reglementary period.
Timeliness, however, was not enough. The Court held that the government failed to attach duplicate originals or certified true copies of the assailed resolutions, as required by the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals and the Rules of Court. The government attached only photocopies. For the Court, this was a mandatory requirement for the perfection of an appeal, and non-compliance rendered the petition dismissible.
BIR and DOJ Lawyers Must Show Proper Authority in Appellate Criminal Tax Cases
The Court also ruled that the petition suffered from a separate fatal defect: it was not filed with proper authority from the Office of the Solicitor General. In appellate proceedings involving the People of the Philippines, the Solicitor General is the proper counsel. Although the Solicitor General may deputize legal officers of the Bureau of Internal Revenue or other government agencies, the deputization must be express, must identify the legal officers being deputized, and must preserve the OSG’s supervision and control.
The government relied on a BIR circular and a memorandum of agreement concerning the general deputization of BIR lawyers. The Court held that this was insufficient because the governing jurisprudence requires an express authorization naming the legal officers deputized for the specific case. The government also submitted a photocopy of an office order naming lawyers deputized by the Department of Justice, but the Court found that the order covered other CTA criminal cases and not this one.
This part of the ruling matters to taxpayers because criminal tax appeals are not merely technical contests on the merits. The government must also comply with the procedural and authority requirements that govern who may represent the People in appellate litigation. A petition filed by counsel without proper authority may be dismissed outright.
The Tax Evasion Charge Had Already Prescribed
Even though the Court could already dismiss the petition on procedural grounds, it still addressed the core issue: whether the criminal action had prescribed. Under Section 281 of the Tax Code, violations of the Code prescribe after five years. The provision states that prescription generally begins from the day of the commission of the violation, or, when the commission is not known at the time, from discovery and the institution of judicial proceedings for investigation and punishment.
The Court applied the doctrine in Lim, Sr., under which the government had five years from the filing of the complaint before the DOJ on June 29, 2016, or until June 29, 2021, to file the corresponding Information in court. Since the Information was filed only on May 27, 2024, the Court held that the government’s right to institute the criminal action had already prescribed for more than two years.
The Court also emphasized that prescription in criminal cases is a matter of substantive law. Even if prescription is not raised, a court may dismiss a case motu proprio when the pleadings or evidence on record show that the claim is already barred by prescription.
Why the Recent Supreme Court Ruling Did Not Save the Prosecution
The prosecution relied on the more recent doctrine that filing a criminal complaint before the prosecution office tolls the running of the prescriptive period. However, the Court En Banc noted that the Supreme Court declared that new rule to apply prospectively. Because the Information in this case was filed before that new doctrine was promulgated, and because the assailed resolutions were also issued earlier, the Court applied the older rule that was more favorable to the accused.
The Court reasoned that, in matters involving prescription of crimes, the interpretation more favorable to the accused must prevail. Applying that approach, the criminal case remained prescribed despite the government’s argument that proceedings before the DOJ should have interrupted prescription.
Key Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers
For corporate taxpayers, this ruling reinforces that criminal tax exposure should be analyzed not only by looking at the alleged deficiency tax, but also by reconstructing the procedural timeline. The date of the alleged violation, the date of discovery, the date of filing with the DOJ, and the date of filing of the Information in court may determine whether the prosecution remains viable.
For directors, presidents, treasurers, managers, and other responsible officers, the ruling is a reminder that criminal tax cases often name both the corporation and its officers. However, the government still bears the burden of filing within the applicable prescriptive period and complying with the procedural rules governing criminal tax appeals.
For businesses under BIR investigation, prescription should be assessed early. A taxpayer should not assume that a criminal complaint, preliminary investigation, or BIR referral automatically means the case can proceed indefinitely. Conversely, taxpayers should not rely on prescription without a careful review of the applicable doctrine, the dates involved, and whether newer rules may apply prospectively or retroactively.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, corporations, and responsible officers in tax assessments, criminal tax investigations, CTA litigation, and appeals involving the Bureau of Internal Revenue and other revenue authorities. Our tax litigation practice reviews assessment records, prescription timelines, authority-to-file issues, due process defects, and litigation strategy from the investigation stage through proceedings before the Court of Tax Appeals.
If your company or officers are facing a tax evasion complaint, deficiency tax assessment, or criminal tax exposure, early legal review can determine whether the case is defensible on the merits, procedurally defective, or already barred by prescription. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.