Splash cologne sales were held subject to excise tax as toilet waters, with VAT on excise tax, surcharge, and daily interest sustained.
Manufacturers and sellers of colognes, body fragrances, and similar personal care products cannot rely on the old three percent essential-oil threshold under RR No. 8-1984 to avoid excise tax if their products fall within the broader statutory and administrative treatment of perfumes and toilet waters. In this ruling, the taxpayer lost its challenge to a 2016 assessment on splash cologne sales, and the Court sustained a substantial excise tax and VAT-on-excise-tax liability, with surcharge and interest continuing until full payment.
Background of the Dispute
The taxpayer was engaged in manufacturing and trading personal care products, including a splash cologne product line with several variants. For taxable year 2016, the Bureau of Internal Revenue examined the taxpayer’s books and issued assessments relating to the sale of its splash cologne products. The disputed items focused on deficiency excise tax, VAT on excise tax, and related penalties arising from the BIR’s position that the splash colognes were taxable as toilet waters under Section 150(b) of the Tax Code.
After receiving the final decision on disputed assessment, the taxpayer paid the separate income tax and VAT items but elevated to the Court of Tax Appeals the remaining excise-tax-related assessment. In the March 17, 2026 decision involving the 2016 assessment (CTA Case No. 11163), the central issue was whether the taxpayer’s splash cologne sales were subject to deficiency excise tax and the corresponding VAT on that excise tax.
The Taxpayer’s Position
The taxpayer argued that its splash cologne products were not toilet waters for purposes of Section 150(b) of the Tax Code. Its theory depended heavily on RR No. 8-1984, which defined toilet waters as scented alcoholic or non-alcoholic preparations primarily used as body fragrance containing essential oils of more than three percent by weight. The taxpayer maintained that its splash cologne products had essential oil content below that level.
The taxpayer also argued that the excise tax provision should be read as applying to non-essential or luxury goods, not to low-priced, commonly used cologne products marketed to ordinary consumers. In substance, it asked the Court to treat its splash colognes as everyday, inexpensive personal care products rather than taxable perfumes or toilet waters.
The Commissioner’s Position
The Commissioner argued that colognes had long been classified by the BIR as toilet waters subject to excise tax. The Commissioner relied on prior BIR interpretation, including the position that all other colognes are classified as toilet waters under Section 150(b) of the Tax Code. The Commissioner also maintained that the taxpayer’s industry classification and claimed commercial standards could not prevail over the BIR’s interpretation of the tax law, especially absent proof that the assessment was plainly wrong.
Why the Court Rejected the Three Percent Essential-Oil Argument
The Court ruled that RR No. 8-1984 could not control the interpretation of Section 150(b) of the 1997 Tax Code, as amended. The reason was not merely technical. RR No. 8-1984 implemented the old percentage tax regime for cosmetic products under the 1977 Tax Code. The present provision, however, imposes an excise tax on perfumes and toilet waters. The Court treated that shift from percentage tax to excise tax as a substantive change in the law.
Because the old regulation was tied to a repealed or replaced tax framework, the Court held that the taxpayer could not use the three percent essential-oil threshold to defeat the excise tax assessment. The Court relied on the Supreme Court’s Avon rulings, which had already rejected the use of RR No. 8-1984 to determine which toilet waters are subject to the current excise tax under Section 150(b).
The Court also noted that the CTA En Banc had already addressed substantially similar arguments, including in a prior case involving the same taxpayer. In that earlier ruling, the CTA En Banc held that the taxpayer’s splash colognes were considered toilet waters under the Tax Code and were therefore subject to excise tax.
How RR No. 9-2023 Affected the Court’s Analysis
The taxpayer argued that the later issuance of RR No. 9-2023, which expressly includes colognes, splash colognes, baby colognes, body sprays, body mists, body splash, and similar products within the definition of toilet water, showed that the old RR No. 8-1984 definition must have governed before 2023. The Court was not persuaded.
For the Court, the decisive point was that RR No. 8-1984 no longer applied to the current excise tax regime. The absence of a newer implementing regulation before RR No. 9-2023 did not revive the old percentage-tax regulation. Instead, the Court held that, in the absence of a new implementing rule, the BIR’s general interpretation of the statute could prevail, consistent with the Supreme Court’s guidance in the Avon cases.
VAT on Excise Tax Was Also Sustained
The Court also sustained the assessment for VAT on excise tax. Under Section 106(A)(1) of the Tax Code, gross selling price for VAT purposes includes excise tax, if any, on the goods sold. This means that once excise tax is found to be due on the cologne products, the VAT base correspondingly increases.
The Court clarified that the VAT assessment was not a second VAT on total sales. It represented only the incremental VAT attributable to the excise tax that should have formed part of the gross selling price. On this point, the Court affirmed the basic deficiency VAT on excise tax in the amount of P5,949,109.49.
Final Amount Ordered Paid
The Petition for Review was denied for lack of merit. The Court ordered the taxpayer to pay P115,972,054.57, representing deficiency excise tax and deficiency VAT on excise tax, inclusive of the 25 percent surcharge and deficiency and delinquency interest under Sections 248(A) and 249(B) of the Tax Code.
The Court further ordered the taxpayer to pay delinquency interest at 12 percent per annum on the total amount due, equivalent to P38,127.80 per day, computed from April 24, 2023 until full payment. The Court also authorized collection remedies under Section 13 of RA No. 9282, including seizure, distraint, and levy, in sufficient quantity to satisfy the tax liability.
Practical Takeaways for Manufacturers, Importers, and Distributors
Businesses dealing in colognes, splash colognes, body sprays, body mists, aftershave lotions, and similar fragrance products should review whether their products may be treated as perfumes or toilet waters for excise tax purposes. The ruling is especially important for companies that historically relied on product concentration, essential oil percentage, price point, or consumer-market positioning to argue that their products are outside Section 150(b).
The decision also shows the importance of distinguishing between old tax regimes and current tax provisions. A regulation issued to implement a prior percentage tax system may not necessarily protect a taxpayer under the present excise tax framework. For tax managers and CFOs, this means that historical regulatory definitions must be tested against later statutory changes, Supreme Court doctrine, BIR issuances, and CTA En Banc rulings.
Finally, the case illustrates how an excise tax issue can create a second layer of exposure through VAT. If excise tax should have been included in the gross selling price, the BIR may assess not only the unpaid excise tax but also the incremental VAT on that excise-tax component, plus surcharge and interest. For businesses with high-volume consumer goods, the cumulative exposure can be significant.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in handling BIR assessments, disputed excise tax issues, VAT assessments, administrative protests, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation team can help evaluate whether an assessment is legally and factually defensible, prepare protest strategies, assess settlement or litigation risk, and represent taxpayers before the BIR and the CTA.
If your company is facing a BIR assessment involving excise tax, VAT, product classification, or alleged deficiency taxes, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation practice.