A VAT refund was partly granted after the taxpayer proved renewable energy zero-rated sales, but defects in input VAT documents reduced the claim.
VAT refund claimants supplying services to renewable energy projects must prove not only that their sales are zero-rated, but also that the underlying renewable energy project is properly supported by the required government registrations and that every peso of input VAT is backed by compliant invoices, receipts, and importation documents. The tax court partly granted a refund claim for unutilized input VAT, but reduced the recoverable amount after disallowing unsupported, overclaimed, and defectively documented input taxes.
Background of the VAT Refund Dispute
The taxpayer was a foreign corporation licensed to operate a Philippine branch engaged in geothermal aerated drilling services and related opportunities. It was registered as a VAT taxpayer and filed an administrative claim for refund of unutilized input VAT for the second quarter of taxable year 2019, covering the period from April 1, 2019 to June 30, 2019. The claim sought Php 2,600,948.34, representing creditable input VAT allegedly attributable to its zero-rated sales.
The BIR, through the relevant revenue region, denied the administrative claim. The taxpayer then elevated the dispute to the Court of Tax Appeals through a petition for review (CTA Case No. 10608). The Commissioner argued that the petition was filed out of time, that the taxpayer failed to fully substantiate the refund, that the sales to the renewable energy developer were not zero-rated, and that tax refunds must be construed strictly against the taxpayer.
Timeliness: The Taxpayer Filed Both Claims on Time
The tax court first addressed jurisdiction and timeliness. The taxpayer filed its administrative claim on June 30, 2021. Because the claim covered the second quarter of 2019, the filing was made within two years from the close of the taxable quarter when the zero-rated sales were made, as required under Section 112 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended.
The taxpayer also received the BIR denial on September 9, 2021. Ordinarily, the taxpayer would have had 30 days from receipt of the denial to seek judicial relief. However, the court considered the Supreme Court and Office of the Court Administrator circulars suspending filing periods due to the physical closure of courts during the COVID-19 pandemic. Taking those issuances into account, the court held that the petition filed on October 8, 2021 was timely. This rejected the Commissioner’s jurisdictional defense.
Renewable Energy Zero-Rating Requires Proof of the Project’s Registrations
The central substantive issue was whether the taxpayer’s services to the renewable energy developer qualified as VAT zero-rated transactions. The taxpayer relied on Section 108(B)(3) of the NIRC, in relation to Section 15(g) of the Renewable Energy Act of 2008. Under that law, renewable energy developers are entitled to zero-rated VAT on local purchases of goods, properties, and services needed for the development, construction, and installation of plant facilities. The zero-rating also extends to the process of exploring and developing renewable energy sources up to conversion into power, including services performed by contractors and subcontractors.
Importantly, the court clarified that the seller, supplier, or contractor rendering services to a renewable energy developer is not required to obtain its own prior DOE registration or accreditation merely to enjoy VAT zero-rating on its sales. However, the renewable energy developer’s project must be properly supported by the required DOE Certificate of Registration and BOI registration.
On the evidence, the court found that only the renewable energy developer’s projects in Tongonan, Leyte and Palinpinon, Negros Oriental were supported by both DOE and BOI registration documents. Other projects lacked BOI registration proof. The practical lesson is clear: contractors and suppliers dealing with renewable energy developers should not rely on general assertions of renewable energy status. They should secure and preserve project-specific DOE and BOI documents, especially when preparing a VAT refund claim.
Zero-Rated Sales Were Substantiated, But the Input VAT Claim Was Reduced
The taxpayer declared zero-rated sales or receipts of Php 53,388,121.19 for the second quarter of 2019. The court examined the official receipts and related billing invoices and found that the reported zero-rated sales were supported by zero-rated official receipts that complied with VAT invoicing requirements. The court also noted that the covered transactions were located at the Leyte geothermal site, which was supported by the required DOE Certificate of Registration and BOI registration.
Because the legal basis for the zero-rated sales was Section 108(B)(3) of the NIRC in relation to the Renewable Energy Act, the taxpayer did not need to prove that the sales were paid in acceptable foreign currency or that the foreign currency proceeds were accounted for under BSP rules. That requirement applies to other types of zero-rated transactions, not to this renewable-energy-based zero-rating theory.
The taxpayer, however, still had to prove the validity of the input VAT claimed. The court emphasized that VAT refund claims are litigated de novo, meaning the taxpayer must prove every material aspect of the claim before the tax court. It is not enough that a refund was administratively filed or that the taxpayer is generally engaged in zero-rated sales.
Why Part of the Refund Was Disallowed
The taxpayer claimed total input VAT of Php 2,600,948.34 from domestic purchases of goods and services and importation of goods. The court disallowed several portions of the claim. First, it denied Php 1,710.55 outright because the schedule of input taxes for local purchases supported a lower amount than what was declared in the VAT return. Second, based on the court-commissioned independent CPA’s findings, Php 190,768.60 was disallowed for failure to meet substantiation and invoicing requirements under VAT law and regulations.
The court then made a further disallowance of Php 163,286.40 because certain official receipts failed to indicate the nature of the payment, contrary to Section 113(B)(3) of the NIRC. Although some receipts referred to invoice numbers, the taxpayer did not submit the related invoices that could have allowed the court to cross-check the receipts and confirm the nature of the payments.
After total disallowances of Php 355,765.55, the court found that only Php 2,245,182.79 represented valid and substantiated input VAT for the second quarter of 2019.
Input VAT Was Attributable to Zero-Rated Sales and Remained Unutilized
The court also found that the substantiated input VAT was attributable to the taxpayer’s zero-rated sales. Since the taxpayer had no other type of sales except zero-rated sales for the period, the entire substantiated amount was treated as attributable to the zero-rated activity.
The court further held that the valid input VAT was not applied against output VAT during the same quarter or succeeding quarters. The taxpayer had no 12% VAT sales for the second quarter of 2019 and therefore had no output VAT against which the claimed input VAT could have been credited. Although the amount was carried over in later VAT returns, the court found that it remained unutilized until it was deducted as VAT Refund or TCC claimed in the amended VAT return for the first quarter of 2021.
Practical Takeaways for VAT Refund Claimants
For renewable energy contractors, suppliers, and service providers, this ruling underscores that VAT zero-rating should be documented at the project level. A contractor should secure copies of the renewable energy developer’s DOE Certificate of Registration and BOI registration for the specific project involved. Without those documents, sales connected to a renewable energy project may be vulnerable to challenge.
For CFOs and tax managers preparing VAT refund claims, the case is also a reminder that output VAT proof and input VAT proof are separate battles. Even if zero-rated sales are accepted, the refund can still be reduced if invoices, official receipts, importation documents, or schedules do not match the claimed amounts. The failure to indicate the nature of payment on official receipts can be fatal to a portion of the claim, especially when the related invoices are not offered in evidence.
The ruling also reinforces the importance of reconciling VAT returns, schedules, official receipts, invoices, SSDTs, SADs, and subsequent VAT returns before filing both the administrative claim and the judicial petition. A small mismatch may be denied outright, while larger documentation defects can materially reduce the recoverable refund.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, renewable energy contractors, and corporate groups in preparing, defending, and litigating VAT refund and tax credit certificate claims before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients evaluate refund eligibility, organize evidence, reconcile VAT returns and supporting schedules, address BIR denial letters, and build a court-ready evidentiary record.
If your business is pursuing a VAT refund, dealing with a denied tax credit claim, or supplying goods or services to renewable energy projects, early documentation review can determine whether the claim survives strict judicial scrutiny. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.