Excess CWT refunds may be proven in court with new evidence; the tax court affirmed a Php7.45M refund despite BIR objections.

Taxpayers seeking a refund or tax credit for excess creditable withholding taxes should not assume that their case is lost merely because the Bureau of Internal Revenue did not act on the administrative claim or later argues that the taxpayer failed to submit every document at the administrative level. In a March 2026 En Banc decision, the Court of Tax Appeals affirmed a multimillion-peso refund because the taxpayer proved, during trial, that its creditable withholding taxes were valid, unutilized, and properly supported by evidence.

Background of the Refund Dispute

The dispute involved a domestic corporation engaged in brokering transactions in foreign exchange, deposits, interest rate instruments, fixed income securities, bonds, repurchase agreements, certificates of deposit, bankers acceptances, bills of exchange, over-the-counter options, and related financial products. The taxpayer was registered with the BIR Large Taxpayers District Office and sought the issuance of a tax credit certificate for excess and unutilized creditable withholding taxes for calendar year 2017.

The taxpayer filed its administrative claim with the BIR on September 30, 2019, requesting a tax credit certificate in the amount of Php8,574,699.00. It later filed a judicial claim on April 8, 2020. After trial, the Division partially granted the claim. The refund amount was initially fixed at Php6,978,758.87, then increased in an amended decision to Php7,456,064.79 after the taxpayer’s partial reconsideration was partly granted. The Commissioner elevated the matter to the En Banc, arguing that the taxpayer was not entitled to a refund of alleged excess and unutilized CWT for 2017 (CTA EB No. 3016).

The Commissioner’s Main Objection

The Commissioner did not primarily dispute the factual findings made by the Division. Instead, the Commissioner argued that a judicial claim for refund before the tax court is an appeal from an unsuccessful administrative claim, not an original action. From that premise, the Commissioner contended that the taxpayer had to show not only that it was substantively entitled to the refund, but also that it satisfied all documentary requirements for the administrative claim. The Commissioner also invoked the familiar rule that tax refund claims are strictly construed against the taxpayer and in favor of the government.

The taxpayer countered that its evidence sufficiently showed that the income from which the CWTs were withheld was included in its gross income reported in its income tax return. It also argued that the Certificates of Creditable Tax Withheld at Source, or BIR Form No. 2307, sufficiently proved the existence and validity of the withholding taxes. The taxpayer further maintained that cases before the tax court are litigated de novo, so the court may receive and consider evidence even if such evidence was not submitted during the administrative stage.

The Petition Was Timely, But Failed on the Merits

The En Banc first addressed jurisdiction and held that the petition was timely filed. The Commissioner received the Division’s resolution denying reconsideration on October 15, 2024 and timely filed a motion for extension. The En Banc granted a non-extendible extension until November 10, 2024, which fell on a Sunday. The petition filed on November 11, 2024 was therefore treated as filed within the allowable period.

However, timeliness did not save the petition. The En Banc held that the Commissioner’s arguments did not justify disturbing the Division’s factual findings. Because the Commissioner adopted the factual findings of the Division and failed to show grave abuse of discretion, arbitrariness, or capriciousness, the En Banc deferred to the Division’s evaluation of the evidence. This was especially important because the tax court, as a specialized court, is given the highest degree of respect in factual matters involving tax refunds.

Judicial Refund Cases Are Litigated De Novo

The most important practical ruling is that a taxpayer may prove its refund claim before the tax court through evidence formally presented in the judicial case. The En Banc rejected the Commissioner’s position that the Division could consider only the documents previously submitted to the BIR in the administrative claim.

The En Banc explained that while a taxpayer must prove every minute aspect of a refund claim, this does not mean the tax court is restricted to the administrative record. Cases before the tax court are litigated de novo. The taxpayer must present, formally offer, and submit evidence to prove entitlement to the refund, but the court is not mechanically confined to what was earlier filed with the BIR. This is particularly significant where the BIR did not act on the administrative claim and did not issue a decision identifying missing documents or requiring further submissions.

For taxpayers, this distinction matters. A refund case is not won by merely filing papers with the BIR and waiting. It must be proven in court with competent evidence, including income tax returns, withholding tax certificates, accounting schedules, testimony, and, where appropriate, an independent certified public accountant’s report. But if the BIR later argues that documents were incomplete during the administrative stage, the taxpayer may still establish the claim at trial, subject to the rules on admissibility and the court’s appreciation of evidence.

Not Every Tax Refund Is Treated Like a Tax Exemption

The En Banc also rejected an overly broad use of the rule that tax refunds are strictly construed against taxpayers. The court distinguished between a refund based on a statute granting exemption or legislative grace, and a refund based on erroneous or excessive payment of tax. When a refund is based on erroneous or illegal collection, the claim is grounded on solutio indebiti: the principle that no one, including the government, should unjustly enrich itself at another’s expense.

Because the taxpayer’s claim involved excess and unutilized creditable withholding taxes under Sections 204(C) and 229 of the Tax Code, the claim was treated as one for the recovery of tax erroneously or excessively collected, not as a request for a tax exemption. The taxpayer therefore needed to prove its entitlement by preponderance of evidence, the standard ordinarily applied in civil cases, rather than by a stricter standard applicable to exemptions.

Practical Takeaways for Businesses Claiming CWT Refunds

Businesses with substantial withholding taxes should treat this decision as a reminder that refund claims must be built for litigation from the start. The administrative claim remains necessary, but the judicial case is where the taxpayer must fully prove entitlement. Taxpayers should ensure that BIR Form No. 2307 certificates are complete and consistent with their income tax returns, that the related income was actually reported, and that the claimed CWTs were not carried over or otherwise used against tax liabilities.

The ruling is also useful when the BIR does not act on an administrative refund claim. Inaction does not prevent the taxpayer from presenting evidence in court. However, this should not be read as permission to file incomplete or careless administrative claims. The safer approach is still to submit a well-documented administrative claim, preserve proof of filing, and prepare the judicial evidence before the two-year period under the Tax Code expires.

For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, the lesson is straightforward: creditable withholding tax refund claims are evidence-heavy. The refund will depend less on broad assertions of overpayment and more on whether the taxpayer can trace the withholding taxes to reported income, valid withholding certificates, and unused tax credits. Where the facts are properly documented, the government cannot defeat the claim simply by invoking a generic strict-construction rule.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in preparing, documenting, and litigating claims for tax refund or tax credit before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate whether excess creditable withholding taxes are recoverable, organize the supporting documents required for administrative and judicial claims, coordinate accounting and independent CPA review, and represent taxpayers in contested refund proceedings.

If your company has excess CWT, VAT, income tax, excise tax, or customs-related refund claims, or if the BIR has failed to act on your administrative claim, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *