A 2015 BIR assessment was cancelled after the FLD repeated the PAN without addressing the taxpayer’s reply, violating due process under Section 228.

Taxpayers facing a BIR deficiency tax assessment should carefully preserve and document every reply, protest, and supporting document submitted during audit because an assessment may be cancelled when the BIR issues a Formal Letter of Demand without genuinely addressing the taxpayer’s explanations. In this February 2025 resolution, the tax court refused to revive a 2015 assessment after finding that the BIR’s handling of the Preliminary Assessment Notice and Formal Letter of Demand violated the taxpayer’s right to due process.

Background of the Assessment Dispute

The dispute arose from a BIR assessment against a corporate taxpayer for taxable year 2015. The Preliminary Assessment Notice, issued and received on September 7, 2018, stated alleged deficiency liabilities for income tax, withholding tax on compensation, expanded withholding tax, fringe benefits tax, final tax, final VAT, documentary stamp tax, and compromise penalties. The total amount assessed at the PAN stage was P50,822,341.54.

The taxpayer filed a reply dated September 21, 2018 contesting the proposed assessment. The BIR later issued the Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices on September 27, 2018. The same total assessment amount of P50,822,341.54 appeared in the FLD/FAN. The taxpayer eventually elevated the dispute after the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment dated July 1, 2020, and the tax court’s earlier decision granted the petition, reversed and set aside the FDDA, cancelled the FLD/FAN, and enjoined the BIR from collecting the assessed amount (Case No. 10334).

The Commissioner’s Motion for Reconsideration

The Commissioner asked the court to reconsider the August 13, 2024 decision. The central argument was that the taxpayer supposedly failed to timely file its reply to the PAN. On that theory, the Commissioner claimed that the BIR could simply reiterate the findings from the PAN in the FLD. The Commissioner also argued that the taxpayer did not raise the due process issue in its protest or petition, and that the court should not have granted relief on an issue not specifically pleaded by the taxpayer.

The taxpayer opposed the motion. It argued that the BIR never treated the PAN reply as defective or late during the assessment process, and that raising the alleged lateness only at the reconsideration stage deprived the taxpayer of a meaningful opportunity to address the point. The taxpayer also emphasized that the BIR’s own records acknowledged the reply to the PAN and indicated that the taxpayer’s documents and explanations would be considered during the FAN stage.

The Tax Court Denied Reconsideration

The tax court denied the Commissioner’s motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. It held that the arguments raised had already been considered and passed upon in the earlier decision. More importantly, it reaffirmed that a tax assessment must comply with the taxpayer’s right to due process, including the requirement under Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code that the taxpayer be informed in writing of the law and the facts on which the assessment is made. Otherwise, the assessment is void.

The court also rejected the argument that it could not rule on an issue not specifically raised by the parties. Under Section 1, Rule 14 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, the court may rule on related issues necessary to achieve an orderly disposition of the case. The court cited Supreme Court authority confirming that the tax court is not strictly limited to the issues stipulated by the parties when a related issue is necessary to resolve the dispute properly.

Why the Identical PAN and FLD Mattered

A key factual point was that the PAN and the FLD reflected identical assessed amounts. The PAN assessed total liabilities of P50,822,341.54, and the FLD repeated the same total. The court also noted that both the PAN and FLD indicated interest computed until September 30, 2018, even though the PAN was issued on September 7, 2018 and the FLD was issued on September 27, 2018.

The court compared the internal memorandum recommending issuance of the FLD with the earlier memorandum recommending issuance of the PAN. It found the memoranda essentially identical, except for an added statement referring to the taxpayer’s reply to the PAN. That statement acknowledged the taxpayer’s response and said that the documents and explanations in the PAN reply would be considered or evaluated during the FAN stage. The court viewed this as important because the BIR’s own records showed that the taxpayer’s reply was acknowledged, yet the FLD proceeded without meaningful consideration of the taxpayer’s arguments and documents.

Due Process Requires More Than Repeating the Assessment

The court reiterated that the BIR is not required to accept a taxpayer’s explanations. However, when the BIR rejects those explanations, it must give reasons. It must state the particular facts and legal bases supporting its conclusions, and those facts must appear in the record. A taxpayer should not be left unaware of how the BIR appreciated, rejected, or disregarded the defenses raised during the assessment process.

This principle is especially important when a taxpayer has submitted a reply to the PAN. Even if the BIR believes the explanation is inadequate, the FLD/FAN and later FDDA must still show the factual and legal basis for the assessment. A mechanical repetition of prior findings may expose the assessment to cancellation if it shows that the taxpayer’s submissions were not genuinely evaluated.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Finance Teams

For CFOs, tax managers, corporate counsel, and accountants, the ruling reinforces the importance of building a clear audit record. Taxpayers should keep proof of receipt and filing dates, copies of PAN replies, attachments, protest letters, and all supporting documents. These records may become critical if the BIR later argues that a submission was late, insufficient, or unworthy of consideration.

The ruling also highlights a powerful defense in BIR assessment disputes: due process defects can invalidate the assessment and collection, even where the dispute involves substantial tax amounts. If the FLD/FAN merely copies the PAN, fails to discuss the taxpayer’s defenses, or does not explain why documents and arguments were rejected, the assessment may be vulnerable to challenge.

At the same time, taxpayers should not treat this ruling as permission to ignore deadlines. The safer approach remains strict compliance with the 15-day period to reply to the PAN and the statutory deadlines for protesting the FLD/FAN and appealing an adverse decision. Due process arguments are strongest when the taxpayer can show that it timely participated in the audit and that the BIR nevertheless failed to meaningfully address its submissions.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, business owners, and corporate finance teams in evaluating BIR assessments, preparing PAN replies and protests, challenging defective FLD/FANs and FDDAs, and litigating tax disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice focuses on identifying both substantive and procedural defenses, including due process violations, defective assessment notices, prescription, lack of authority, and unsupported factual findings.

If your company has received a PAN, FLD/FAN, FDDA, collection letter, warrant, or other BIR enforcement action, early review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on your tax assessment dispute and available remedies before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *