Airline won a partial excise tax refund after proving franchise exemption, in-flight use, and lower import costs for selected alcohol imports.
Airlines and importers claiming excise tax refunds cannot rely on a statutory tax exemption alone; they must prove, item by item, that the imported goods satisfy the conditions of the exemption and that the taxes were timely and erroneously collected.
Background of the Excise Tax Refund Dispute
The taxpayer is a domestic airline operating under a legislative franchise granted by Presidential Decree No. 1590. From July 2018 to April 2019, it imported various liquors and wines as part of its in-flight and commissary supplies. The Bureau of Customs billed the taxpayer for excise taxes on these alcohol importations in the total amount of P4,332,880.85, which the taxpayer paid under protest on February 12, 2020.
The taxpayer later filed an administrative claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate with the Bureau of Internal Revenue on February 9, 2022. It then elevated the case to the Court of Tax Appeals on February 14, 2022, seeking recovery of the full amount allegedly representing illegally collected excise taxes on alcohol products used for international in-flight consumption (CTA Case No. 10765).
Why the Court Had Jurisdiction Over the Refund Claim
The Commissioner challenged the refund claim, but the Court first addressed whether it had jurisdiction. Under Sections 204(C) and 229 of the National Internal Revenue Code, a taxpayer seeking refund of erroneously or illegally collected internal revenue taxes must file both the administrative and judicial claims within two years from payment of the tax. The administrative claim must also be filed before the judicial claim.
Because the taxpayer paid the excise taxes under protest on February 12, 2020, it generally had until February 12, 2022 to file both claims. The administrative claim was filed on February 9, 2022. The petition was filed on February 14, 2022 because the last day fell on a Saturday. On these facts, the Court treated the filing sequence and timing as sufficient for it to take cognizance of the case.
The Airline Franchise Exemption Remained Available Despite Later Tax Amendments
The central legal question was whether the taxpayer could still invoke its franchise tax privilege under Presidential Decree No. 1590 despite the enactment of Republic Act No. 9334, which amended Section 131 of the NIRC. The Commissioner argued that the later law repealed the taxpayer’s exemption and, even assuming the exemption remained effective, the taxpayer failed to comply with its conditions.
The Court rejected the broad repeal argument. Relying on Supreme Court rulings involving the same airline franchise, it held that the tax privilege under PD No. 1590 had not been revoked by the NIRC, as amended, including the amendment introduced by RA No. 9334. Under that franchise, payment of either basic corporate income tax or franchise tax, whichever is lower, may operate in lieu of other taxes, duties, charges, royalties, or fees, except real property tax, provided the statutory conditions are met.
Tax Exemption Still Required Evidence of Use and Local Non-Availability
The decision is important because it confirms that even where a franchise exemption exists, the taxpayer must still prove compliance with the exemption’s specific requirements. For importations of commissary and catering supplies, the Court applied three key requisites: the taxpayer must have paid the applicable corporate income tax or franchise tax; the imported supplies must be used in transport or non-transport operations or activities incidental thereto; and the supplies must not be locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price.
The taxpayer proved the first requirement through its annual income tax returns and corresponding payment forms for the relevant years. It also proved the second requirement through the Authorities to Release Imported Goods, which stated that the shipments would be used exclusively for international in-flight consumption. The Court treated the ATRIGs as prima facie evidence of the declared use, especially because such documents are issued only after verification by the tax authorities.
The third requirement became the decisive issue. The taxpayer presented witness testimony, a table of comparison, and price lists from local suppliers to show that the imported wines and liquors were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price. However, the Court did not accept the claim wholesale. It examined the importation cost per bottle against available domestic retail prices and allowed recovery only for products where the taxpayer’s evidence showed that importation was cheaper than local purchase.
The Refund Was Partially Granted, Not Fully Allowed
Out of the P4,332,880.85 refund claim, the Court granted only P3,472,366.86. The approved amount corresponded to excise taxes paid on specific imported products for which the taxpayer established that importation costs were lower than domestic purchase prices. These included certain wines, beer, vermouth, champagne, and other listed products supported by the comparison of importation costs and local price lists.
The balance of the claim was effectively denied because the taxpayer failed to prove entitlement for every imported item covered by the refund application. The Court’s approach shows that in a tax refund case, the taxpayer bears the burden of proving the claim with clear, specific, and competent evidence. A favorable legal theory does not automatically translate into a full refund if the documentary proof does not support each item being claimed.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers
Taxpayers seeking refunds or tax credit certificates for excise taxes, VAT, customs duties, or other internal revenue taxes should treat the case as an evidence-heavy proceeding. The Court will not presume entitlement to a refund simply because the taxpayer invokes an exemption, franchise, treaty, or special law. The taxpayer must establish both the legal basis for exemption and the factual basis for the amount claimed.
For importers, the ruling highlights the importance of preserving import documents, ATRIGs, customs entries, official receipts, sales invoices, supplier quotations, price lists, and internal procurement records. Where the exemption depends on local non-availability or price comparison, the taxpayer should prepare a product-by-product matrix showing foreign cost, exchange rate, duties or taxes paid, landed cost, comparable domestic price, and the source of the local price data.
For CFOs and tax managers, the ruling is also a reminder to monitor refund deadlines strictly. Administrative and judicial claims under Sections 204 and 229 of the NIRC are governed by a two-year period counted from payment. Missing that period can be fatal, regardless of the substantive merits of the refund claim.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, importers, airlines, logistics companies, and regulated businesses in tax refund claims, customs disputes, excise tax controversies, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate whether a refund claim is viable, organize the evidentiary record, prepare administrative refund applications, and represent taxpayers before the BIR, BOC, and CTA.
For businesses facing disputed excise taxes, customs assessments, denied refunds, or tax credit certificate issues, early legal review can make the difference between a recoverable claim and a denied case. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.