A taxpayer defeated a deficiency income tax assessment after the CTA held that the BIR must meaningfully consider a timely PAN reply before issuing final assessments.

Taxpayers who submit a timely and substantive reply to a Preliminary Assessment Notice should not be met with a final assessment that simply repeats the same findings without addressing their explanations. In a February 2025 resolution, the Court of Tax Appeals reinforced that due process in tax assessments requires more than issuing the proper forms: the BIR must meaningfully consider the taxpayer’s arguments before proceeding to a Final Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment.

Background of the Assessment Dispute

The case involved a deficiency income tax assessment for taxable year 2016 against a broadcasting company. The BIR issued a Preliminary Assessment Notice, followed by a Formal Letter of Demand, Final Assessment Notice, and eventually a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment. The disputed assessment reached P21,597,097.96, inclusive of interest, based on deficiency income tax findings that included the disallowance of management fees.

The taxpayer challenged the assessment before the Court of Tax Appeals, arguing that its right to due process had been violated because the BIR did not meaningfully address the explanations and documents it submitted in response to the Preliminary Assessment Notice. In the earlier decision, the Court granted the petition, cancelled the Formal Letter of Demand and Assessment Notice dated December 6, 2019, reversed and set aside the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment dated October 22, 2021, and enjoined the Commissioner from collecting the assessed amount (CTA Case No. 10687).

Why the Commissioner Sought Reconsideration

The Commissioner moved for reconsideration, arguing that the Court should reverse its earlier decision. The core position of the Commissioner was that the BIR was not required to reply to the taxpayer’s response to the Preliminary Assessment Notice. The Commissioner relied on Section 3.1.1 of Revenue Regulations No. 12-99, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 18-13, and maintained that the factual and legal bases of the assessment had already been disclosed to the taxpayer.

The Commissioner also argued that even assuming the BIR had responded to the taxpayer’s Preliminary Assessment Notice reply, the result would have remained the same. From the BIR’s perspective, repeating the findings in the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment did not amount to a denial of due process because the taxpayer had already been informed of the basis of the assessment.

The Taxpayer’s Position on Due Process

The taxpayer countered that the requirement to state factual and legal bases is not satisfied by merely citing a Tax Code provision without engaging with the taxpayer’s actual objections. The taxpayer emphasized that the Details of Discrepancies attached to the Preliminary Assessment Notice and the Final Assessment Notice/Formal Letter of Demand merely cited Section 34(A)(1) of the Tax Code without adequately addressing the taxpayer’s explanations regarding the disallowed management fees.

The taxpayer also relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Avon Products Manufacturing, Inc., which recognized that due process in tax assessments has two essential aspects. First, the taxpayer must be given a fair and reasonable opportunity to explain its side. Second, the decision-maker must give due consideration to the taxpayer’s arguments and evidence. The taxpayer argued that it submitted official receipts and other commercial documents to support the deductibility of the management fees as ordinary and necessary business expenses.

The Court’s Ruling: The Motion for Reconsideration Was Denied

The Court denied the Commissioner’s Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. It maintained that the BIR’s failure to engage meaningfully with the taxpayer’s reply to the Preliminary Assessment Notice undermined the legality of the final assessment documents. Because the Commissioner failed to successfully rebut this finding, the prior cancellation of the assessment stood.

The Court also clarified an important point in the assessment process. It noted that the Commissioner repeatedly referred to the BIR as responding or replying to the Preliminary Assessment Notice, when the BIR actually issues the Preliminary Assessment Notice. While this misstatement did not affect the outcome, the Court reminded the Commissioner to exercise greater care in preparing and filing motions and court submissions.

Why the Preliminary Assessment Notice Stage Matters

The Court stressed that the Preliminary Assessment Notice stage is significant because it gives both the taxpayer and the BIR an opportunity to resolve disputes early. This stage is not a meaningless procedural checkpoint. It exists to allow the taxpayer to contest the proposed findings before a final assessment is issued, and to give the BIR an opportunity to evaluate whether its preliminary findings should be maintained, modified, or withdrawn.

The Court recognized that Section 228 of the Tax Code does not require a taxpayer to respond to a Preliminary Assessment Notice. However, when a taxpayer does submit a reply within the prescribed fifteen-day period, the BIR must wait for and consider that reply before preparing the Final Assessment Notice or Formal Letter of Demand. A final assessment that ignores the taxpayer’s timely objections may be vulnerable to cancellation for violation of due process.

Meaningful Consideration Is Not the Same as Mechanical Repetition

The ruling is important because it distinguishes between mechanical compliance and meaningful compliance. The BIR cannot cure due process issues by simply issuing the standard assessment documents if those documents fail to show that the taxpayer’s explanations were actually considered. Repeating the same findings from the Preliminary Assessment Notice, without addressing the taxpayer’s refutations and evidence, may render the assessment void.

For taxpayers, this means that a well-prepared reply to a Preliminary Assessment Notice can become a crucial part of the litigation record. If the BIR later issues a final assessment that does not engage with the reply, the taxpayer may have a strong due process argument before the Court of Tax Appeals. For the BIR, the ruling underscores the need to evaluate the taxpayer’s evidence and explain why the agency accepts or rejects the taxpayer’s position.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers Facing BIR Assessments

Taxpayers should treat the Preliminary Assessment Notice stage as a serious opportunity to build the foundation for either settlement, administrative resolution, or future litigation. A taxpayer should submit a timely, complete, and evidence-backed reply that directly addresses each item in the Details of Discrepancies. Unsupported general denials are rarely enough. The reply should identify the relevant facts, attach supporting documents, and explain the legal basis for the taxpayer’s position.

Companies facing disallowance of expenses, such as management fees, service fees, related-party charges, or other deductions, should ensure that their documents establish the nature of the service, the business purpose, the ordinary and necessary character of the expense, and the connection to taxable operations. Official receipts and commercial documents may help, but they should be organized and explained in a way that allows the BIR, and later the Court, to understand the transaction.

Taxpayers should also carefully compare the Preliminary Assessment Notice, the Final Assessment Notice, the Formal Letter of Demand, and the Final Decision on Disputed Assessment. If the later documents merely repeat the earlier findings and fail to address the taxpayer’s reply, that pattern may support an argument that the assessment violated due process. In Court of Tax Appeals litigation, the issue is not only whether the BIR used the correct forms, but whether the taxpayer’s right to be heard was real and meaningful.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers in all stages of tax controversy, from responding to BIR audit findings and Preliminary Assessment Notices to protesting Final Assessment Notices and litigating before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients identify procedural defects, prepare evidence-based defenses, challenge unsupported assessments, and develop strategies for settlement or litigation when collection risk becomes imminent.

For businesses, corporate officers, accountants, and individuals facing a BIR assessment, early action is critical. A carefully drafted Preliminary Assessment Notice reply can shape the entire case. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team on assessment defense, due process objections, deficiency tax disputes, and Court of Tax Appeals representation.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *