Petroleum importers may recover excise taxes on fuel sold to exempt international carriers, but refund claims still fail without strict proof of foreign use.

Petroleum importers claiming excise tax refunds on Jet A-1 fuel sold to international air carriers must prove both the legal exemption and the factual use of the fuel outside the Philippines; a valid refund theory will not save a claim that lacks the required supporting evidence for a particular carrier.

Background of the Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from a petroleum company’s claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate for excise taxes paid on imported Jet A-1 fuel sold and delivered to tax-exempt international air carriers from April to May 2019. In the earlier decision, the Court partially granted the claim and ordered the Commissioner to refund or issue a tax credit certificate in the amount of PHP 70,767,488.00, representing erroneously paid excise taxes on imported Jet A-1 fuel sold to qualified international carriers.

After that decision, both sides sought partial reconsideration. The Commissioner argued that excise tax liability arose upon importation and that, when the importer sells the fuel to an exempt entity and cannot pass on the tax burden, the importer must bear that burden. The taxpayer, on the other hand, sought to expand or preserve its refund position by insisting that the evidence showed that fuel sold to Deutsche Lufthansa AG was consumed outside the Philippines (CTA Case No. 10502).

The Court Denied Both Motions for Reconsideration

The Court denied both motions for lack of merit. It refused to disturb the earlier partial grant of the refund, but it also refused to allow the taxpayer’s claim as to the fuel sold to Deutsche Lufthansa AG because the taxpayer failed to present sufficient evidence that the fuel was used or consumed outside the Philippines.

For the Commissioner’s motion, the Court found that the arguments were merely a rehash of points already raised in the pleadings and previously addressed in the decision. The Court maintained that the taxpayer, as the statutory taxpayer that paid the excise taxes on petroleum products sold to international carriers, may be entitled to a refund or tax credit when the petroleum products fall within the exemption under Section 135 of the National Internal Revenue Code.

For the taxpayer’s motion, the Court held that the evidence presented did not cure the evidentiary gap identified in the decision. The taxpayer relied on aviation service returns, a judicial affidavit, a certification from the Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines, and the air transport agreement with Germany. However, the Court found these insufficient because the taxpayer failed to present Deutsche Lufthansa AG’s Foreign Air Carrier Permit issued by the Civil Aeronautics Board.

Why the Excise Tax Refund Was Partially Allowed

The ruling confirms an important principle for petroleum companies and fuel importers: excise tax on petroleum products is imposed on the statutory taxpayer, such as the manufacturer, producer, or importer. When the statutory taxpayer pays excise tax on petroleum products that are later sold to entities exempt under Section 135 of the NIRC, the tax may be treated as erroneously or illegally paid and may be refunded or credited under Section 204 of the NIRC.

The Court relied on prior Supreme Court guidance involving petroleum products sold to international carriers. In substance, the exemption under Section 135 is construed in favor of the petroleum products themselves. Because of that, the importer who actually paid the excise tax may be the proper claimant for refund or tax credit, even though the transaction involves sales to exempt international carriers.

This is a significant point for petroleum importers because it rejects the simplistic argument that the importer must always absorb the excise tax once the fuel is imported. The Court’s approach recognizes that where the law exempts the petroleum products sold to specified entities, the statutory taxpayer’s payment may become recoverable if the taxpayer can prove that the legal and factual requirements for refund are met.

Why the Claim Failed as to Deutsche Lufthansa AG

The taxpayer’s problem was not the absence of a legal theory. The problem was proof. The Court found that, for the fuel sold to Deutsche Lufthansa AG, the taxpayer failed to prove that the imported Jet A-1 fuel products were used or consumed outside the Philippines.

The taxpayer argued that Deutsche Lufthansa AG was not an on-line carrier maintaining regular flight operations from the Philippines to another country and therefore had no Foreign Air Carrier Permit from the Civil Aeronautics Board. The taxpayer also claimed that, without such permit, the carrier could land at the Ninoy Aquino International Airport only for maintenance or refueling purposes.

The Court did not accept those allegations because allegations are not evidence. Without an evidentiary basis showing that the Foreign Air Carrier Permit requirement could be dispensed with, the Court could not credit the taxpayer’s position. The Court emphasized that the taxpayer was required to show that the carrier was armed with a permit to operate scheduled international services to and from the Philippines. Without that permit, the Court could not determine whether the fuel was used or consumed outside the Philippines.

Key Legal Principles for Tax Refund Claims

The ruling illustrates the strict nature of tax refund litigation. A claim for refund is treated similarly to a tax exemption and is strictly construed against the claimant. This means the taxpayer bears the burden of proving every factual and legal element of the claim.

It is not enough to show that the buyer is an international carrier or that the product is generally of a type used for international aviation. The claimant must present competent evidence connecting the specific sale, the specific carrier, and the specific statutory exemption. Where the exemption depends on use or consumption outside the Philippines, the taxpayer must be ready to prove that factual requirement through documents acceptable to the Court.

The decision also shows that motions for reconsideration are not opportunities to simply repeat arguments already rejected. For the Commissioner, reasserting that excise tax liability arose upon importation did not overcome the Court’s reliance on Supreme Court rulings allowing refund or credit of excise taxes paid on petroleum products sold to exempt international carriers. For the taxpayer, restating the relevance of existing evidence did not overcome the absence of the specific permit the Court considered necessary.

Practical Takeaways for Petroleum Importers and International Carrier Transactions

Petroleum companies, aviation fuel suppliers, and importers should treat this ruling as a documentation warning. Refund claims involving excise taxes on Jet A-1 fuel require more than invoices, delivery records, and general certifications. The claimant should secure and preserve carrier-specific regulatory permits, flight-related documents, delivery records, tax payment documents, and evidence showing that the fuel was used or consumed outside the Philippines.

For CFOs and tax managers, the practical lesson is to review refund documentation before the administrative claim is filed, not only when the case reaches the Court of Tax Appeals. Missing regulatory permits or incomplete proof of foreign consumption can result in a partial denial even where the taxpayer’s overall legal position is correct.

For customs brokers and logistics teams, the ruling underscores the importance of aligning importation records, excise tax payment records, aviation fuel delivery documents, and carrier documentation. Tax litigation outcomes often turn on whether the documentary trail is complete and internally consistent.

For corporate counsel, the ruling is also a reminder that tax refund claims should be prepared as litigation files from the beginning. The taxpayer must anticipate that the Commissioner will challenge not only the legal basis for the refund but also the sufficiency of every document used to prove entitlement.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises and represents taxpayers, importers, fuel suppliers, and corporate groups in tax refund claims, excise tax disputes, BIR assessments, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can assist in evaluating refund eligibility, preparing administrative refund claims, reviewing documentary evidence, developing litigation strategy, and representing clients before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals.

For businesses dealing with excise tax refunds, VAT refunds, customs disputes, or contested tax assessments, early legal review can determine whether the claim is properly documented before critical deadlines expire. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *