CTA En Banc upholds seizure and forfeiture of USD 491,600 for failure to declare foreign currency at NAIA. Petitioners’ offer of settlement was denied due to fraud.
Travelers and businesses importing foreign currency into the Philippines must now exercise heightened diligence when declaring amounts exceeding USD 10,000. A recent Court of Tax Appeals En Banc decision reaffirms that failure to declare foreign currency is subject to seizure and forfeiture under the Customs Modernization and Tariff Act (CMTA), even when the omission may have been unintentional or partially assisted by companions.
Background
The case involved petitioners Chang L. Mohammad, Sharalyn S. Pedrena, Johnny S. Yusup, Ferdaus A. Omar, and Armand P. Daud, all associated with SSP Money Changer. Mohammad arrived in Manila from Hong Kong carrying two bags totaling USD 649,600. He declared only USD 148,000 on the required Foreign Currency Declaration Form (FCDF), resulting in a Warrant of Seizure and Detention for the remaining USD 491,600. The petitioners sought release of 70% of the seized currency under a proposed settlement, which was denied by the NAIA District Collector and later affirmed by the Commissioner of Customs and the Court in Division (CTA Case No. 10346)
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
CTA En Banc Ruling
The En Banc Court confirmed that the Petition for Review was timely filed and addressed the substantive issue of whether the denial of the offer of settlement was proper. The Court ruled that Mohammad’s failure to declare the full amount constituted actual fraud. Evidence, including admissions during administrative proceedings, showed that Mohammad had sole responsibility to declare the currency. The Court emphasized that forfeiture proceedings are in rem and target the property, not the person. Even absent intent to defraud, seizure and forfeiture were appropriate because the currency was undeclared in writing, contrary to Sections 1113 and 1404 of the CMTA and implementing regulations under CAO 1-2017
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
Legal Principles Applied
The Court applied several critical provisions under Philippine customs law: (1) Section 216 of the CMTA grants the Commissioner authority to seize goods subject to forfeiture; (2) Section 1113 identifies undeclared goods, including currency, as subject to seizure; (3) Section 1404 mandates seizure for failure to declare; and (4) Section 1124 sets conditions for settlement of seized goods, barring acceptance where fraud is present or release would contravene law. Jurisprudence confirmed that fraud must be actual and intentional to prevent settlement, and the burden of proof in forfeiture proceedings rests on the claimant. Self-serving statements or mere allegations without corroborating evidence are insufficient to negate fraud
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
Practical Implications
For importers, money changers, and travelers, this ruling underscores the necessity of accurate written declaration of all foreign currency. Reliance on verbal disclosure, companions, or assumptions of good faith is insufficient to prevent forfeiture. Financial institutions and businesses involved in currency handling should implement strict internal compliance measures and ensure that staff understand their declaration obligations. Settlements or offers to pay a fine are discretionary and may be denied if any ground for fraud or improper declaration exists.
Key Takeaways
1. Undeclared foreign currency exceeding USD 10,000 is subject to seizure and forfeiture regardless of intent to conceal. 2. Offers of settlement by payment of a fine may be rejected if fraud or regulatory non-compliance is present. 3. Written declaration is mandatory; verbal declarations or partial disclosures do not suffice. 4. Administrative and judicial proceedings require substantiated evidence; self-serving statements are insufficient. 5. Burden of proof in forfeiture cases lies with the claimant seeking release of seized goods.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Businesses, travelers, and currency handlers facing customs seizures can seek strategic guidance to protect their interests. Our team provides compliance reviews, representation in forfeiture and settlement proceedings, and litigation support before the Court of Tax Appeals. For expert assistance navigating complex customs and foreign currency issues, visit