The CTA en banc upheld Grid Solutions US’s refund of PHP 8.68M CGT, confirming tax treaty exemption and substantial compliance with procedural requirements.
Businesses and investors with cross-border transactions between the Philippines and the United States should note that capital gains arising from the sale of shares in a Philippine corporation may not be taxable in the Philippines if the seller is a U.S. resident and the corporation’s assets do not principally consist of Philippine real property. Taxpayers in similar situations must carefully assess their asset composition and the applicable tax treaty to determine their refund or exemption rights.
Background
Grid Solutions (U.S.) LLC, a Delaware-based corporation, sold its shares in General Electric Philippines Meter & Instrument Company, Inc. (GE PH) to Aclara Meters LLC on June 29, 2017, resulting in a net capital gain of approximately PHP 86.88 million. Although Grid Solutions US initially paid capital gains tax (CGT) of PHP 8,683,100, it later sought a refund under the RP-US Tax Treaty, asserting that the gain should only be taxable in the United States because GE PH’s assets did not principally consist of real property located in the Philippines. The administrative claim was filed in June 2019, followed by a judicial claim before the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) Second Division (CTA Case No. 10146)
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
CTA’s Ruling
The Court affirmed the taxpayer’s entitlement to a refund, highlighting three key points. First, Grid Solutions US filed both administrative and judicial claims within the two-year reglementary period under Section 229 of the National Internal Revenue Code. Second, the delayed submission of the Apostilled Verification and Certification of Non-Forum Shopping and Director’s Certificate was deemed substantial compliance due to distance and time constraints. Third, the audited financial statements demonstrated that Philippine real property assets of GE PH were significantly below the 50% threshold specified under Revenue Regulations No. 04-86, confirming that the capital gains were exempt from Philippine CGT under Article 14(2) of the RP-US Tax Treaty
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
Key Legal Principles
The Court emphasized that substantial compliance with verification and certification requirements is sufficient where rigid application would frustrate justice. The refund claim was grounded in the erroneous payment of CGT and supported by Section 229 of the Tax Code. Tax treaties, specifically the RP-US Tax Treaty, allocate taxing rights for capital gains: gains from the sale of shares by a U.S. resident are taxable exclusively in the U.S. unless more than 50% of the corporation’s assets are Philippine real property. Revenue Regulations No. 04-86 provide that audited or unaudited financial statements may be used to determine asset composition, allowing Grid Solutions US to substantiate its claim
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
Practical Takeaways
For investors and corporations with U.S.-Philippine cross-border transactions, this decision underscores the importance of accurate asset assessment and documentation. Taxpayers must maintain thorough audited or interim financial statements to demonstrate the composition of assets at the time of a transaction. Furthermore, timely filing of administrative and judicial claims is critical to preserve refund rights. Even when the deposit slip indicates a different payor, the statutory taxpayer has legal standing to claim a refund if the tax was paid on their account. Businesses should also be aware that substantial compliance with procedural requirements can protect refund claims, particularly in international contexts.
How We Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco specializes in Philippine tax litigation and cross-border tax advisory services. Our team helps corporate clients and investors navigate refund claims, ensure compliance with tax treaties, and effectively document financial evidence to support their rights before the BIR and the CTA. For guidance on capital gains, treaty relief, and refund claims, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to schedule a consultation.