CTA En Banc affirms that SOAs issued for permit renewal are not assessments under Section 195 LGC; taxpayers may recover overpaid LBT via Section 196 remedies.
Businesses that prepay local business taxes through Statements of Account (SOAs) for permit renewal are not automatically bound by Section 195 of the Local Government Code (LGC). Taxpayers may now recover alleged excess payments using Section 196 remedies when the SOA fails to constitute a proper notice of assessment.
Background
Royal Cargo Inc. paid its local business tax (LBT) for 2020 to the City Treasurer of Paranaque City to secure its Mayor’s Permit. The payments covered the first three quarters of the year, totaling over PHP 18 million, as reflected in an SOA issued by the city (CTA EB No. 2908). In November 2021, Royal Cargo filed a written claim for refund of approximately PHP 12.3 million, asserting it had overpaid the LBT. The company subsequently filed a judicial claim for refund before the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Paranaque City in February 2022. The RTC dismissed the case on the ground of prescription, finding that the SOA constituted a valid assessment and that Royal Cargo’s appeal was untimely.
CTA En Banc Ruling
The Court En Banc affirmed the CTA Division’s decision that the SOA issued by the City Treasurer was not an assessment under Section 195 of the LGC. The Court emphasized that a valid notice of assessment must provide the taxpayer with sufficient information on the tax, amount due, period covered, and any applicable penalties to allow an intelligent protest. Here, the SOA merely summarized the amounts payable for permit renewal without indicating deficiency taxes, surcharges, interests, or penalties, and was signed by the BPLO Chief rather than the City Treasurer. Therefore, the SOA could not serve as the legal basis for a Section 195 protest.
Because the SOA did not constitute an assessment under Section 195, Royal Cargo properly invoked Section 196 of the LGC. The En Banc Court cited precedents including Tigerway Facilities and Resource, Inc., confirming that Section 196 allows a taxpayer to file a written claim for refund within two years from payment, followed by a judicial action, when no valid assessment exists. Royal Cargo satisfied both requisites by filing its administrative claim in November 2021 and judicial claim in February 2022, well within the prescriptive periods.
Key Legal Principles
The Court highlighted the following rules:
1. Tax assessments issued without sufficient facts or legal basis violate due process and are void. Taxpayers must be informed of the nature, amount, and legal basis of the liability to prepare an intelligent protest or claim.
2. SOAs issued solely for the purpose of permit renewal and payment of ordinary business taxes, without identifying deficiencies, surcharges, or penalties, do not constitute a notice of assessment under Section 195.
3. Section 196 provides the proper administrative and judicial remedy for refund claims when no valid assessment exists, requiring a written claim to the treasurer and a judicial action within two years from payment.
Practical Takeaways
Businesses paying taxes for permit renewal should review SOAs carefully. An SOA that lacks details on deficiency, penalties, or period covered is not a notice of assessment. Taxpayers in similar situations may recover overpayments by filing a Section 196 claim and following the judicial claim timeline. Municipal treasurers and local governments should ensure that any notice of assessment complies with Section 195 to avoid refund claims.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Our tax litigation team in Makati provides expert guidance for taxpayers navigating local business tax disputes, claims for refunds, and administrative remedies. We assist in preparing Section 196 claims, filing judicial actions, and defending against improper assessments. Learn more at