CTA En Banc voids BIR deficiency assessment for TY 2010 due to lack of LOA and due process violations, enjoining collection.
Taxpayers who receive a deficiency assessment without proper procedural safeguards may now rely on the principle that assessments issued without a Letter of Authority (LOA) or in violation of due process can be declared void. In a recent En Banc ruling, the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) confirmed that the taxpayer’s right to timely and proper notice is paramount, affecting collection and enforcement actions.
Background
The case involved a taxpayer who was assessed by the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) for deficiency income tax and value-added tax for the taxable year 2010. The assessment was based on discrepancies between the taxpayer’s declared purchases and the Sales List submitted by suppliers. The BIR issued a Letter Notice, followed by a Preliminary Assessment Notice (PAN), and a Formal Letter of Demand/Final Letter of Demand (FAN/FLD). The taxpayer protested, submitted supporting documents beyond the BIR-prescribed period, and received a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment (FDDA). The taxpayer subsequently filed a Request for Reconsideration.
The dispute centered on whether the assessment was valid given that no LOA was issued and whether the taxpayer had been afforded due process in submitting supporting documents. The First Division had earlier declared the assessment void and enjoined collection. The Commissioner of Internal Revenue challenged this decision before the CTA En Banc (CTA EB No. 2734, April 2025)
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
CTA En Banc Ruling
The CTA En Banc affirmed the First Division’s decision, emphasizing key procedural lapses. The court held that: (1) the taxpayer’s testimony that he received the Final Decision on Request for Reconsideration (FDRR) on a specific date was unrebutted and supported by documentary evidence; (2) no LOA was issued authorizing the BIR to examine the taxpayer’s books, and a Letter Notice cannot substitute for an LOA; and (3) the BIR’s assessment was presumptive, relying solely on supplier data compared to the taxpayer’s tax returns without independent verification.
Because of these procedural defects, the CTA En Banc ruled that the deficiency assessment for TY 2010, totaling PHP 2,260,073.57 including interest, was void, and all collection actions were enjoined
CTA En Banc Division Decision โฆ
.
Key Legal Principles
This decision reiterates several important tax law principles: (1) Assessments require proper authority, typically via an LOA issued to a revenue officer. Without it, any audit or assessment may be invalid. (2) Taxpayers must be afforded due process, including adequate time to submit supporting evidence, and arbitrary deadlines may result in procedural unfairness. (3) The presumption of correctness in tax assessments can be rebutted when the BIR relies on unverified third-party data without an LOA.
Additionally, the ruling confirms that belated submission of evidence can be considered if it supports jurisdictional and procedural compliance, drawing from precedent cases like Filminera Resources Corporation v. CIR.
Practical Implications for Taxpayers
Taxpayers should ensure that any deficiency assessment: (i) is preceded by a valid LOA, (ii) affords reasonable time for protest and submission of supporting documents, and (iii) is based on verified facts rather than presumptions from third-party data. Failure by the BIR to meet these procedural requirements may result in the nullification of assessments and enjoinment of collection actions.
For importers and businesses, this decision serves as a caution to monitor notices of assessment, PANs, FANs, and FDRRs, ensuring timely administrative appeals and preservation of documentary evidence to assert rights effectively before the CTA.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Our tax litigation team assists clients in challenging invalid assessments, ensuring procedural compliance by the BIR, and protecting taxpayer rights. We provide strategic guidance for administrative protests, appeals to the CTA, and enjoinment of unlawful collection actions. Learn more at