The Supreme Court and CTA En Banc upheld CGT and DST assessments on BW Resources share transfers, emphasizing taxpayer admissions and proper computation under RR No. 02-82.
Taxpayers involved in over-the-counter transactions of non-listed shares must now recognize that admissions of transfer or disposition can trigger capital gains tax (CGT) and documentary stamp tax (DST) liabilities even when formal evidence from the BIR was not submitted. The Supreme Court and the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) En Banc have clarified that failure to formally contest the correctness of an assessment does not relieve the taxpayer of liability, and courts must determine the correct amount of CGT based on the net capital gains realized.
Background
The case involves respondent Jerry Ocier, who received deficiency assessments from the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) in 2001 for capital gains tax and documentary stamp tax arising from the transfer of 4.9 million shares of Best World Resources Corporation (BW Resources) in 1999. The BIR treated the transfers as sales rather than loans and assessed a CGT of P17,862,848.21 and DST of P71,703.76. Respondent protested, claiming the transfers were loans, not sales, and the CTA initially canceled the assessments.
The Commissioner of Internal Revenue elevated the case to the Supreme Court, which affirmed the CGT and DST assessments, rejecting the loan characterization and emphasizing that the respondent had not claimed exemption from CGT. The Supreme Court remanded the case to the CTA to determine the exact CGT liability amount.
CTA En Banc Ruling
The CTA En Banc was tasked to determine the proper amount of deficiency CGT based on respondent’s net capital gains. The court reiterated that BIR assessments are prima facie correct, and the burden of proving error lies with the taxpayer. Respondent had not contested the computations, selling price, or cost basis in accordance with Revenue Regulations No. 02-82. The court relied on respondent’s admissions of the transfer of shares, determining that even transfers characterized as stock loans constitute