Business permit statements of account were not local tax assessments, allowing a timely Section 196 refund claim over excess local business tax.

Businesses renewing local permits should not automatically treat a city-issued statement of account as a final and unappealable local tax assessment, especially where the document merely states amounts payable for permit renewal and does not explain any deficiency tax, surcharge, interest, penalty, facts, or legal basis. For taxpayers disputing alleged excess local business tax payments, this distinction can determine whether the case is barred by the short protest-and-appeal periods under Section 195 of the Local Government Code, or whether the taxpayer may pursue a refund under the two-year period in Section 196.

Background: A Local Business Tax Refund Dispute After Permit Renewal

The taxpayer, a domestic corporation engaged in the operation of restaurants, coffee shops, refreshment parlors, and catering-related food services, applied in January 2021 for renewal of the business permits of its Parañaque branches. In support of the renewal applications, it submitted sales certificates for calendar year 2020 showing total gross sales of Php522,503,595.20.

The city issued statements of account for local business tax allegedly totaling Php4,906,968.93. The taxpayer paid the first installment for the business permit renewals on January 21, 2021. It later wrote the city treasurer on March 19, 2021 requesting a refund of Php2,294,450.95, arguing that the city computed its local business tax using a higher basis than the gross sales reflected in the submitted sales certificates. The city treasurer denied the request on May 12, 2021.

The taxpayer then filed a complaint before the Regional Trial Court on June 24, 2021, principally challenging the city’s use of the Presumptive Income Level Assessment Approach, or PILAA, in computing the local business tax. The RTC dismissed the complaint, holding that the action had prescribed because the taxpayer supposedly failed to comply with the shorter periods governing protests of assessments. The taxpayer elevated the dispute to the Court of Tax Appeals in a petition for review (CTA AC No. 265).

The Core Issue: Assessment Protest or Refund Claim?

The dispute turned on whether the city’s statements of account were the kind of assessment contemplated under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. If they were valid assessments, the taxpayer’s remedy would be tied to the strict Section 195 framework: a written protest within 60 days from receipt of the assessment, followed by an appeal to court within 30 days from denial or inaction. If no assessment was issued, the refund claim would instead be governed independently by Section 196, which requires a written claim with the local treasurer and a court action within two years from payment or from the date the taxpayer became entitled to a refund or credit.

The city argued that the Business Permit and Licensing Office acted on behalf of the city treasurer when it issued the statements of account, and that these documents should be treated as assessments. The taxpayer countered that there was no assessment because the city treasurer did not issue a notice based on a finding that correct taxes had not been paid, and the documents were not post-audit deficiency assessments.

Ruling: Statements of Account for Permit Renewal Were Not Section 195 Assessments

The court held that Section 195 applies only when an assessment is actually issued. A notice of assessment must state the nature of the tax, fee, or charge; the amount of deficiency; and the applicable surcharges, interests, and penalties. It must also sufficiently inform the taxpayer of the facts and law used as bases for the assessment, so that the taxpayer can make a reasonable protest.

On the facts, the statements of account were issued as prerequisites for the issuance or renewal of business permits. They did not contain information about the facts and law on which a supposed assessment was based. There was also no showing that they were issued by the city treasurer, or by a duly authorized representative, after a prior finding that the taxpayer had failed to pay the correct taxes, fees, or charges at the time required by law.

Because the statements of account were not notices of assessment under Section 195, the taxpayer’s refund remedy was governed by Section 196. The taxpayer paid the local business tax on January 21, 2021, filed its administrative refund claim on March 19, 2021, and filed the judicial claim on June 24, 2021. All of these acts fell within the two-year period ending January 21, 2023. The RTC therefore erred in dismissing the complaint on prescription grounds.

PILAA Cannot Be Used Casually to Increase Local Business Tax

The decision also addressed the city’s use of PILAA. The taxpayer argued that local business tax for 2021 should be based on its 2020 gross sales or receipts, consistent with the Local Government Code and the city’s own revenue rules. The city, however, used a presumptive income approach, resulting in a higher tax amount.

The court cited the Bureau of Local Government Finance reminder that PILAA may be used in computing local business tax only when the taxpayer is unable to provide proof of gross sales or receipts, and only when the use of PILAA is authorized by the local tax ordinance after the required public hearings and publications. These safeguards are important because presumptive income figures can materially increase the amount collected from a business.

The court found that the city’s revenue code did define presumptive income level, but did not authorize PILAA as a mechanism for imputing gross income for local business tax computation. Rather, the relevant provisions used presumptive income levels to validate declared gross sales or receipts and to identify possible manifest under-declaration that may affect the issuance or renewal of a mayor’s permit. The revenue code also referred to the use of best available evidence when a taxpayer fails to submit a sworn statement of gross sales or receipts, but it did not authorize PILAA as the basis for calculating local business tax due.

For that reason, the court agreed that the city’s use of PILAA was erroneous for lack of legal basis. However, it did not finally award the refund because the RTC proceedings had not yet concluded the pre-trial stage. The case was remanded to the RTC for further proceedings on the merits of the refund claim, including examination of the parties’ evidence and defenses.

Practical Takeaways for Businesses and Local Taxpayers

First, businesses should carefully distinguish between a statement of account issued for business permit renewal and a formal notice of assessment for deficiency local taxes. A document that merely lists amounts payable for permit renewal may not automatically trigger the Section 195 protest regime unless it contains the required elements of an assessment and is issued after the required finding of underpayment.

Second, taxpayers seeking a refund of local business tax should still act promptly. Even when Section 196 applies, the taxpayer must file a written claim for refund or credit with the local treasurer before going to court, and the judicial action must be filed within two years from payment or from entitlement to refund or credit. Delay can still be fatal.

Third, local governments cannot rely on presumptive income methods merely because they doubt the taxpayer’s declarations. PILAA is not a shortcut for increasing collections. Its use must be anchored on the applicable local ordinance and must comply with the limitations recognized by the BLGF and the Local Government Code framework.

Fourth, businesses should preserve the documents that prove their gross sales or receipts, including sales certificates, sworn statements, official receipts, permit renewal documents, and correspondence with the city treasurer. These records can determine whether the taxpayer can prove that the local business tax was computed using the wrong base.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Local business tax disputes often turn on technical procedural questions: whether the document issued by the city is a true assessment, whether the taxpayer used the correct administrative remedy, whether the judicial action was timely filed, and whether the LGU’s computation has legal basis under the Local Government Code and the applicable revenue ordinance. A missed deadline or an incorrectly framed remedy can defeat an otherwise meritorious refund claim.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, property owners, importers, and corporate taxpayers in evaluating local tax assessments, preparing protests and refund claims, challenging unlawful local tax collection practices, and litigating tax disputes before the proper courts, including the Court of Tax Appeals. For assistance with local business tax, real property tax, customs, or national tax disputes, visit MakatiLawFirm.com or contact our tax litigation team for a confidential consultation.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *