Airline excise tax refund claim denied for failure to prove imported alcohol products were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price.

Airline operators claiming excise tax refunds on imported commissary or catering supplies cannot rely on thin or outdated price comparisons; they must present reliable, product-specific evidence showing that the imported items were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price at the time of importation.

Background of the Excise Tax Refund Dispute

The taxpayer, a domestic airline, sought a refund or tax credit certificate for P2,904,585.91 in excise taxes paid under protest on July 27, 2017 and October 19, 2017. The taxes related to importations of alcohol products used as commissary and catering supplies. The taxpayer argued that these importations were exempt under Presidential Decree No. 1590, its franchise law, because the taxes it pays under the franchise are in lieu of other taxes, duties, charges, and fees on qualifying importations.

The refund request was filed with the Commissioner on July 22, 2019, and the judicial claim was filed shortly after, on July 25, 2019, to protect the two-year prescriptive period for tax refund claims. The dispute eventually reached the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc, where the taxpayer challenged the denial of its refund claim (CTA EB No. 2657).

What the Taxpayer Had to Prove Under Its Franchise

Under Section 13 of Presidential Decree No. 1590, qualifying importations by the airline may be exempt from taxes, duties, and charges if the imported articles, supplies, or materials are for use in its transport or non-transport operations and other incidental activities, and if they are not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price.

The key dispute was the third requirement. The taxpayer did not merely have to show that it imported alcohol products or that the items were used for airline operations. It had to establish, by competent evidence, that the locally available alternatives were insufficient in quantity, inferior in quality, or unreasonable in price compared with the imported products. The qualification is alternative, not cumulative, but at least one of those grounds must still be proven.

Why the Refund Claim Was Denied

The En Banc affirmed the denial of the claim because the taxpayer failed to present sufficiently reliable evidence that the imported alcohol products were not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price. The taxpayer relied on the judicial affidavit and testimony of its purchasing manager, product price lists from three merchants, Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012, and a table comparing importation costs with local prices.

The Court recognized that prior cases involving the same taxpayer had accepted price lists, tables of comparison, and testimony as sufficient in certain circumstances. However, the Court clarified that the issue is not simply the number of price lists submitted. A single supplier’s price list may be sufficient in an appropriate case, but only when the evidence is reliable, relevant, and adequate to establish the required fact. In this case, the Court found that the evidence failed in quality, not merely quantity.

One major weakness was that Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012 was based on a 2010 BIR price survey of alcohol products. The importations in this case occurred in 2013 and 2014. Because prices, availability, and market conditions for alcohol products can change over time, the Court held that the 2010 survey could not serve as a reliable benchmark for importations made several years later.

The Court also examined the taxpayer’s table of comparison and found that the actual product comparisons were extremely limited. Out of 24 types of alcohol products listed, only four were actually compared for the two-year period involved, or only 16% of the products. For 2013, only two comparative prices were presented: Charles Heidsieck Brut Reserve 12% and Remy Martin VSOP. For 2014, only two comparative prices were presented: Asahi Super Dry Beer and Rawson Private Release Shiraz Cabernet. The Court described this as meager evidence and insufficient to support the conclusion that the imported products were not locally available at reasonable prices.

Why Merchant Price Lists Were Not Enough

The taxpayer presented price lists from Absolute Sales Corporation, Future Trade International, and Minivan Enterprise. However, the Court found that not all merchants provided prices for each imported product. Some products had no meaningful local price comparison at all, while others were supported by only one supplier’s price.

The Court was not convinced that the price lists represented the local market price or the market for the entire country. The taxpayer did not present corroborating evidence showing that the merchants were exclusive distributors, that their prices represented prevailing local market prices, or that the taxpayer made a sufficiently diligent canvass of local suppliers before importation. Without that corroboration, the Court could not determine whether importing was actually cheaper than buying locally.

The Burden of Proof in Tax Refund Cases

The ruling reinforces a familiar principle in Philippine tax litigation: the taxpayer bears the burden of proving entitlement to a refund or tax credit. A refund claim is treated similarly to a tax exemption because it derogates from the State’s taxing power. For that reason, the requirements are strictly construed against the taxpayer and liberally in favor of the government.

The Court also emphasized the distinction between burden of proof and burden of evidence. The taxpayer must first establish a prima facie case. Only after it presents evidence that is good and sufficient on its face does the burden shift to the Commissioner to controvert the claim. Here, the taxpayer’s evidence was found insufficient even at the prima facie stage. As a result, the Commissioner’s failure to present contrary evidence did not automatically entitle the taxpayer to a refund.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Importers

Taxpayers claiming refunds or exemptions for imported goods should treat market availability as a factual issue that must be documented contemporaneously. A bare table of comparison, unsupported by a robust canvass, may not be enough. For importers relying on a condition that goods are not locally available in reasonable quantity, quality, or price, the evidence should ideally identify comparable local products, current supplier quotations, dates of canvassing, availability or inventory limitations, product specifications, and the basis for concluding that the local alternative is unreasonable.

The ruling is especially important for companies with special franchises, tax exemptions, or import-related privileges. Even when the legal exemption exists, the taxpayer must still prove compliance with each statutory condition. The Court will look closely at whether the evidence relates to the actual period of importation, whether the comparison covers the specific imported products, and whether the local price data is representative and reliable.

For CFOs, tax managers, and customs brokers, the lesson is operational as much as legal: build the evidentiary file before or at the time of importation. Waiting until a refund case is filed may leave the taxpayer with outdated quotations, incomplete canvass records, or price lists that do not match the imported products. In a tax refund case, those gaps can be fatal.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, and corporate groups in evaluating tax refund claims, preparing evidentiary records, handling BIR administrative claims, and litigating tax and customs disputes before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients identify the legal requirements for refund claims and build the factual proof needed to withstand judicial scrutiny.

If your company is facing a disputed assessment, denied refund claim, customs controversy, or tax exemption issue, our lawyers can help assess your position and prepare a litigation strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco regarding Philippine tax litigation and Court of Tax Appeals representation.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *