CTA denied the Commissioner’s bid to reverse a P104.1M VAT refund for imported prescription drugs, rejecting repeated format-based objections.

Pharmaceutical importers seeking VAT refunds for prescription drugs should focus on proving the substantive basis of their exemption and preserving documentary evidence, because a refund should not be defeated merely by a repeated procedural objection that the tax authority fails to substantiate with contrary evidence.

Background of the VAT Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from a refund claim involving VAT paid on the importation of prescription drugs and medicines for diabetes, high cholesterol, and hypertension. In the earlier decision, the taxpayer obtained a partial refund of P104,126,887.43, representing VAT erroneously paid on covered importations for the period from July 1, 2020 to November 30, 2020.

After the partial grant of the refund, the Commissioner sought reconsideration and asked the Court to partially reverse the decision. The case involved a petition for review for refund or issuance of tax credit before the Court of Tax Appeals First Division (CTA Case No. 10854).

The Commissioner’s Objection to the Refund

The Commissioner argued that the taxpayer failed to prove that the input tax on the imported items had not been reported and claimed as input tax credit in its monthly and quarterly VAT returns. The Commissioner relied on Section 3 of Revenue Regulations No. 18-2020 and maintained that the taxpayer’s refund claim should have been denied for failure to substantiate the claim at the administrative level.

The Commissioner also invoked the familiar rule that tax refunds are construed strictissimi juris against the taxpayer. In practical terms, the government’s position was that the taxpayer carried the burden of proving every requirement for the VAT refund and that any failure in the manner of presenting the claim should be fatal.

The Taxpayer’s Response

The taxpayer countered that it had submitted documents in compliance with the law and the directives of the Bureau of Internal Revenue, particularly Revenue Memorandum Order No. 36-2020, which it identified as the prevailing issuance at the time of the refund claim. The taxpayer emphasized that RMO No. 36-2020 did not prescribe a specific format for presenting the input tax claimed for refund in the Quarterly VAT Return or Monthly VAT Declaration.

The taxpayer further argued that RMO No. 36-2020 did not require denial of a refund claim merely because a taxpayer failed to format its VAT returns or declarations in a particular way. It also maintained that it did not claim the subject input tax as an input tax credit and that its evidence established the factual and legal bases for the refund. The taxpayer additionally pointed out that the Commissioner failed to present evidence during trial showing that the transaction was not covered by the exemption.

Why the Motion for Partial Reconsideration Was Denied

The Court denied the Commissioner’s motion for partial reconsideration for lack of merit. The Court observed that the motion merely repeated arguments already raised in the petition for review and already addressed in the earlier decision.

Crucially, the Court found that the Commissioner failed to identify which findings or conclusions in the earlier decision were supposedly contrary to law or unsupported by evidence. Instead of presenting a compelling reason to revisit the ruling, the motion simply asserted error without substantiating the claim.

The Court reiterated that a motion for reconsideration does not require the Court to rewrite its decision or address every repeated argument again in full detail. Where the motion merely rehashes issues already passed upon, it is enough for the Court to state a legal ground for denial, especially when no substantial argument or cogent reason is shown to justify reconsideration or modification.

Key Legal Principle for Tax Refund Litigation

The ruling is important for taxpayers because it confirms that, while refund claims remain strictly construed against the taxpayer, the Commissioner cannot rely on bare repetition or generalized objections to defeat a refund that the evidence already supports. A motion for reconsideration must do more than restate prior arguments. It must point to specific factual or legal errors that warrant a different result.

For VAT refund and tax credit cases, the decision also highlights the importance of matching the taxpayer’s compliance evidence with the rules in force at the time the claim was filed. Here, the taxpayer’s position was anchored on the applicable BIR issuance governing the refund claim, and the Court was not persuaded that a formatting objection, without more, justified reversal of the partial refund award.

Practical Takeaways for Pharmaceutical Importers and VAT Refund Claimants

Businesses importing VAT-exempt or zero-rated goods should not treat the refund process as a mere filing exercise. They must preserve evidence showing the nature of the imported goods, the period covered, the VAT actually paid, the legal basis for exemption or refund, and the fact that the same input tax was not claimed as credit against output VAT.

At the same time, taxpayers should be prepared to answer administrative-level objections about VAT return presentation, input tax reporting, and supporting schedules. Even if the applicable BIR issuance does not require a specific format, the safer litigation approach is to make the paper trail easy for both the BIR and the Court to verify.

The ruling is also a reminder to the BIR that reconsideration is not a second opportunity to relitigate the same points without identifying concrete error. If the taxpayer’s evidence supports the refund and the Commissioner fails to present contrary evidence, a motion that simply repeats strictissimi juris arguments may not be enough.

What This Means for Taxpayers with Pending VAT Refund Claims

Taxpayers with pending VAT refund claims should review whether their VAT returns, import documents, payment records, exemption basis, and accounting treatment are consistent and litigation-ready. In refund disputes, the central question is not only whether the taxpayer is legally entitled to recover the tax, but whether the record proves that entitlement in a manner the Court can rely on.

For importers of prescription drugs and medicines, the case is particularly relevant where VAT was paid despite a claimed exemption. The ruling shows that a refund may be sustained when the taxpayer can establish the factual and legal basis of the claim and when the government’s challenge fails to identify a decisive defect in the evidence.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, and corporate finance teams in evaluating VAT refund claims, preparing administrative refund submissions, responding to BIR objections, and litigating refund or tax credit cases before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice helps clients build the evidentiary record needed to withstand strict scrutiny in refund cases.

For businesses facing disputed VAT refund claims, denied administrative applications, or pending Court of Tax Appeals litigation, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *