CTA denies Avaloq PH’s refund claim, ruling that ROHQ status and service export status alone cannot prove services were rendered in the Philippines.

Businesses claiming tax refunds for services purportedly rendered in the Philippines must now ensure robust proof of actual local performance. Avaloq Philippines Operating Headquarters’ recent appeal for a tax refund was denied, reinforcing that assertions based solely on service export status or ROHQ designation are insufficient to meet the statutory requirements.

Background

Avaloq Philippines Operating Headquarters filed a petition for review against the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, seeking a refund for income taxes paid on services claimed to be rendered in the Philippines (CTA EB No. 2746, CTA Case No. 10119). The taxpayer argued that as a regional operating headquarters (ROHQ) exporting services to foreign affiliates, its activities were conducted domestically, supported by testimony from its accountant and an Independent Certified Public Accountant (ICPA) report. The initial CTA decision (January 9, 2023, affirmed March 13, 2023) denied the refund, prompting a Motion for Reconsideration in July 2024.

CTA Ruling on the Motion for Reconsideration

The Court of Tax Appeals En Banc resolved the motion on March 20, 2025, confirming the prior denial. The court emphasized that the ICPA report and testimonies presented by the petitioner failed to conclusively demonstrate that services were rendered in the Philippines. Moreover, the court rejected the notion that ROHQ status or the general definition of exportation automatically established domestic service performance. Citing Section 3, Rule 13 of the Revised Rules of the CTA, the Court reiterated that the burden of proof rests on the taxpayer and that refund claims, being akin to tax exemptions, are strictly construed in favor of the government.

Key Legal Principles

The decision underscores several important principles for tax refund claims:

First, taxpayers must provide direct and conclusive evidence of services rendered domestically to satisfy refund requirements. General attestations of export activity, even when supported by an accountant or ICPA report, are insufficient.

Second, claims for refund are strictly construed and cannot rely on presumptions based on corporate status or tax compliance. The court cited precedent emphasizing that arguments merely reiterating previously rejected issues provide no basis for reconsideration.

Third, a Motion for Reconsideration does not compel the court to re-examine issues already fully adjudicated. The legal standard allows the court to deal with such motions summarily when the motion presents no new substantive or cogent arguments.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and ROHQs

Businesses operating as ROHQs must maintain detailed, verifiable documentation demonstrating that services for which a tax refund is claimed were performed within the Philippines. Reliance on export designation, payment of domestic taxes, or general ROHQ status alone will likely fail.

Companies should also ensure that any independent accounting reports or supporting documents explicitly address the statutory requirement of domestic service rendering. Broad statements about service exportation or regional operations are inadequate.

Finally, practitioners and corporate taxpayers should be mindful that motions for reconsideration offer limited scope. Submitting repetitive arguments without new evidence or legal basis is unlikely to alter adverse rulings.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Our tax litigation team provides expert guidance for businesses seeking to claim tax refunds, especially for ROHQs and exporters of services. We help assess the adequacy of evidence, structure claims to meet strict CTA standards, and advise on strategic responses to adverse rulings. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to discuss how we can support your tax compliance and refund recovery efforts.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *