A tax prosecution for willful failure to pay income tax was dismissed because the Information was filed beyond five years; DOJ preliminary investigation did not toll prescription.

Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should closely examine when the alleged offense was committed and when the Information was actually filed in court, because a complaint for preliminary investigation may not be enough to stop prescription from running. In this ruling, the government’s criminal case for willful failure to pay deficiency income tax was dismissed because the Information was filed after the five-year prescriptive period under the Tax Code had already expired.

Background of the Tax Prosecution

The dispute arose from a deficiency income tax assessment for taxable year 2008. The Commissioner issued a final decision on the disputed assessment dated August 7, 2015. The taxpayer did not appeal the assessment, and it became final, executory, and demandable in September 2015. The government later pursued criminal prosecution for willful failure to pay tax under Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code.

The government filed a complaint for preliminary investigation with the Department of Justice on September 27, 2018. However, the Information was filed with the Court of Tax Appeals only on August 10, 2023. The taxpayer and the individual respondents argued that the criminal action had already prescribed because more than five years had passed from the alleged commission of the offense before the Information was filed in court (CTA En Banc Crim. No. 145).

The Central Issue: What Stops Prescription in a Criminal Tax Case?

The key issue was whether the filing of the complaint for preliminary investigation interrupted the running of the five-year prescriptive period for violations of the Tax Code. The government argued that the September 27, 2018 complaint was filed within five years from the assessment becoming final and demandable. On that theory, prescription would have been tolled, making the August 10, 2023 Information timely.

The taxpayer disagreed. Its position was that the criminal action was not commenced by the filing of the preliminary investigation complaint, but only by the filing of the Information in court. Since the alleged offense occurred when the assessment became final and remained unpaid in September 2015, the five-year period had expired by September 2020. By the time the Information was filed in August 2023, the taxpayer argued, the government’s right to prosecute had already prescribed.

The CTA En Banc Ruling

The CTA En Banc denied the government’s petition and upheld the dismissal of the criminal case. It ruled that the filing of a complaint for preliminary investigation does not toll the five-year prescriptive period for tax offenses. For criminal actions before the CTA, prescription is interrupted by the filing of the Information in court, not by the earlier filing of a complaint before the DOJ for preliminary investigation.

Applying Section 281 of the Tax Code, the court recognized that violations of the Tax Code prescribe after five years. The period generally begins to run from the commission of the offense, or if the commission is not known, from its discovery and the institution of judicial proceedings for investigation and punishment. In the context of this prosecution, the offense was treated as having been committed when the assessment became final and demandable and the taxpayer failed to pay.

Because the Information was filed only on August 10, 2023, the filing came almost three years after the five-year period had lapsed. The CTA En Banc therefore sustained the dismissal of the criminal charge for prescription.

Why the Ruling Matters to Taxpayers

This ruling is important because criminal tax cases often begin long before an Information reaches the CTA. A taxpayer may receive an assessment, fail to settle or successfully contest it, face a DOJ complaint years later, and then see the Information filed much later. The decision confirms that taxpayers should not stop their prescription analysis at the date the DOJ complaint was filed. The more important date, for purposes of instituting the criminal action before the CTA, is the filing of the Information in court.

For business owners, CFOs, and corporate counsel, the practical lesson is that prescription is not a mere technicality. It can determine whether the government may still pursue criminal punishment for alleged nonpayment of tax. A taxpayer accused of willful failure to pay deficiency income tax should reconstruct the entire timeline: receipt of the assessment, finality of the assessment, due date for payment, filing of any DOJ complaint, issuance of any prosecutor resolution, and actual filing of the Information with the CTA.

What This Means for BIR Enforcement

The ruling also underscores the need for strict coordination among the BIR, the DOJ, and the prosecuting authorities. If the government intends to convert a final assessment into a criminal tax prosecution, it must be mindful that the five-year clock continues to matter. Delay between the preliminary investigation stage and the filing of the Information may be fatal.

At the same time, taxpayers should not assume that every delay automatically results in dismissal. The exact reckoning point, the nature of the alleged Tax Code violation, the date of discovery, and the procedural history of the assessment all matter. Prescription defenses in tax prosecutions are highly fact-sensitive and should be evaluated against the assessment record and the actual court filings.

Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers

First, keep complete records of assessment notices, final decisions on disputed assessments, demand letters, and proof of receipt. These documents may establish when the alleged offense became complete and when prescription began to run. Second, do not ignore a preliminary investigation complaint merely because the assessment is old. The complaint may indicate that the government is attempting to escalate the matter into a criminal case, but it may also reveal a prescription defense if the Information is filed late. Third, corporate officers named in tax complaints should obtain individual legal advice because exposure may differ from that of the corporation.

Finally, this decision reinforces that tax litigation strategy should cover both the civil assessment and the possible criminal consequences. Once a tax assessment becomes final, executory, and demandable, the taxpayer may face collection action and, in some cases, criminal prosecution. But the government must still comply with the statutory periods and procedural rules governing criminal actions before the CTA.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, and business owners in evaluating BIR assessments, CTA cases, criminal tax exposure, prescription defenses, and settlement or litigation options. Our tax litigation practice can review the assessment timeline, identify jurisdictional and procedural defenses, prepare submissions for preliminary investigation, and represent clients before the Court of Tax Appeals.

If you or your company received a BIR assessment, a DOJ subpoena, or an Information for an alleged Tax Code violation, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax assessment disputes, criminal tax prosecution, and CTA litigation strategy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *