CTA affirmed a P146.87M beer excise tax refund, holding that BIR issuances cannot impose rates beyond Section 143 of the NIRC.
Manufacturers paying excise tax under a revenue regulation or circular that goes beyond the statute may seek a refund or tax credit before the Court of Tax Appeals, provided both the administrative and judicial claims are filed within the two-year period from payment. For beer and other fermented liquor manufacturers, the ruling is a reminder that even long-applied BIR classifications and tax-rate issuances cannot override the rates fixed by the National Internal Revenue Code.
Background: A Refund Claim Over 2018 Beer Excise Taxes
The dispute arose from excise taxes paid on beer products removed from brewery plants from January 1, 2018 to December 31, 2018. The taxpayer was engaged in the manufacture, sale, and distribution of fermented and malt-based beverages. For the 2018 period, the BIR required the taxpayer to pay excise tax at P25.03 per liter, relying on prior implementing issuances for fermented liquors.
The taxpayer filed an administrative claim for refund or tax credit on October 17, 2019, followed by a judicial claim on December 11, 2019. It sought to recover overpaid excise taxes allegedly caused by the BIR’s application of rates that exceeded the statutory excise tax rate under Section 143 of the NIRC, as amended by Republic Act No. 10351. The Court in Division partially granted the refund, and the Commissioner elevated the case to the Court En Banc (CTA EB No. 2834).
The Commissioner’s Main Objections
The Commissioner argued that the Court in Division should not have taken jurisdiction because the taxpayer’s refund claim allegedly required the nullification of Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012 and Revenue Regulations No. 17-2012. In the Commissioner’s view, challenges to the validity of BIR issuances should be brought before courts of general jurisdiction, not the Court of Tax Appeals.
The Commissioner also argued that the taxpayer failed to exhaust administrative remedies under Section 4 of the NIRC and that the taxpayer was not entitled to a refund. Among the Commissioner’s substantive points was the argument that there had been no reclassification of San Mig Light because it had allegedly always been treated as a variant of an existing brand.
The Court Confirmed CTA Jurisdiction Over Tax Issuance Challenges
The Court En Banc rejected the jurisdictional objection. It held that the taxpayer’s claim was a refund case involving internal revenue taxes, which falls within the jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals under Republic Act No. 1125, as amended, and the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals.
More importantly, the Court applied the Supreme Court’s doctrine in Banco De Oro and later cases, recognizing that the Court of Tax Appeals has jurisdiction to pass upon the constitutionality or validity of tax laws, regulations, and administrative issuances when the issue is raised in a tax dispute, assessment case, or refund claim. This means taxpayers do not necessarily need to file a separate action before a regional trial court merely because their refund theory requires showing that a revenue regulation or circular is invalid.
The Refund Claim Was Timely Filed
The Court also held that the taxpayer complied with the two-year prescriptive period under Sections 204(C) and 229 of the NIRC, in relation to Section 130(A)(2). For excise tax on domestic products, the tax is paid before removal from the place of production. Accordingly, the relevant payment dates are tied to the actual removals of the taxable products from the brewery plants.
The earliest removal date involved in the claim was January 2, 2018. The taxpayer therefore had until January 2, 2020 to file both its administrative and judicial claims. Because the taxpayer filed its administrative claim on October 17, 2019 and its judicial claim on December 11, 2019, the Court found both claims timely.
Why the BIR’s P25.03 Per Liter Rate Was Invalid
The central substantive issue was whether the BIR could collect excise tax on the beer products at P25.03 per liter for 2018. The Court held that it could not. Section 143 of the NIRC, as amended by RA No. 10351, prescribed a specific rate structure for fermented liquors and provided that the four percent annual increase would begin effective January 1, 2018.
By contrast, Section 5 of RR No. 17-2012 increased the applicable tax rate by four percent annually starting January 1, 2014. The Court found this inconsistent with the statute. It also noted that portions of Annex A-1 of RMC No. 90-2012 imposed rates of P15.49 or P20.57 per liter effective January 1, 2013, regardless of whether the net retail price per liter of volume capacity was P50.60 or less, or more than P50.60.
For 2018, the Court compared the statutory rate of P24.44 per liter against the P25.03 per liter actually collected under the challenged BIR issuances. The P0.59 per liter difference was the basis of the overpayment.
Administrative Issuances Cannot Rewrite the Tax Code
The Court emphasized a basic rule in tax administration: the power to issue regulations does not include the power to amend, enlarge, restrict, or go beyond the law being implemented. Administrative agencies may interpret and implement tax statutes, but they cannot create tax burdens not authorized by Congress.
Applying this principle, the Court found that the Secretary of Finance and the Commissioner effectively engaged in law-making when they imposed excise tax rates contrary to Section 143 of the NIRC. The Court therefore sustained the declaration that the relevant portions of Annex A-1 of RMC No. 90-2012 and the proviso in Section 5 of RR No. 17-2012 were invalid, without force and effect, insofar as they imposed rates inconsistent with the statute.
The Taxpayer Was Entitled to a Substantial Refund or Tax Credit
The Court relied on the findings of the court-commissioned independent certified public accountant, complemented by the Court in Division’s own determination. The verified removals covered 248,939,935.60 liters of beer products for 2018. These removals should have been taxed at P24.44 per liter, not P25.03 per liter.
The resulting P0.59 per liter overpayment produced an erroneous, excessive, or illegal collection of P146,874,555.07. The Court therefore affirmed the partial grant of the taxpayer’s claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate for the covered beer products, including San Mig Light, San Miguel Premium All Malt Beer, San Miguel Pale Pilsen in can, Super Dry, Red Horse in can, San Mig Zero, and San Miguel flavored beer products for the 2018 period.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Excise Tax Manufacturers
First, taxpayers should not assume that a BIR regulation or circular is valid simply because it has been applied for years. If the issuance imposes a tax burden beyond the statutory text, it may be challenged in the proper tax case.
Second, refund claims remain highly deadline-sensitive. For excise taxes on domestic products, the two-year period generally runs from payment, which in turn is linked to removal from the place of production. Taxpayers should preserve detailed removal records, tax returns, payment confirmations, product classifications, and computations early, because waiting until the end of the two-year period can create avoidable litigation risk.
Third, a taxpayer bringing a refund claim must establish the statutory basis for the claim and prove the amount of overpayment. Once the taxpayer complies with the minimum statutory requirements and establishes a prima facie right to refund, the burden shifts to the BIR to disprove the claim.
Finally, the ruling is significant beyond the beer industry. It reinforces the principle that tax administrators cannot use implementing rules to accelerate, increase, or modify taxes beyond what Congress enacted. This matters for manufacturers, importers, and regulated businesses that pay excise taxes or other internal revenue taxes under detailed BIR issuances.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, manufacturers, and corporate finance teams in evaluating BIR assessments, excise tax disputes, refund claims, tax credit applications, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review whether a tax payment was imposed under a valid statutory basis, assess refund deadlines, prepare administrative claims, and represent clients before the BIR and the Court of Tax Appeals.
If your company is facing a disputed tax assessment, excise tax issue, customs controversy, or possible refund claim, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco’s tax litigation team.