The CTA dismissed a petition challenging customs seizure due to untimely filing; importers must adhere to statutory appeal periods or risk forfeiture of goods.
Importers must now pay careful attention to statutory deadlines when contesting the forfeiture of imported goods. In cases involving customs seizures, failing to file an appeal within the prescribed period can result in automatic affirmation of the Collector’s decision, leaving importers without a remedy, regardless of the merits of their claim.
Background
This case arose from the seizure of a shipment of collectible magazines containing commemorative bank notes sent via FEDEX from Hong Kong to the Philippines. The shipment was examined by customs officials, who identified additional collectible notes allegedly not declared, leading the District Collector to order forfeiture and a 500% surcharge under Sections 1400 and 1113 of the Customs Modernization and Tariff Act (CMTA). The consignee, petitioner Sigrid Carandang, disputed the imposition of the surcharge and claimed that the goods were received in good faith and that the seizure was improper (CTA EB No. 10523)
CTA 2nd Division Decision SIGRโฆ
.
CTA’s Ruling
After reviewing the submissions, the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction. The CTA found that the petitioner failed to file a timely appeal following the