Foreign seller won a ₱7.38M CGT refund after the Court applied the Philippines-Netherlands tax treaty to exempt gains from a Philippine share sale.
Foreign corporate sellers of Philippine shares should not assume that capital gains tax is always due simply because the shares belong to a domestic corporation. When an applicable tax treaty assigns taxing rights exclusively to the seller’s country of residence, a Philippine CGT payment may be treated as erroneous and refundable, provided the taxpayer proves treaty residence, ownership, the share sale, payment of tax, and timely administrative and judicial refund claims.
Background: Dutch Seller Paid CGT on Sale of Philippine Company Shares
The dispute involved a Netherlands company that sold 901,000 common shares in a Philippine corporation to an Australian company under a Sale and Purchase Agreement dated December 4, 2019. The sale consideration consisted of a closing amount and deferred consideration payable in United States dollars. The seller later filed a Capital Gains Tax Return and paid Philippine CGT in the amount of ₱7,382,449.50 on August 24, 2020.
The seller subsequently sought a refund from the Bureau of Internal Revenue on the theory that the capital gain was exempt from Philippine income tax under the Philippines-Netherlands Tax Treaty. The administrative claim was filed on July 29, 2022, followed by a judicial claim on August 25, 2022, after court work in Metro Manila had been suspended on the last day of the original two-year period (CTA Case No. 10968).
The Core Issue: Whether the CGT Payment Was Legally Due
The central question was whether the taxpayer was entitled to recover the ₱7,382,449.50 CGT paid on the share sale. The Commissioner argued that the claim remained subject to administrative investigation and that the taxpayer filed in court without allowing the BIR sufficient time to act. The Commissioner also invoked the rule that tax refunds are construed strictly against taxpayers and in favor of the government.
The taxpayer argued that the payment was erroneous because, under Article 13 of the Philippines-Netherlands Tax Treaty, the gain from the alienation of the Philippine shares was taxable only in the Netherlands. It also asserted that both the administrative and judicial claims were filed within the two-year period required under Sections 204(C) and 229 of the Tax Code.
The Court Granted the Refund
The Court granted the petition and ordered the Commissioner to refund ₱7,382,449.50, representing CGT erroneously or wrongfully paid in relation to the sale of the Philippine company shares. The Court found that the taxpayer had sufficiently established the factual basis of its claim: it was a Netherlands tax resident, it owned the shares sold, it sold those shares to the buyer, it filed the CGT return, and it paid the tax for which a refund was sought.
The Court also noted that the Commissioner did not present documentary or testimonial evidence contradicting the taxpayer’s evidence. The Commissioner relied mainly on general legal propositions regarding strict construction of tax refunds and the alleged prematurity of the court action.
Why the Refund Claim Was Timely Despite the Short Interval Between BIR Filing and Court Filing
For erroneous or illegally collected internal revenue taxes, Sections 204(C) and 229 of the Tax Code require the taxpayer to file a written administrative claim with the Commissioner within two years from payment of the tax. A judicial claim must also be filed within the same two-year period, and the administrative claim must precede the judicial claim.
The taxpayer paid the CGT on August 24, 2020. The administrative claim was filed on July 29, 2022, within two years from payment. The judicial claim was filed on August 25, 2022, the next working day after the suspension of court work on August 24, 2022. The Court held that the judicial claim was likewise timely.
Importantly, the Court rejected the Commissioner’s argument that the taxpayer failed to exhaust administrative remedies. Relying on Supreme Court jurisprudence, the Court emphasized that for refund claims under Sections 204 and 229, the law does not prescribe a separate waiting period for the Commissioner to act. The controlling requirement is that both the administrative and judicial claims must be filed within two years from tax payment, with the administrative claim filed first. It does not matter how close together the filings are, provided those requirements are satisfied.
Tax Treaty Protection for Non-Resident Foreign Corporations
Under Section 28(B)(5)(c) of the Tax Code, net capital gains derived by a non-resident foreign corporation from the sale of shares in a domestic corporation not traded through the stock exchange are generally subject to Philippine final tax. However, Section 32(B)(5) excludes from gross income items exempt under a treaty obligation binding on the Philippine government.
The Court applied the Philippines-Netherlands Tax Treaty. Article 13 allocates taxing rights over gains from the alienation of property. Gains from immovable property, certain business property of a permanent establishment, and ships or aircraft operated in international traffic are covered by specific paragraphs. For property other than those categories, Article 13(4) provides that the gains shall be taxable only in the state where the alienator is a resident.
The shares sold by the taxpayer fell within this residual category. Because the taxpayer proved that it was a resident of the Netherlands under Article 4 of the treaty, the gains from the sale were taxable only in the Netherlands. Consequently, the Philippine CGT imposed under domestic law was not legally due.
Proof Matters: Treaty Residence, Ownership, and Actual Payment
The ruling is useful for foreign sellers and Philippine transaction advisers because it shows the evidentiary burden in a CGT refund claim involving a tax treaty. The taxpayer did not merely rely on treaty language. It submitted proof of Netherlands residence, proof that it was not registered as a Philippine corporation, stock certificates, corporate records showing ownership, the sale agreement, the CGT return, and the revenue official receipt showing payment.
The decision reinforces a practical point: treaty exemption is not automatic in litigation. A claimant must prove the facts that bring the transaction within the treaty. For share sale transactions, that usually means proving the seller’s treaty residence, beneficial ownership of the shares, the nature of the property sold, the transaction documents, the tax payment, and compliance with refund deadlines.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Foreign Investors
Foreign corporations selling shares in Philippine companies should review applicable tax treaties before paying CGT, especially where the seller is resident in a treaty jurisdiction. A domestic tax provision may impose CGT as a general rule, but a treaty may override or limit Philippine taxing rights.
Taxpayers that already paid CGT should immediately track the two-year prescriptive period from the date of payment. Waiting for BIR action can be risky because the same two-year period governs both administrative and judicial refund claims. Where the deadline is approaching, a taxpayer may need to file in court after filing the administrative claim to preserve the refund action.
For CFOs, tax managers, and corporate counsel, this decision underscores the importance of building a complete refund file early. Treaty residence certificates, apostilled foreign documents, stock ownership records, sale agreements, proof of receipt of consideration, CGT returns, and official receipts should be organized before the refund deadline becomes urgent.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, foreign investors, and corporate groups in evaluating Philippine tax exposure on share transfers, invoking tax treaty relief, preparing administrative refund claims, and litigating refund cases before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help determine whether CGT, withholding tax, VAT, customs duties, or other assessments may be challenged or recovered.
For assistance with tax treaty claims, CGT refunds, or Court of Tax Appeals litigation, visit MakatiLawFirm.com or contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco for a focused assessment of your tax dispute.