Petroleum importers may recover excise tax on fuel sold to PEZA entities, but only if delivery, tax payment, and ecozone use are properly proven.

Fuel importers and petroleum suppliers selling to PEZA-registered enterprises may recover previously paid excise taxes when the petroleum products are proven to have been sold and delivered to a tax-exempt ecozone buyer, but the refund will be reduced for any delivery volume supported by unreadable or inadmissible documents.

Background: Excise Tax Refund Claim on Fuel Oil Sold to a PEZA Enterprise

The dispute arose from a petroleum company’s claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate for excise taxes paid on imported fuel oil. The fuel oil had been imported from June to November 2020 and later sold and delivered from July to December 2020 to a PEZA-registered enterprise engaged in float glass manufacturing within the Asahi Special Economic Zone. The taxpayer sought to recover P90,732,000.00, representing excise taxes on 15,122,000 liters of fuel oil at the rate of P6.00 per liter.

The taxpayer filed two administrative claims with the Bureau of Internal Revenue on May 27, 2021 and July 23, 2021, and later filed the judicial claim before the Court of Tax Appeals on June 14, 2022 (Case No. 10891). The Commissioner opposed the claim, arguing that refund claims for excise taxes were governed only by Section 130(D) of the Tax Code and that Section 135 should not be invoked by the seller because the exemption supposedly belonged to the buyer.

Why the Court Treated the Excise Tax as Erroneously Collected

The Court rejected the Commissioner’s theory and treated the excise taxes paid on the qualifying fuel oil as erroneously or illegally collected. The key point is that excise tax on petroleum products is a tax on the property itself, and the direct legal liability for the tax falls on the statutory taxpayer, namely the manufacturer, producer, or importer. When petroleum products are sold to an entity covered by Section 135 of the National Internal Revenue Code, the exempt character attaches to the petroleum products themselves.

Section 135 exempts petroleum products sold to certain international carriers and exempt entities, including entities that are by law exempt from direct and indirect taxes. The Court emphasized that the statutory phrase “petroleum products” is not limited to locally manufactured products. Because the law does not distinguish between locally produced and imported petroleum products, the exemption may apply to imported fuel oil as long as the legal and evidentiary requirements are met.

This distinction is important for companies involved in fuel importation, ecozone sales, and tax credit certificate claims. The Court did not say that every sale to a PEZA enterprise automatically results in a refund. Rather, the taxpayer must prove both the legal status of the buyer and the factual link between the taxed importation and the fuel actually sold and delivered to the exempt entity.

PEZA Registration and Ecozone Use Were Critical

The taxpayer presented the buyer’s PEZA Certificate of Registration showing that the buyer was an Ecozone Export Enterprise at the Asahi Special Economic Zone. The Court also considered the legal framework under the Special Economic Zone Act, its implementing rules, Presidential Decree No. 66, and Executive Order No. 226, which generally treat merchandise and supplies brought into the ecozone for registered operations as not subject to customs and internal revenue laws and regulations.

Beyond the buyer’s registration, the taxpayer submitted documents intended to prove that the fuel oil was actually delivered to the ecozone and used in the buyer’s PEZA-registered operations, particularly in the manufacture and production of float glass for export. These documents included applications for permits to bring goods from the customs territory into the zone, the supply agreement and amendment, certifications from the buyer, depot records, warehouse certificates, bulk delivery notes, sales invoices, SAP printouts, and liquidation reports.

The Refund Was Partly Granted Because Some Deliveries Were Not Adequately Proven

The Court found that the taxpayer timely filed both its administrative and judicial claims within the two-year period counted from payment of the excise taxes, in accordance with Sections 204(C) and 229 of the Tax Code. It also found that the taxpayer sufficiently proved the payment of excise taxes on imported fuel oil and the qualifying sale and delivery of a substantial portion of that fuel oil to the PEZA-registered buyer.

However, the Court did not grant the entire P90,732,000.00 claim. It allowed only P89,304,000.00, corresponding to 14,884,000 liters of fuel oil that were properly substantiated. The disallowed amount of P1,428,000.00 corresponded to 238,000 liters of bunker fuel oil supported by bulk delivery notes that had been denied admission because they were unreadable, because originals were not presented for comparison, or because the documents did not satisfy the rules on duplicates or secondary evidence.

The practical lesson is that tax-exempt status and legal entitlement are not enough. Refund litigation is evidence-driven. Even where the substantive tax theory is correct, the Court may reduce the refund if the taxpayer cannot present admissible, readable, and properly authenticated documents tracing the importation, tax payment, sale, delivery, and ecozone use of the petroleum products.

Practical Takeaways for Fuel Suppliers, Importers, and PEZA Buyers

First, petroleum importers selling to PEZA-registered or otherwise tax-exempt entities should maintain a complete document trail from importation to delivery. The records should connect the Single Administrative Document, Statement of Settlement of Duties and Taxes, tax payment documents, inventory and depot records, delivery notes, sales invoices, permits to bring goods into the ecozone, and buyer certifications.

Second, taxpayers should treat bulk delivery notes and similar operational documents as litigation-critical evidence. If these documents are unreadable, incomplete, or not supported by originals or admissible duplicates, the corresponding refund amount may be denied even if the sale actually occurred.

Third, the ruling confirms that the seller-importer may be the proper refund claimant because it is the statutory taxpayer that paid the excise tax. The buyer’s exemption is relevant because it changes the tax character of the petroleum product sold, but the refund belongs to the party that legally bore the direct liability to pay the excise tax.

Finally, the decision is useful for companies preparing or defending claims for excise tax refund, tax credit certificate issuance, PEZA-related fuel transactions, and Section 135 petroleum product exemptions. It shows that the strongest refund claims combine a sound legal theory with meticulous documentary proof.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, exporters, PEZA enterprises, customs brokers, and corporate groups in tax refund claims, tax credit certificate applications, excise tax disputes, VAT and customs litigation, and proceedings before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can help assess refund eligibility, organize documentary proof, prepare administrative claims, and litigate disputed refunds where the BIR denies or fails to act on a claim.

For companies dealing with excise tax refunds, PEZA transactions, or Court of Tax Appeals litigation, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with Ablola, Saribong & Gueco’s tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *