A tax criminal case stayed dismissed after the En Banc refused to revive a prescribed prosecution, stressing timing and OSG authority in BIR appeals.
Tax criminal charges may fail before trial if the government files the Information after the applicable prescriptive period has already expired, even where the prosecution later argues that an earlier preliminary investigation should have interrupted the running of time. For corporate taxpayers, responsible officers, accountants, and tax counsel, the ruling is a reminder that prescription is not a mere technical defense. In tax prosecution, the timing of investigation, referral, and filing in court can determine whether the State still has the right to prosecute at all.
Background of the Tax Criminal Case
The dispute arose from a criminal tax case involving a corporate taxpayer and its responsible officers for alleged violation of the National Internal Revenue Code. The case concerned the government’s attempt to prosecute the accused for a tax offense connected with taxable year 2012, including the alleged failure to pay deficiency tax or to supply correct and accurate information under Section 255 of the Tax Code.
The Court in Division had dismissed the criminal case on the ground of prescription. The En Banc later affirmed that dismissal, and the government moved for reconsideration of the adverse ruling (CTA EB Crim. No. 131). In the resolution promulgated on July 15, 2025, the En Banc denied the government’s motion for reconsideration for lack of merit.
The Government Argued That Preliminary Investigation Interrupted Prescription
The government’s main argument was that the prescriptive period had been interrupted when the complaint for preliminary investigation was filed with the Department of Justice. In other words, the prosecution sought to avoid dismissal by treating the DOJ filing as a step that stopped the clock from continuing to run against the government’s right to bring the criminal tax case.
The government also argued that the Supreme Court ruling in Tupaz v. Ulep should prevail over Lim, Sr. v. Court of Appeals. According to the government, Tupaz was decided later and applied Section 281 of the amended National Internal Revenue Code, while Lim interpreted Section 354 of the old Tax Code. The argument was directed at the legal framework for determining whether prescription had been interrupted before the Information was filed in court.
The En Banc Refused to Revive the Criminal Tax Case
The En Banc found no sufficient or cogent reason to disturb its earlier decision. It held that the matters raised in the motion for reconsideration had already been thoroughly discussed and passed upon, first by the Court in Division and then on appeal by the En Banc. Because the government did not present new matters or issues that would justify reconsideration or modification, the motion was denied.
The practical result is that the dismissal of the criminal tax case remained in place. The Court in Division’s ruling, as affirmed by the En Banc, treated the government’s right to institute the case as already prescribed when the Information was filed before the Court on December 5, 2022. A separate opinion noted that, by that time, the five-year prescriptive period to indict the accused had already lapsed.
Why Prescription Matters in Tax Criminal Prosecutions
Prescription is a substantive defense in criminal tax cases because it limits the period within which the State may prosecute. Once the prescriptive period lapses, the government can no longer validly pursue the criminal charge. This protects taxpayers and accused corporate officers from indefinite exposure to prosecution based on old tax periods, stale records, or delayed enforcement action.
For businesses, the ruling is especially significant because tax assessments and criminal tax investigations can move on different timelines. A taxpayer may be dealing with administrative assessment proceedings, internal BIR referrals, DOJ preliminary investigation, and eventual filing before the Court of Tax Appeals. Each step matters, but not every step will necessarily save a prosecution from prescription unless the applicable law and controlling jurisprudence support interruption of the prescriptive period.
Separate Opinion: BIR Appeals in Criminal Tax Cases Need OSG Authority
A separate concurring opinion agreed in the result but emphasized a different procedural ground. The separate opinion stated that the government’s petition for review suffered from a procedural defect because it sought to appeal the very right of the State to prosecute, yet there was no sufficient showing of participation, conformity, or actual deputation by the Office of the Solicitor General.
The separate opinion explained that, in criminal cases, the State is the party affected by the dismissal of the criminal action. Under the cited rules and jurisprudence, the Solicitor General represents the People in appellate proceedings, although BIR legal officers may be deputized under proper conditions. The separate opinion observed that the petition was not signed by the OSG, that the OSG was not even furnished a copy of the petition, and that the mere caption stating that the case was brought through the Solicitor General was not enough without actual deputation.
This point is important for tax enforcement litigation. Even where the BIR has a clear statutory interest in prosecuting violations of the Tax Code, criminal appeals that affect the State’s right to prosecute must still comply with the rules on OSG representation, control, supervision, and deputation. Failure to observe those procedural requirements may independently jeopardize the government’s appeal.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers
First, taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should immediately examine the timeline. The relevant dates include the taxable year involved, discovery or accrual of the alleged offense, referral for preliminary investigation, filing of the complaint, filing of the Information, and any appeal or motion filed by the government. A prescription defense can be decisive if the Information was filed too late.
Second, corporate officers should not assume that a criminal tax case is valid simply because the BIR or prosecution has already initiated proceedings. The Court may still dismiss the case if the government’s right to prosecute has prescribed or if the appeal was pursued without proper authority.
Third, businesses should preserve assessment records, protest documents, notices, receipts, and communications with the BIR and DOJ. These documents may establish the timeline needed to challenge a delayed prosecution or to show that the government’s theory of interruption is unsupported.
Finally, the ruling shows that motions for reconsideration in tax litigation must do more than repeat previously rejected arguments. Where the court has already passed upon the legal issue and no new matter is raised, reconsideration is unlikely to succeed.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, importers, and business owners in tax assessments, criminal tax investigations, preliminary investigations, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review prescription defenses, assess exposure of responsible officers, prepare pleadings, coordinate defense strategy, and represent clients in disputes involving the BIR, DOJ, and the Court of Tax Appeals.
If your company or officers are facing a tax assessment, criminal tax complaint, or delayed prosecution, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on tax litigation, criminal tax defense, and Court of Tax Appeals strategy.