CTA upholds acquittal of driver Victor Gaw Sy; individuals not owners or importers cannot be held liable for excise taxes on untaxed cigarettes.
Taxpayers and logistics operators can take note: individuals who are merely drivers or custodians of goods cannot automatically be held liable for excise taxes unless they are proven to be owners or importers of the taxable items. Recent Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) guidance confirms that civil liability for excise taxes does not extend to individuals without statutory responsibility.
Background
The case involved Victor Gaw Sy, who was charged with violation of Section 263 of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) of 1997, as amended. The government contended that he possessed imported cigarettes without payment of excise tax. The CTA acquitted him in its initial decision dated January 15, 2025 (CTA CRIM. CASE NO. O-1050), holding that he was merely the driver of the vehicle transporting the cigarettes and that there was no evidence establishing ownership or importation responsibilities. The People of the Philippines filed a Motion for Reconsideration, arguing that he should remain civilly liable for the excise taxes and asserting that the search of the vehicle was valid and reasonable
CTA 1st Division Resolution on โฆ
CTA 1st Division Resolution on โฆ
.
CTA’s Ruling
The CTA denied the motion for reconsideration, reinforcing that a judgment of acquittal cannot be disturbed unless there is evidence of grave abuse of discretion or a mistrial. The Court emphasized the constitutional protection against double jeopardy, citing the Supreme Court’s ruling in Antonio Lejano v. People of the Philippines, which restricts reconsideration of acquittals to exceptional circumstances
CTA 1st Division Resolution on โฆ
.
Additionally, the CTA clarified that possession alone, without knowledge of the contents or ownership, cannot establish civil liability for excise taxes. Evidence showed that Gaw Sy was only the driver of the Foton van, with no knowledge of the untaxed cigarettes inside. As the excise tax obligation under Section 131 of the NIRC falls on the owner, importer, or statutory transferee, liability could not be imposed on a mere custodian
CTA 1st Division Resolution on โฆ
CTA 1st Division Resolution on โฆ
.
Key Legal Principles
The CTA reaffirmed several principles critical for taxpayers and importers:
1. Excise tax liability is statutory: Only owners, importers, or designated transferees may be held responsible for excise taxes.
2. Double jeopardy limits government actions: Once acquitted, a person cannot be retried or reassessed for the same underlying act unless exceptional circumstances exist.
3. Probable cause must be substantiated: Arguments asserting searches were valid do not override the requirement to identify the statutory taxpayer.
4. Civil liability is distinct from criminal acquittal: Even if a criminal conviction were possible, civil tax obligations still require competent evidence establishing statutory responsibility.
Practical Takeaways
Logistics companies, drivers, and independent couriers should note that simply transporting goods without being owners or importers does not trigger excise tax liability. Companies should ensure clear documentation identifying the statutory owner or importer of excisable items and train drivers to understand their limited responsibilities. Likewise, tax authorities and prosecutors must establish statutory ownership or importation when seeking civil liability for excise taxes.
For businesses, this decision underscores the importance of internal controls and documentation to clearly differentiate between agents, drivers, and statutory taxpayers for tax compliance purposes. Merely being in possession or transporting untaxed goods is insufficient to hold an individual liable.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Our tax litigation team advises clients on mitigating potential civil and criminal exposure under the NIRC, ensuring proper risk allocation, and defending against improper assessments. For guidance on excise tax obligations, driver liability, or contesting unreasonable claims, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our experienced attorneys.